Abstract
We have combined single-crystal neutron and x-ray diffractions to investigate the magnetic and crystal structures of the honeycomb lattice Na${}_{2}$IrO${}_{3}$. The system orders magnetically below $18.1(2)$ K with Ir${}^{4+}$ ions forming zigzag spin chains within the layered honeycomb network with an ordered moment of $0.22(1){\ensuremath{\mu}}_{\text{B}}/\text{Ir}$ site. Such a configuration sharply contrasts with the N'eel or stripe states proposed in the Kitaev-Heisenberg model. The structure refinement reveals that the Ir atoms form a nearly ideal two-dimensional honeycomb lattice while the IrO${}_{6}$ octahedra experience a trigonal distortion that is critical to the ground state. The results of this study provide much needed experimental insights into the magnetic and crystal structure that are crucial to the understanding of the exotic magnetic order and possible topological characteristics in the $5d$-electron-based honeycomb lattice.
Introduction
In the search for exotic quantum states such as spin liquids and topological insulators, $5d$-based transition metal oxides, particularly iridates, have emerged as primary candidates. In these materials, the heavy iridium atoms generate significant spin-orbit coupling (SOC) that competes with electron-electron repulsion. This competition can potentially realize the Kitaev model, which predicts a quantum spin liquid on a honeycomb lattice. However, experimental verification has been challenging. For $\text{Na}_2\text{IrO}_3$, previous studies on powder samples left questions regarding exact crystal symmetry and low-temperature spin alignment, with theoretical models predicting either Néel or stripe magnetic phases. This study addresses these gaps using high-quality single-crystal data.
Methods
The primary challenge in studying iridium compounds with neutrons is the high absorption cross-section of iridium. To overcome this, the researchers grew thin single crystals (~0.1 mm) using a self-flux method, allowing sufficient neutron penetration.
- Neutron Diffraction: Conducted at Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) using HB1A and HB3A spectrometers to map magnetic order.
- X-ray Diffraction: Used to refine the crystal structure and determine the $C2/m$ space group.
- Thermodynamic Characterization: Specific heat and EDX measurements confirmed the magnetic transition temperature ($T_N$) and chemical purity.
Results and Discussion
The investigation revealed that $\text{Na}_2\text{IrO}_3$ orders magnetically at $T_N = 18.1(2)$ K. The crystal structure belongs to the $C2/m$ space group, featuring a nearly ideal 2D honeycomb lattice of Ir atoms.
A key finding is the presence of a "zigzag" magnetic ground state, rather than the previously predicted stripe or Néel phases. This was confirmed by measuring magnetic scattering at specific wave vectors. For instance, the absence of signal at $\mathbf{q}_3 = (0, 3, 0.5)$ ruled out the stripe phase, while the observed intensities matched the zigzag configuration.
The $\text{IrO}_6$ octahedra exhibit a trigonal distortion, with O-Ir-O bond angles of $84.1^\circ$ and $84.5^\circ$ deviating from the ideal $90^\circ$. This distortion is critical as it narrows the energy gap between quantum levels, likely stabilizing the zigzag order. Furthermore, the measured magnetic moment of $0.22(1) \mu_B/\text{Ir}$ is significantly smaller than the $1 \mu_B$ expected for a pure spin-1/2 system, indicating strong hybridization between Ir $5d$ and O $2p$ orbitals.
Conclusion
The discovery of the zigzag magnetic state in $\text{Na}_2\text{IrO}_3$ suggests that the standard Kitaev-Heisenberg model requires refinement, possibly by including further-neighbor interactions or more detailed crystal field effects. While stacking faults were noted in the crystals, the overall results provide a definitive benchmark for the magnetic and structural properties of this honeycomb lattice material, guiding future efforts to tune these systems toward spin-liquid phases.
Summary updated