Dipolar magnets and glasses: Neutron-scattering, dynamical, and calorimetric studies of randomly distributed Ising spins

Daniel H. Reich, Brett Ellman, Jerry Zhijian Yang, T. F. Rosenbaum, G. Aeppli, D. P. BelangerPhysical 1990 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the magnetic behavior of diluted Ising magnets, specifically LiHoxY1-xF4, by combining neutron scattering, susceptibility, and calorimetry. They discovered that varying the concentration of magnetic ions (Ho) leads to distinct magnetic "glassy" states: a conventional spin glass at intermediate dilution and a novel "decoupled cluster glass" at very low dilution, challenging existing theories of magnetic glasses.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the fundamental nature of "glassy" behavior in magnetic systems is a long-standing challenge. Glasses are characterized by history-dependent responses and a multitude of possible ground states, making it difficult to pinpoint the microscopic origins of their behavior. The researchers aimed to study a simplified model system – randomly distributed Ising dipoles in LiHoxY1-xF4 – where the microscopic interactions are well-understood. This system allows for the exploration of how disorder (dilution of magnetic ions) influences magnetic ordering and the emergence of glassy states, with the goal of identifying universal features of magnetic glasses.

Methods

The study employed a multi-pronged experimental approach:

  • Neutron Scattering: Used to probe magnetic correlations and the structure of magnetic clusters. This technique allows researchers to "see" how spins are arranged and how these arrangements change with temperature.
  • AC Magnetic Susceptibility: Measured the real and imaginary parts of the magnetic susceptibility over a wide range of frequencies and temperatures. This technique is sensitive to the dynamics of magnetic relaxation and can reveal the presence of glassy freezing.
  • Calorimetry (Specific Heat): Measured the heat capacity of the samples. This provides information about the energy spectrum of the system, particularly the excitations from the ground state.
  • Thermal Relaxation: Observed how the sample temperature responded to a heat pulse. This directly probes the dynamics of energy dissipation and can reveal non-exponential relaxation processes characteristic of some glassy systems.

The researchers also utilized theoretical models, including a generalization of the Debye theory for dielectric relaxation and a mean-field theory for dipolar-coupled Ising systems, to interpret their experimental data.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental measurements performed on synthesized single crystals of LiHoxY1-xF4.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Diverse Glassy Regimes: The most striking finding is the existence of at least two distinct types of magnetic glassiness in this system, directly linked to the concentration of magnetic ions. This challenges the notion of a single, universal spin-glass behavior.
  • "Decoupled Cluster Glass" (DCG): The very dilute sample (x=0.045) exhibits behavior inconsistent with conventional spin glasses. It shows decreasing relaxation barriers and nonexponential thermal relaxation as temperature approaches zero, suggesting a ground state composed of isolated, non-interacting spin clusters.
  • Spin Glass (SG) Behavior: The intermediate dilution sample (x=0.167) displays characteristics more aligned with typical spin glasses, including a complex ground state with no apparent gap for excitations.
  • Role of Dipolar Interactions: The long-range nature of the dipolar interaction is crucial. It leads to ferromagnetic correlations within clusters and a unique "bow-tie" shape in neutron scattering, distinguishing it from exchange-coupled magnets.
  • Cluster Growth: Neutron scattering reveals the growth of ferromagnetic clusters in the x=0.167 sample, suggesting that spin-glass freezing is governed by the collective behavior of these clusters.

Key Results

  • Phase Diagram: The study contributes to mapping the magnetic phase diagram of LiHoxY1-xF4, identifying ferromagnetic (FM), spin glass (SG), and the newly proposed decoupled cluster glass (DCG) regimes.
  • Ferromagnetism Down to x=0.46: The system remains ferromagnetic for concentrations as low as x=0.46, with a Curie temperature that scales with concentration according to mean-field theory.
  • Distinct Dynamics: The x=0.167 sample shows dynamics consistent with spin glasses, while the x=0.045 sample exhibits significantly different behavior, including a sharp Schottky-like peak in specific heat and nonexponential thermal relaxation.
  • Arrhenius Law for Relaxation: For the x=0.167 sample, relaxation times follow an Arrhenius law, a common observation in glassy systems. However, the x=0.045 sample shows deviations, suggesting a different underlying mechanism.
  • Neutron Scattering Signatures: The neutron scattering data for the x=0.167 sample reveals the presence of FM clusters with a characteristic shape dictated by the dipolar interaction.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Microscopic Origin of DCG: While the authors propose a model of decoupled spin clusters for the x=0.045 sample, a definitive microscopic explanation for this state and its transition from the SG state is still needed.
  • Shape Dependence: The authors acknowledge that the exact temperature dependence of certain parameters (like ΔE) might be influenced by sample geometry, and suggest future investigations to address this.
  • Theoretical Framework for DCG: The paper highlights the need for new theoretical frameworks to fully understand the behavior of the DCG state, particularly concerning its ground state and excitations.
  • Further Neutron Scattering: The authors suggest that future neutron scattering experiments on the more dilute x=0.045 sample could provide further insights into its magnetic correlations.
  • Investigating Other Systems: The hope is that this study of a "microscopically clean model system" will inspire further research into the complex macroscopic behavior of glasses.

Summary updated

Abstract

We have measured the magnetic correlations, susceptibility, specific heat, and thermal relaxation in the dipolar-coupled Ising system ${\mathrm{LiHo}}_{\mathit{x}}$${\mathrm{Y}}_{1\mathrm{\ensuremath{-}}\mathit{x}}$${\mathrm{F}}_{4}$. The material is ferromagnetic for spin concentrations at least as low as x=0.46, with a Curie temperature obeying mean-field scaling relative to that of pure ${\mathrm{LiHoF}}_{4}$. In contrast, an x=0.167 sample behaves as a spin glass above its transition temperature, while an x=0.045 crystal shows very different glassy properties characterized by decreasing barriers to relaxation and nonexponential thermal relaxation as T\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0. We find the properties of the x=0.045 system to be consistent with a single low-degeneracy ground state with a large gap for excitations. The x=0.167 sample, however, supports a complex ground state with no appreciable gap, in accordance with prevailing theories of spin glasses. The underlying causes of such disparate behavior are discussed in terms of random clusters as probed by neutron studies of the x=0.167 sample.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{reich1990dipolar,
  author = {Daniel H. Reich and Brett Ellman and Jerry Zhijian Yang and T. F. Rosenbaum and G. Aeppli and D. P. Belanger},
  title = {{Dipolar magnets and glasses: Neutron-scattering, dynamical, and calorimetric studies of randomly distributed Ising spins}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {1990},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevb.42.4631},
}
Figure