Direct Digital Subtractive Manufacturing of a Functional Assembly Using Voxel-Based Models

Roby Lynn, Mahmoud Dinar, Nuodi Huang, James S. Collins, Jing Yu, Clayton M. Greer, Tommy Tucker, Thomas R. KurfessJournal of Manufacturing Science and Engineering 2017 · DOI

Abstract

Direct digital manufacturing (DDM) typically leverages additive manufacturing (AM) to create complex, "nonassembly" mechanisms directly from CAD models. While AM offers geometric freedom, subtractive manufacturing (SM) provides superior material strength and isotropy. However, SM process planning for internal geometries is traditionally difficult. This paper presents a voxel-based computer-aided manufacturing (CAM) system that enables Direct Digital Subtractive Manufacturing (DDSM). By treating material removal as a voxel-by-voxel process, the system automates toolpath generation and collision avoidance. The approach is validated through the successful fabrication of a functional ball-in-socket mechanism from a single aluminum block.

Introduction

The rise of 3D printing has popularized the concept of "nonassembly" mechanisms—complex devices that function immediately after fabrication without manual assembly. While Additive Manufacturing (AM) excels here, the resulting parts often suffer from material anisotropy and lower strength. Subtractive Manufacturing (SM), such as 5-axis CNC milling, produces high-performance isotropic parts but faces significant hurdles in process planning for intricate internal features. Traditional surface-based (B-rep) CAM software struggles with the computational cost of collision checking in tight, complex spaces. This research introduces a voxel-based approach to bridge this gap, aiming for "push-button" CNC machining of functional assemblies.

Voxel-Based CAM and Data Structures

The core of this DDSM system is the shift from surface models to voxel-based representations. Using a custom CAM system called SculptPrint, the part is represented as a grid of 3D pixels (voxels). To manage memory and computational efficiency, these voxels are organized in a Hybrid Dynamic Tree (HDT).

Voxel representation using a Hybrid Dynamic Tree (HDT) to define surfaces and internal volumes.

This structure allows for rapid spatial queries, which are essential for the "reverse additive" logic of subtractive manufacturing. Instead of calculating complex surface intersections, the system simply identifies which voxels to remove.

Automated Process Planning

To automate toolpath generation, the researchers employed morphological offsetting—an algorithm inspired by image processing. By "dilating" the part volume with a spherical structuring element representing the tool tip, the system generates a safe "contact volume."

A 3D model of a ball-in-socket mechanism showing tool accessibility for internal machining.

For every point along the toolpath, the system generates binary accessibility maps to determine safe tool orientations. This allows the 5-axis machine to reach deep into crevices while automatically avoiding collisions between the tool, the part, and the machine itself. GPU acceleration makes these high-density voxel operations feasible in real-time.

Results and Validation

The system was tested by machining a functional ball-in-socket joint from 6061-T6 aluminum. Unlike AM, where supports counteract gravity, DDSM uses tiny 1mm support tabs to resist the mechanical thrust of the machine and prevent internal components from vibrating or falling out during the final cuts.

Key findings include:

  • Support Efficiency: The machined part required only 0.06% support material by mass, compared to 5-20% for FDM 3D-printed versions.
  • Predictive Accuracy: The voxel approach provides a "What-You-See-Is-What-You-Get" simulation, accurately predicting toolmarks and scallops.
  • Functional Success: The automated orientation selection successfully navigated low-accessibility regions to produce a moving assembly from a solid block.

Conclusion

This research demonstrates that voxel-based modeling can bring the automation of additive manufacturing to the high-performance domain of subtractive manufacturing. While challenges remain—such as CNC controller bottlenecks when processing massive numbers of tiny voxel-based movements—the DDSM approach opens new doors for creating high-strength, complex functional assemblies without the need for manual assembly.

Summary updated

Abstract

Direct digital manufacturing (DDM) is the creation of a physical part directly from a computer-aided design (CAD) model with minimal process planning and is typically applied to additive manufacturing (AM) processes to fabricate complex geometry. AM is preferred for DDM because of its minimal user input requirements; as a result, users can focus on exploiting other advantages of AM, such as the creation of intricate mechanisms that require no assembly after fabrication. Such assembly free mechanisms can be created using DDM during a single build process. In contrast, subtractive manufacturing (SM) enables the creation of higher strength parts that do not suffer from the material anisotropy inherent in AM. However, process planning for SM is more difficult than it is for AM due to geometric constraints imposed by the machining process; thus, the application of SM to the fabrication of assembly free mechanisms is challenging. This research describes a voxel-based computer-aided manufacturing (CAM) system that enables direct digital subtractive manufacturing (DDSM) of an assembly free mechanism. Process planning for SM involves voxel-by-voxel removal of material in the same way that an AM process consists of layer-by-layer addition of material. The voxelized CAM system minimizes user input by automatically generating toolpaths based on an analysis of accessible material to remove for a certain clearance in the mechanism's assembled state. The DDSM process is validated and compared to AM using case studies of the manufacture of two assembly free ball-in-socket mechanisms.
BibTeX
@article{lynn2017direct,
  author = {Roby Lynn and Mahmoud Dinar and Nuodi Huang and James S. Collins and Jing Yu and Clayton M. Greer and Tommy Tucker and Thomas R. Kurfess},
  title = {{Direct Digital Subtractive Manufacturing of a Functional Assembly Using Voxel-Based Models}},
  journal = {Journal of Manufacturing Science and Engineering},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1115/1.4037631},
}
Figure