TL;DR
This study directly measures the swimming speeds and metabolic rates of shortfin mako sharks using advanced bio-loggers. The findings reveal mako sharks are high-speed "energy speculators" capable of impressive bursts, but this performance may make them vulnerable to climate change impacts like ocean deoxygenation.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The shortfin mako shark ( Isurus oxyrinchus) is known for its speed and high energy demands, suggesting it's a top predator with significant energetic needs. However, direct measurements of their swimming speeds in their natural environment are scarce. This lack of data makes it difficult to understand their ecological role, how they interact with their environment, and their vulnerability to threats like climate change. Existing estimates often rely on indirect methods, which can be less precise. This paper aims to fill this gap by providing direct, in-situ measurements of mako shark swimming speeds, kinematics, and thermal physiology, and using this data to estimate their field metabolic rate.
Methods
The researchers employed sophisticated animal-borne bio-logging tags attached to two shortfin mako sharks. These tags were equipped with:
- Tri-axial accelerometers and magnetometers: To record fine-scale 3D movements and body orientation.
- Speed sensors: To directly measure swimming speed (though one shark's speed was estimated from tail-beat frequency).
- Pressure and temperature sensors: To record depth and ambient water temperature.
- Internal temperature sensors: To measure white muscle temperature, providing insights into physiological responses.
- GPS units: For tag recovery.
The data from these sensors were analyzed to determine:
- Swimming speeds: Both sustained (cruising) and maximum (burst) speeds.
- Tail-beat frequency (TBF): A key indicator of swimming effort.
- Kinematics: Including pitch and roll angles to understand body posture during movement.
- Internal muscle temperature: To assess the thermal impact of different behaviors.
- Field Metabolic Rate (FMR): Estimated using a method adapted from previous studies, relating swimming speed to oxygen consumption.
A novel aspect was the direct measurement of swimming speed using a calibrated speed sensor, combined with detailed kinematic and thermal data, allowing for a more holistic understanding of the shark's energetic expenditure.
Datasets
The study utilized data collected from two tagged shortfin mako sharks (S1, a female, and S2, a male) over deployment durations of approximately 16 and 36 hours, respectively. The data collected included:
- High-resolution accelerometry, speed, pressure, and temperature data.
- Internal white muscle temperature data.
The FMR estimation also incorporated data from previous respirometry studies on juvenile mako sharks (Sepulveda et al., 2007) and length-weight relationship data for Atlantic mako sharks.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Mako Sharks as "Energy Speculators": The high cruising speeds and impressive burst capabilities suggest makos are "energy speculators," prioritizing rapid movement and energy acquisition, similar to tunas and other endothermic fish.
- Gliding as an Energy Recovery Mechanism: Gliding behavior (zero tail-beat frequency) was frequently observed after periods of high activity, particularly when internal muscle temperatures were elevated. This suggests gliding serves as a crucial energy recovery strategy and helps manage heat production.
- Vulnerability to Climate Change: The species' reliance on high-speed performance and high oxygen demand makes it potentially vulnerable to ocean deoxygenation and warming, which could impair their ability to hunt and recover from exertion.
- Direct Measurement Value: This study highlights the importance of direct, in-situ measurements for understanding the true energetic costs and behavioral strategies of large pelagic predators, as indirect estimates can be misleading.
Key Results
- Cruising Speed: Mean sustained (cruising) speed was 0.90 m s⁻¹ (±0.07 s.d.).
- Maximum Burst Speed: A maximum burst speed of 5.02 m s⁻¹ was recorded in a 2m female shark.
- Burst Duration: Burst swimming was sustained for an average of 14 seconds, with a mean speed of 2.38 m s⁻¹.
- Muscle Temperature Increase: A single burst event led to a 0.24°C increase in white muscle temperature within 12.5 minutes post-burst.
- Routine Field Metabolic Rate (FMR): Estimated at 185.2 mg O₂ kg⁻¹ h⁻¹ at 18°C ambient temperature.
- Gliding Behavior: Gliding was prevalent, particularly during descents, and was more common in the initial hours post-tagging, suggesting a role in recovery from capture stress.
Limitations and Future Work
- Small Sample Size: The study was conducted on only two individuals, which limits the ability to capture the full range of variability within the species. Future work should involve more deployments to better understand population-level behaviors and energetics.
- Tag Impact: The authors acknowledge that the presence of fin-mounted tags and their associated drag might have influenced the maximum speeds achievable by the tagged animals.
- Anaerobic Metabolism: The FMR estimation method primarily captures aerobic metabolism. The high-speed bursts likely involve anaerobic pathways, which are not fully accounted for in the current FMR estimates. Future research could explore methods to better quantify anaerobic contributions.
- Climate Change Impact: While the study suggests vulnerability to climate change, further research is needed to fully understand how warming temperatures and deoxygenation will specifically impact mako shark swimming kinematics, energy expenditure, and habitat use.
- Ontogenetic Shifts: The study did not explore potential ontogenetic shifts in swimming speeds, which have been observed in other large shark species. This is an area for future investigation.
Summary updated