Dimensional personality pathology and disordered eating in young adults: measuring the DSM-5 alternative model using the PID-5

Tanya Gilmartin, Caroline Gurvich, Joanna F. Dipnall, Gemma SharpFrontiers in Psychology 2023 · DOI

Abstract: It was concluded that understanding disordered eating behaviour in the context of personality pathology may assist formulating potentially risky behaviour.

Introduction

Traditional psychiatric classification systems often rely on categorical diagnoses, such as Anorexia Nervosa or Bulimia Nervosa. However, clinical presentations are frequently complex, with patients often exhibiting sub-clinical behaviors or shifting between diagnostic categories. This has led to a paradigm shift toward dimensional models of personality, which view pathology as a spectrum of maladaptive traits. This study, published in Frontiers in Psychology, explores how these dimensional traits—specifically those defined by the DSM-5 Alternative Model of Personality Disorders—relate to specific disordered eating behaviors in a non-clinical sample of young adults.

The PID-5 Framework

The researchers utilized the Personality Inventory for DSM-5 (PID-5) to map maladaptive personality traits. The PID-5 measures 25 specific trait facets organized into five broad domains: Negative Affect, Detachment, Antagonism, Disinhibition, and Psychoticism. Understanding these domains is crucial for identifying the specific "fingerprints" of personality that correlate with different eating pathologies.

Figure 1: Domains and facets of the PID-5.

Methodology

The study involved an online survey of 571 young adults (ages 16–30) in Australia, including 394 females and 167 males. Participants completed the PID-5 Short-Form and the Eating Pathology Symptoms Inventory (EPSI), which assesses six behaviors: restrictive eating, binge eating, purging, chewing and spitting, excessive exercise, and muscle building. The researchers used simultaneous equations path modeling to determine how personality traits, age, and body dissatisfaction predict these behaviors, specifically testing whether body dissatisfaction acts as a mediator between personality and behavior.

Key Findings

The study identified unique "fingerprints" of maladaptive traits for different eating behaviors, demonstrating that disordered eating is not a monolithic outcome of personality pathology. For instance, impulsivity—a facet of the Disinhibition domain—was a primary predictor for binge eating across both genders. In contrast, rigid perfectionism was more closely linked to restrictive eating in females.

Gender differences were particularly notable, especially regarding behaviors less commonly studied in women. In males, muscle building was directly predicted by traits such as Callousness (a lack of concern for others) and Restricted Affectivity. This suggests that male body image pathology may have distinct interpersonal and emotional drivers, where a drive for muscularity is linked to a more constricted emotional experience. Furthermore, traits like Depressivity and Emotional Lability often influenced behaviors indirectly; these traits predicted higher levels of body dissatisfaction, which then served as the immediate driver for behaviors like purging or binge eating.

In females, the trait of Deceitfulness emerged as a significant predictor for secretive behaviors like binge eating, purging, and chewing and spitting. This highlights the role of concealment and shame in these specific pathologies. Excessive exercise in females was predicted by Anxiousness and Anhedonia (the inability to feel pleasure), with this relationship being mediated through body dissatisfaction.

Conclusion

This research provides a nuanced view of how personality pathology manifests in disordered eating. While the study's cross-sectional nature prevents definitive causal claims, it underscores the value of using dimensional personality models like the PID-5. Recognizing these specific trait-behavior associations may help clinicians identify individuals at risk and tailor interventions more effectively. Future longitudinal research is needed to determine if these personality fingerprints can predict the development of clinical eating disorders over time and how these relationships evolve throughout adulthood.

Summary updated

Abstract

It was concluded that understanding disordered eating behaviour in the context of personality pathology may assist formulating potentially risky behaviour.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gilmartin2023dimensional,
  author = {Tanya Gilmartin and Caroline Gurvich and Joanna F. Dipnall and Gemma Sharp},
  title = {{Dimensional personality pathology and disordered eating in young adults: measuring the DSM-5 alternative model using the PID-5}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2023.1113142},
}
Figure