Direct Germline Transformation of Cotton Meristem Explants With No Selection

Yurong Chen, Andrea Lange, Zarir Vaghchhipawala, Xudong Ye, Annie SaltarikosFrontiers in Plant Science 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Regenerating transgenic plants without selectable markers (SMs) simplifies the development of trait-stacked products and addresses regulatory concerns. While 2 T-DNA systems are common for creating marker-free plants, they often suffer from low efficiency. This study demonstrates a "no selection" transformation system in cotton using Agrobacterium inoculation of seed meristem explants. By screening regenerated shoots via GUS histochemical assays, researchers achieved a germline transformation frequency of 0.2%–0.7%, comparable to traditional selection-based methods. This approach offers a viable alternative for generating marker-free transgenic cotton and improving the transformation pipeline.

Introduction: The Challenge of Selectable Markers

The creation of transgenic crops typically relies on selectable markers (SMs)—genes conferring resistance to antibiotics or herbicides—to identify transformed cells. However, SMs present significant hurdles:

  1. Trait Stacking: A limited pool of effective SMs restricts the number of traits that can be sequentially added to a plant.
  2. Regulatory and Public Acceptance: Removing marker genes is often preferred for streamlined regulatory approval and broader public acceptance.
  3. Efficiency Issues: Existing marker-free techniques, such as the 2 T-DNA system, are often inefficient due to the frequent co-integration of the gene of interest (GOI) and the marker gene.

Cotton is particularly challenging due to its recalcitrance in tissue culture and long transformation cycles.

Methodology: Transformation Without Selection

Researchers at Bayer Crop Science targeted the meristem (the growing tip) of cotton seeds using Agrobacterium-mediated transformation.

Vector Design

The team utilized the binary vector pMON114908, which contains a GUS reporter gene and an aadA (spectinomycin resistance) gene. Notably, although the vector contained a resistance gene, no selective agents were used during the regeneration process.

T-DNA structure of pMON114908 used for transformation.

Regeneration and Screening

Instead of using chemicals to eliminate non-transformed cells, all shoots were allowed to regenerate. This created a large population of shoots that were subsequently screened for the "needle in the haystack"—rare transgenic events—using GUS histochemical assays.

Regenerated cotton shoots from meristem explants.

Stable integration and germline transmission were validated in the T1 progeny through segregation analysis and Southern blots.

Key Results and Insights

The study involved seven independent experiments, screening a total of 4,667 individual cotton shoots.

  • Transformation Frequency: 50 GUS-positive T0 plants were identified (1.1% putative frequency). The final germline transformation frequency ranged from 0.16% to 0.71%, matching the efficiency of traditional selection-based meristem transformation.
  • Speed: Bypassing the selection phase significantly accelerated regeneration. Transgenic plants reached the soil within 4 weeks, compared to the 8–9 weeks required in traditional protocols.
  • Germline vs. Epidermal Transformation: Approximately 67% of initial GUS-positive plants were "epidermal" transformations, where the transgene was restricted to the outer layer and not passed to offspring. This underscores the importance of targeting the L2/L3 cell layers for stable inheritance.
  • Inheritance Patterns: 70% of germline events followed Mendelian segregation (1 or 2 functional loci), confirming stable DNA integration.

Limitations and Future Directions

The primary drawback of this "no selection" system is the labor-intensive nature of screening thousands of shoots manually. To make this commercially viable, high-throughput, non-destructive screening methods are essential. The authors suggest implementing molecular tests like Recombinase Polymerase Amplification (RPA) or CRISPR-based detection (SHERLOCK) to identify transgenic shoots more efficiently. Further optimization of wounding techniques, such as sonication, may also improve the rate of deep-tissue transformation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Regeneration of transgenic plants without selectable markers can facilitate the development and commercialization of trait stacking products. A wide range of strategies have been developed to eliminate selectable markers to produce marker-free transgenic plants. The most widely used marker free approach is probably the <i>Agrobacterium</i>-based 2 T-DNA strategy where the gene-of-interest (GOI) and selectable marker gene are delivered from independent T-DNAs (Darbani et al., 2007). The selectable marker gene is segregated away from the GOI in subsequent generations. However, the efficiency of this 2 T-DNA system is much less than the traditional 1 T-DNA system due to the inefficiency of T-DNA co-transformation and high rate of con-integration between the GOI and selectable marker gene T-DNAs. In contrast, no selection transformation utilizes a single T-DNA carrying the GOI and thus eliminates the need to remove the selectable marker insert and potentially provides a viable alternative marker-free system. In this study, we reported the successful regeneration of transgenic cotton plants through <i>Agrobacterium</i> inoculation of seed meristem explants without the use of selective agents. Regeneration of putative transgenic plants were identified by GUS histo-chemical assay. The germline transmission of transgene to progeny was determined by segregation of pollen grains, immature embryos and T1 plants by GUS expression. The results were further confirmed by Southern analyses. The marker-free transformation frequency in this no selection system was similar to current meristem transformation system with selection (0.2%-0.7%). The strategy for further improvement of this system and its implication in improving cotton transformation pipeline and in developing transgene-free genome editing technology is discussed.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2020direct,
  author = {Yurong Chen and Andrea Lange and Zarir Vaghchhipawala and Xudong Ye and Annie Saltarikos},
  title = {{Direct Germline Transformation of Cotton Meristem Explants With No Selection}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Plant Science},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3389/fpls.2020.575283},
}

Loading related content...

Figure