Direct observation of charge density wave order at zero magnetic field in ortho-II YBa$_2$Cu$_3$O$_{6.54}$

E. Blackburn, Joon‐Hyuk Chang, M. Hücker, A. T. Holmes, N. B. Christensen, Ruixing Liang, D. A. Bonn, W. N. Hardy, M. v. Zimmermann, E. M. Forgan, S. M. HaydenarXiv 2012 · arXiv

Introduction

The nature of the "pseudogap" phase in high-temperature cuprate superconductors remains one of the most significant challenges in condensed matter physics. A central question is whether electronic "orders," such as Charge Density Waves (CDWs)—periodic ripples in electron density—compete with superconductivity in this regime. While CDWs have been observed in several cuprates, their presence in the highly ordered "ortho-II" phase of $YBa_2Cu_3O_y$ (YBCO) at zero magnetic field was long suspected but not directly proven. This study utilizes high-energy X-ray diffraction to provide the first direct evidence of CDW order in ortho-II YBCO ($y \approx 6.54$) and explores how its symmetry is dictated by the material's internal oxygen structure.

Experimental Approach

To probe the bulk properties of the crystal, the researchers employed high-energy (100 keV) X-ray diffraction at the BW5 beamline of the DORIS storage ring (DESY). Unlike standard X-rays, which are surface-sensitive, 100 keV photons penetrate the entire sample, ensuring that the observed electronic modulations are representative of the bulk material. The team used high-quality, ~99% detwinned single crystals of YBCO in three phases: ortho-II ($y=6.54$), ortho-VIII ($y=6.67$), and ortho-III ($y=6.75$). Detwinning was essential to distinguish between the a and b crystallographic axes, allowing for a precise determination of the CDW's dimensionality.

Symmetry and Oxygen Ordering

A key finding of this work is the distinct symmetry of the CDW in the ortho-II phase compared to other YBCO variants. In ortho-VIII and ortho-III samples, the CDW is "2-q," characterized by modulations along both the a and b axes. In contrast, the ortho-II phase exhibits a "1-q" state, where periodic ripples in electron density occur exclusively along the b-axis—the direction of the perfectly ordered oxygen chains.

Diffraction scans along the a-axis (h) and b-axis (k) for ortho-II YBCO. The presence of a peak only along the k-direction at 65 K (red circles) confirms the 1-q symmetry of the CDW.

This observation suggests that the high degree of oxygen chain ordering in ortho-II suppresses the CDW along the a-axis. Furthermore, the CDW wavevector was identified at $q_{CDW} = (0, 0.329, 0.5)$, with lattice displacements primarily occurring along the c-axis, involving oxygen atoms in the $CuO_2$ bilayers.

Temperature Evolution and Superconductivity

The study also characterized the temperature dependence of the CDW order. The onset temperature ($T_{CDW}$) for ortho-II was found to be approximately 155 K, which is higher than the onset temperatures observed in more heavily doped samples (~140 K). This trend aligns with other pseudogap signatures, such as the Kerr effect, suggesting a common physical origin.

Temperature dependence of the CDW intensity. Panel (c) illustrates the onset of CDW order at T_CDW and its subsequent suppression as the material enters the superconducting state below T_c.

As shown in the temperature-dependent scans, the CDW intensity increases as the temperature drops toward the superconducting transition temperature ($T_c$), but it is notably suppressed once superconductivity sets in. This competition highlights the antagonistic relationship between these two collective electronic states.

Discussion and Outlook

The discovery of a 1-q CDW in ortho-II YBCO at zero field provides a crucial piece of the puzzle regarding electronic order in cuprates. It demonstrates that the underlying crystal lattice and oxygen stoichiometry play a decisive role in shaping the symmetry of electronic modulations. While these zero-field results show a 1-q state, they contrast with high-field NMR and ultrasound data that suggest a 2-q state may emerge at very high magnetic fields (above ~18 T). This discrepancy implies that magnetic fields might "lock" the system into a different symmetry or induce a secondary modulation, a possibility that warrants further investigation with high-field X-ray diffraction techniques.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{blackburn2012direct,
  author = {E. Blackburn and Joon‐Hyuk Chang and M. Hücker and A. T. Holmes and N. B. Christensen and Ruixing Liang and D. A. Bonn and W. N. Hardy and M. v. Zimmermann and E. M. Forgan and S. M. Hayden},
  title = {{Direct observation of charge density wave order at zero magnetic field in ortho-II YBa$\_2$Cu$\_3$O$\_\{6.54\}$}},
  year = {2012},
  eprint = {1212.3836},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1212.3836},
}
Figure