Dirac Vs. Majorana Neutrino Masses From a TeV Interval

David Diego Castro, Mariano QuirosOpenReview 2025 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper explores a supersymmetric five-dimensional model to explain the origin of neutrino masses, specifically addressing whether neutrinos are Dirac or Majorana particles. They find that the nature of neutrino masses (Dirac or Majorana) depends on the alignment of certain parameters related to boundary conditions and bulk mass terms, while their smallness can be achieved through the localization of right-handed neutrinos or specific Yukawa couplings.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Standard Model of particle physics has long struggled to explain the origin of neutrino masses and their peculiar properties. Specifically, the question of whether neutrinos are Dirac fermions (like other fundamental fermions, requiring a mass term that conserves lepton number) or Majorana fermions (where the neutrino is its own antiparticle, allowing for lepton number violation) remains a crucial open problem. The "seesaw mechanism" is a popular theoretical framework to explain the lightness of neutrinos, but it often requires very high energy scales or extremely small couplings, pushing new physics beyond the reach of current experiments. This paper tackles these questions within the context of a supersymmetric five-dimensional (5D) model, aiming to provide a natural explanation for both the nature and the smallness of neutrino masses.

Methods

The authors employ a supersymmetric 5D model compactified on an interval. Key aspects of their methodology include:

  • Scherk-Schwarz Symmetry Breaking: Supersymmetry is broken via Scherk-Schwarz boundary conditions, which also influences electroweak symmetry breaking through radiative corrections.
  • Bulk and Boundary Fields: Gauge and Higgs fields propagate in the "bulk" of the 5D space, while quarks and leptons are localized on the "boundaries" of this interval. Right-handed neutrinos also propagate in the bulk with a mass term.
  • Variational Principle: The equations of motion and boundary conditions are derived using the variational principle applied to the 5D action.
  • Effective 4D Action: The 5D theory is reduced to an effective 4D theory by integrating out the extra dimension. This allows for the calculation of effective mass matrices for neutrinos.
  • Analysis of Mass Matrices: The authors analyze the eigenvalues of these effective mass matrices to determine whether they correspond to Dirac or Majorana masses and to estimate their magnitudes.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Nature of Neutrino Mass (Dirac vs. Majorana) is Determined by Boundary Conditions: The paper reveals that the fundamental nature of neutrino masses (whether they are Dirac or Majorana) is not fixed but depends crucially on the relative orientation of boundary terms (represented by a vector $\vec{s}$) and the bulk mass term (represented by a vector $\vec{p}$).
  • Generic Case: If $\vec{s}$ and $\vec{p}$ have arbitrary orientations, lepton number is violated, leading to Majorana neutrino masses.
  • Specific Case: If $\vec{s}$ and $\vec{p}$ are aligned (or anti-aligned), a conserved global U(1) symmetry emerges, preventing lepton number violation and resulting in Dirac neutrino masses. This is a significant insight, as it links a fundamental symmetry to the particle nature of neutrinos.
  • Small Neutrino Masses Achieved Through Localization: The smallness of neutrino masses (in the sub-eV range) can be naturally explained by:
  • Dirac Neutrinos: Exponential localization of the zero-mode of right-handed neutrinos towards the boundary opposite to where the Standard Model fermions are localized. This requires a specific bulk mass parameter $MR \sim 10$.
  • Majorana Neutrinos: Localizing quarks and leptons on different boundaries, leading to an exponential suppression of effective Yukawa couplings. This scenario can yield sub-eV masses with Yukawa couplings around $10^{-3}R$.
  • Perturbativity Maintained: The model maintains perturbativity up to its natural cutoff, even when achieving these small neutrino masses, which is a desirable feature for theoretical consistency.

Key Results

  • Dirac Neutrino Masses: Achieved when boundary and bulk mass parameters are aligned, leading to a conserved U(1) symmetry. Sub-eV masses are obtained when the right-handed neutrino zero-mode is localized away from the SM fermion brane, with $MR \sim 10$.
  • Majorana Neutrino Masses: Occur in the generic case of misaligned boundary and bulk mass parameters, violating lepton number. Sub-eV masses are obtained with Yukawa couplings around $10^{-3}R$ when quarks and leptons are on different boundaries.
  • Specific Parameter Alignments: For particular alignments of $\vec{s} \cdot \vec{p}$, cancellations can occur in the neutrino mass matrix, allowing for meV-scale masses even with large localizing masses and $MR \sim 10$.

Limitations and Future Work

  • "Solution" to Neutrino Mass Problem: The authors acknowledge that while their model provides a framework for generating realistic neutrino masses, it doesn't fundamentally explain the origin of the input parameters (like the bulk masses of right-handed neutrinos). A more fundamental theory (e.g., string theory) would be needed to determine these values.
  • Texture of RH Neutrino Masses: The paper suggests that the framework can be extended to describe the textures of right-handed neutrino masses and their mixing patterns, which would involve a parallel calculation of three-by-three mass matrices.
  • Experimental Signatures at LHC: The characteristic pattern of the supersymmetric spectrum predicted by this model could be experimentally identifiable at the LHC.
  • Fine-tuning: While the model aims for naturalness, some scenarios (particularly related to Higgs mass and electroweak symmetry breaking) might still involve a modest amount of fine-tuning, as noted in footnote 13.

Summary updated

Abstract

We investigate the nature (Dirac vs. Majorana) and size of left-handed neutrino masses in a supersymmetric five-dimensional model compactified in the interval $[0,\pi R]$, where quarks and leptons are localized on the boundaries while the gauge and Higgs sectors propagate in the bulk of the fifth dimension. Supersymmetry is broken by Scherk-Schwarz boundary conditions and electroweak breaking proceeds through radiative corrections. Right-handed neutrinos propagate in the bulk and have a general five-dimensional mass $M$, which localizes the zero modes towards one of the boundaries, and arbitrary boundary terms. We have found that for generic boundary terms left-handed neutrinos have Majorana masses. However for specific boundary configurations left-handed neutrinos are Dirac fermions as the theory possesses a conserved global $U(1)$ symmetry which prevents violation of lepton number. The size of neutrino masses depends on the localization of the zero-modes of right-handed neutrinos and/or the size of the five-dimensional neutrino Yukawa couplings. Left-handed neutrinos in the sub-eV range require either MR~10 or Yukawa couplings ~$10^{-3}R$, which make the five-dimensional theory perturbative up to its natural cutoff.
BibTeX
@misc{castro2025dirac,
  author = {David Diego Castro and Mariano Quiros},
  title = {{Dirac Vs. Majorana Neutrino Masses From a TeV Interval}},
  year = {2025},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=LCl1PmolJh},
  howpublished = {OpenReview},
}
Figure