Direct observation of 3D atomic packing in monatomic amorphous materials

Yakun Yuan, Dennis Kim, Jihan Zhou, Dillan J. Chang, Fan Zhu, Yasutaka Nagaoka, Yao Yang, Minh Phạm, Stanley Osher, Ou Chen, Peter Ercius, Andreas K. Schmid, Jianwei MiaoarXiv 2020 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Liquids and solids are two fundamental states of matter. However, due to the lack of direct experimental determination, our understanding of the 3D atomic structure of liquids and amorphous solids remained speculative. Here we advance atomic electron tomography to determine for the first time the 3D atomic positions in monatomic amorphous materials, including a Ta thin film and two Pd nanoparticles. We observe that pentagonal bipyramids are the most abundant atomic motifs in these amorphous materials. Instead of forming icosahedra, the majority of pentagonal bipyramids arrange into networks that extend to medium-range scale. Molecular dynamic simulations further reveal that pentagonal bipyramid networks are prevalent in monatomic amorphous liquids, which rapidly grow in size and form icosahedra during the quench from the liquid state to glass state. The experimental method and results are expected to advance the study of the amorphous-crystalline phase transition and glass transition at the single-atom level.

Introduction

While the atomic structure of crystalline solids—defined by neat, repeating lattices—has been well-understood for over a century, the internal architecture of liquids and amorphous solids (like glass) has remained a structural mystery. Because these materials lack long-range order, traditional characterization tools such as X-ray or electron diffraction only provide statistical averages, such as pair distribution functions (PDFs). They cannot pinpoint the specific 3D coordinates of individual atoms.

For decades, scientists relied on speculative models to describe this "disordered" state. In 1952, physicist F.C. Frank hypothesized that "icosahedral order"—groups of 12 atoms surrounding a central one—was the dominant motif in liquids. However, without a method to directly observe the atoms, confirming how these materials are truly packed was impossible. This study bridges that gap, providing the first literal 3D map of the amorphous atomic landscape.

Methodology: Atomic Electron Tomography

To map the amorphous structure, the research team utilized Atomic Electron Tomography (AET). By taking a series of 2D images of samples at various tilt angles using a Scanning Transmission Electron Microscope (STEM) in annular dark-field mode, they were able to reconstruct the 3D volume.

The technical breakthrough relied on several key components:

  • RESIRE Algorithm: A novel real-space iterative reconstruction algorithm was developed to handle the unique challenges of thin-film geometry, where different tilt angles capture varying volumes of material.
  • Coordinate Refinement: Following reconstruction, individual atomic positions were traced and refined with a precision of 18 picometers—approximately 1/10th the diameter of a typical atom.
  • Voronoi Tessellation: This mathematical method was used to characterize the local "neighborhood" around each atom, allowing the team to identify specific geometric motifs like tetrahedra and bipyramids.

The experimental data encompassed three primary samples: an amorphous Tantalum (Ta) thin film (8,284 atoms) and two amorphous Palladium (Pd) nanoparticles (52,308 and 76,238 atoms).

Key Insights: The Pentagonal Bipyramid Network

The study's most significant finding challenges the long-held icosahedral hypothesis. While icosahedra are often cited as the fundamental unit of amorphous packing, the experimental data revealed that pentagonal bipyramids (two atoms "capping" a five-atom ring) are far more abundant.

Medium-Range Order and Geometric Frustration

These bipyramids do not exist in isolation. Instead, they link by sharing edges to form Pentagonal Bipyramid Networks (PBNs). These networks extend to a "medium-range" scale (up to ~2.8 nm), providing a hidden, organized architecture within the apparent chaos of the amorphous solid.

The researchers identified "geometric frustration" as the reason these structures do not simply form icosahedra. The dihedral angles between these bipyramids are roughly 120°, whereas a perfect icosahedron requires an angle of 116.57°. This small discrepancy prevents the bipyramids from easily closing into icosahedral clusters, forcing them instead into extended, disordered networks.

Quenching and Density

To complement the experimental findings, the team conducted Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations of bulk Ta and Pd being quenched from a liquid state (5200 K) to a metallic glass state (300 K). The simulations revealed that PBNs are prevalent even in the liquid state. As the liquid cools, these networks rapidly grow in size and only then begin to assemble into full icosahedra. Furthermore, the study established a direct link between local packing and mass: regions with higher "polytetrahedral" packing (like PBNs) exhibited significantly higher local mass density.

Conclusion

By achieving 96.8% tetrahedral packing in the observed samples, the study proves that amorphous materials are far from random. The 3D models were so accurate that their calculated PDFs perfectly matched experimental electron diffraction data.

This ability to map 3D atomic positions in non-crystalline materials opens new avenues for studying the physics of jamming, quasicrystals, and the glass transition. By moving from a statistical understanding of disorder to a deterministic, atom-by-atom map, researchers can now explore the amorphous-crystalline phase transition with unprecedented clarity.

Summary updated

Abstract

Liquids and solids are two fundamental states of matter. However, due to the lack of direct experimental determination, our understanding of the 3D atomic structure of liquids and amorphous solids remained speculative. Here we advance atomic electron tomography to determine for the first time the 3D atomic positions in monatomic amorphous materials, including a Ta thin film and two Pd nanoparticles. We observe that pentagonal bipyramids are the most abundant atomic motifs in these amorphous materials. Instead of forming icosahedra, the majority of pentagonal bipyramids arrange into networks that extend to medium-range scale. Molecular dynamic simulations further reveal that pentagonal bipyramid networks are prevalent in monatomic amorphous liquids, which rapidly grow in size and form icosahedra during the quench from the liquid state to glass state. The experimental method and results are expected to advance the study of the amorphous-crystalline phase transition and glass transition at the single-atom level.
BibTeX
@misc{yuan2020direct,
  author = {Yakun Yuan and Dennis Kim and Jihan Zhou and Dillan J. Chang and Fan Zhu and Yasutaka Nagaoka and Yao Yang and Minh Phạm and Stanley Osher and Ou Chen and Peter Ercius and Andreas K. Schmid and Jianwei Miao},
  title = {{Direct observation of 3D atomic packing in monatomic amorphous materials}},
  year = {2020},
  eprint = {2007.03881},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2007.03881},
}
Figure