Abstract
Electroreduction of $CO_2$ to valuable multicarbon ($C_{2+}$) products is a highly attractive way to utilize and divert emitted $CO_2$. However, a major fraction of $C_{2+}$ selectivity is confined to less than 90% by the difficulty of coupling C-C bonds efficiently. Herein, we identify the stable $Cu^0/Cu^{2+}$ interfaces derived from copper phosphate-based (CuPO) electrocatalysts, which can facilitate $C_{2+}$ production with a low-energy pathway of OC-CHO coupling verified by in situ spectra studies and theoretical calculations. The CuPO precatalyst shows a high Faradaic efficiency (FE) of 69.7% towards $C_2H_4$ in an H-cell, and exhibits a significant $FE_{C2+}$ of 90.9% under industrially relevant current density ($j$ = -350 mA $cm^{-2}$) in a flow cell configuration. The stable $Cu^0/Cu^{2+}$ interface breaks new ground for the structural design of electrocatalysts and the construction of synergistic active sites to improve the activity and selectivity of valuable $C_{2+}$ products.
Introduction
Converting $CO_2$ into multicarbon products ($C_{2+}$) via electroreduction (CO2RR) is a cornerstone of the "circular carbon economy." While copper (Cu) is the only metal capable of producing these fuels at scale, the process is plagued by a difficult C-C bond-coupling step. Most state-of-the-art catalysts rely on a $Cu^0/Cu^{1+}$ interface. However, these typically struggle to exceed 90% selectivity, especially at high current densities. While theoretical models suggest that $Cu^{2+}$ sites could facilitate better coupling pathways, $Cu^{2+}$ is notoriously unstable under the harsh reducing conditions of electrolysis, usually reverting quickly to metallic $Cu^0$. This research addresses the challenge of stabilizing $Cu^{2+}$ and demonstrating its role in improving reaction selectivity.
Methods and Materials
The study combined high-throughput computational screening with advanced operando characterization. The Materials Project Database was used to screen 83 copper-containing compounds, filtering for thermodynamic and electrochemical stability based on formation energy ($E_f$), energy above the convex hull ($E_{hull}$), and dissolution potential ($U_{diss}$).
Copper phosphate-based catalysts ($Cu_3(PO_4)_2$ and $Cu_2P_2O_7$, collectively termed CuPO) were synthesized via a scalable precipitation and calcination method. To monitor the oxidation state of Cu during the reaction, operando X-ray Absorption Fine Structure (XAFS) and in situ Raman spectroscopy were employed. Mechanistic insights were gained through Surface-Enhanced Infrared Absorption Spectroscopy (SEIRAS) paired with Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations to map the energy barriers of different carbon-coupling pathways.
Results and Discussion
The Phosphate "Anchor" and $Cu^{2+}$ Stability
A key discovery was the role of the phosphate group ($PO_4^{3-}$) in stabilizing oxygen atoms. This prevents the complete reduction of $Cu^{2+}$ to $Cu^0$, maintaining a stable synergistic interface even at high negative potentials. This stability is crucial, as $Cu^{2+}$ sites are shown to be essential for the formation of key intermediates.
The OC-CHO Coupling Pathway
Traditionally, C-C coupling occurs via CO-CO dimerization. However, this study identifies a lower-energy "OC-CHO" shortcut. DFT calculations reveal that $Cu^{2+}$ sites significantly lower the Gibbs free energy for the hydrogenation of adsorbed CO (CO) into a formyl intermediate (CHO) compared to $Cu^0$ or $Cu^{1+}$ sites.
As shown in Figure 1, the formation of CHO is thermodynamically much more favorable on $Cu^{2+}$. This CHO intermediate then couples with a neighboring *CO adsorbed on a $Cu^0$ site at the interface.
The OC-CHO coupling barrier was calculated to be only 0.46 eV, which is notably lower than the 0.54 eV required for standard CO-CO dimerization on pure copper surfaces. This synergistic mechanism at the interface (Figure 5) is the primary driver for the enhanced selectivity.
Electrocatalytic Performance
In a flow cell configuration using alkaline electrolyte, the CuPO catalyst achieved a Faradaic Efficiency ($FE_{C2+}$) of 90.9% at a current density of -350 mA $cm^{-2}$. In a standard H-cell, the catalyst showed a high FE of 69.7% specifically for ethylene ($C_2H_4$). The $C_{2+}/C_1$ product ratio for CuPO was approximately 12.4, vastly outperforming standard CuO control samples (ratio of ~1.5). The $Cu^0/Cu^{2+}$ interface remained robust for at least 18 hours of continuous operation.
Conclusion and Future Outlook
The identification of a stable $Cu^0/Cu^{2+}$ interface provides a new strategy for designing high-performance CO2RR catalysts. While the 18-hour stability is promising, industrial applications will require catalysts that can last thousands of hours. Future research should focus on the long-term degradation mechanisms of the phosphate framework and adapting this interface for use in membrane electrode assemblies (MEAs) or acidic electrolytes to mitigate carbonate formation. Additionally, further tuning of the interface could help in narrowing the product distribution to favor specific high-value liquid products.
Summary updated