Dimensionless constants, cosmology, and other dark matters

Max Tegmark, Anthony Aguirre, M. J. Rees, Frank WilczekPhysical 2006 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We identify 31 dimensionless physical constants required by particle physics and cosmology, and emphasize that both microphysical constraints and selection effects might help elucidate their origin. Axion cosmology provides an instructive example, in which these two kinds of arguments must both be taken into account, and work well together. If a Peccei-Quinn phase transition occurred before or during inflation, then the axion dark matter density will vary from place to place with a probability distribution. By calculating the net dark matter halo formation rate as a function of all four relevant cosmological parameters and assessing other constraints, we find that this probability distribution, computed at stable solar systems, is arguably peaked near the observed dark matter density. If cosmologically relevant weakly interacting massive particle (WIMP) dark matter is discovered, then one naturally expects comparable densities of WIMPs and axions, making it important to follow up with precision measurements to determine whether WIMPs account for all of the dark matter or merely part of it.

Introduction: The Fine-Tuning Problem

Modern physics and cosmology are built upon "Standard Models" that describe the universe with remarkable precision. However, these models rely on 31 "free parameters"—dimensionless constants like the electron-to-proton mass ratio or the cosmological constant—that must be measured experimentally rather than derived from first principles. The specific values of these constants present a profound "fine-tuning" challenge: if many of these numbers were even slightly different, the resulting universe would be sterile, lacking the stars, atoms, or stable environments necessary for life.

This paper explores the hypothesis that these constants are not fixed by a single "Theory of Everything" but are instead "effective laws" or "bylaws" that vary across a vast multiverse. In this framework, we find ourselves in a specific region of the multiverse because its local constants permit the existence of observers—a concept known as anthropic selection.

The 31 Constants of Our Universe

The authors consolidate 26 parameters from the Standard Model of particle physics and 5 from cosmology into a single dimensionless vector $\mathbf{p}$. These include coupling constants for fundamental forces, particle masses, and cosmological densities.

A subset of the 31 dimensionless parameters and derived physical quantities that define our universe.

By analyzing these parameters, the research aims to move the multiverse discussion from philosophical speculation to quantitative science. The goal is to calculate the probability distributions of these constants to see if our observed values are "typical" for habitable regions.

Conceptual Framework: The Shifting Boundary

A key insight of the paper is the historical shift in what we consider "fundamental." Kepler once sought a fundamental geometric reason for the specific sizes of planetary orbits, which we now understand as accidental initial conditions of our solar system's formation.

The hierarchy of physical laws, illustrating the shift from fundamental to effective "bylaws."

The authors suggest that the 31 constants are the next set of "laws" to be reclassified. What appears to be a fundamental constant in our local neighborhood may simply be an environmental variable determined by the "landscape" of a more fundamental theory, such as string theory, combined with inflationary processes.

Methodology: Bayesian Selection and Axion Modeling

To quantify this, the authors employ a Bayesian approach. The observed distribution of a parameter $f(\mathbf{p})$ is modeled as the product of a "prior" distribution $f_{\text{prior}}(\mathbf{p})$ (derived from fundamental theory) and a "selection" factor $f_{\text{selec}}(\mathbf{p})$ (representing the density of observers or stable solar systems produced by those parameters).

The paper focuses on axions—a leading dark matter candidate—as a primary case study. Unlike WIMPs (Weakly Interacting Massive Particles), which depend on complex thermal processes, axion density in certain inflationary scenarios has a robust, simple prior ($1/\sqrt{\xi}$). This allows for a more direct test of the selection hypothesis.

The "Standard Banana" and Habitability

The researchers modeled the "habitable" regions of the universe by plotting dark matter halo density against temperature. They identified a specific "banana-shaped" region where galaxies can form and support life:

  1. The Cooling Limit: If the dark matter density is too low, gas cannot cool efficiently enough to collapse into stars.
  2. The Stability Limit: If the dark matter density is too high, the resulting dense stellar environments lead to frequent close encounters between stars. These encounters would strip planets from their host stars or destabilize planetary orbits, creating a "kill zone" for life.

Key Results and Implications

The study finds that after accounting for selection effects, the probability distribution for axion dark matter density is peaked remarkably close to the observed value ($\xi \approx 4$ eV). This suggests that our universe's dark matter density is not a random fluke but a natural consequence of the requirements for galaxy and planetary stability.

Furthermore, the paper notes that if WIMPs are eventually discovered, they likely coexist with axions in comparable densities. Anthropic selection suggests that if multiple dark matter species exist, we should expect to see them in similar proportions rather than one vastly dominating the other.

Limitations and Future Outlook

While the axion model is robust, other parameters like the fluctuation amplitude ($Q$) remain difficult to model due to uncertainties in their theoretical priors. Additionally, the definition of "habitability" based on stable solar systems is a proxy that may be subject to "carbon bias."

Future tests of this framework include high-precision CMB experiments. The simplest axion models consistent with this selection logic predict a relatively low scale of inflation, which would result in no detectable primordial gravitational wave signal—a falsifiable prediction for upcoming missions.

Summary updated

Abstract

We identify 31 dimensionless physical constants required by particle physics and cosmology, and emphasize that both microphysical constraints and selection effects might help elucidate their origin. Axion cosmology provides an instructive example, in which these two kinds of arguments must both be taken into account, and work well together. If a Peccei-Quinn phase transition occurred before or during inflation, then the axion dark matter density will vary from place to place with a probability distribution. By calculating the net dark matter halo formation rate as a function of all four relevant cosmological parameters and assessing other constraints, we find that this probability distribution, computed at stable solar systems, is arguably peaked near the observed dark matter density. If cosmologically relevant weakly interacting massive particle (WIMP) dark matter is discovered, then one naturally expects comparable densities of WIMPs and axions, making it important to follow up with precision measurements to determine whether WIMPs account for all of the dark matter or merely part of it.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tegmark2006dimensionless,
  author = {Max Tegmark and Anthony Aguirre and M. J. Rees and Frank Wilczek},
  title = {{Dimensionless constants, cosmology, and other dark matters}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2006},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevd.73.023505},
}

Loading related content...

Figure