Dimensional neuroimaging: (Internet) Gaming Disorder symptoms according to the WHO and APA frameworks associate with lower striatal volume

Xinqi Zhou, Renjing Wu, Congcong Liu, Juan Kou, Yuanshu Chen, Halley M. Pontes, Dezhong Yao, Keith M. Kendrick, Benjamin Becker, Christian MontagbioRxiv 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the neurobiological underpinnings of Internet Gaming Disorder (IGD) by examining brain structure in relation to symptom severity as defined by the WHO and APA. They found that higher IGD symptom load is associated with reduced gray matter volume in the striatum, suggesting a neurobiological basis for these diagnostic criteria and highlighting similarities with other addictive disorders.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing prevalence of problematic internet gaming has led to its recognition as a disorder by major health organizations like the WHO and APA. However, the neurobiological mechanisms driving these addictive patterns, and how they compare to other substance-based addictions, remain poorly understood. This paper aims to bridge this gap by exploring the relationship between IGD symptom severity, as defined by two prominent diagnostic frameworks (APA's IGD and WHO's GD), and specific brain structures, particularly the striatum, which is known to be involved in reward processing and addiction.

Methods

The researchers employed a dimensional neuroimaging approach using voxel-based morphometry (VBM) on high-resolution T1-weighted MRI scans. They analyzed structural brain data from 82 healthy young adults. The core of their analysis involved multiple linear regression models to assess the association between IGD symptom load (measured by the IGDS9-SF for APA criteria and the GDT for WHO criteria) and gray matter volume in the striatum. To account for potential confounding factors, they also included age, education level, depression (BDI-II), autism spectrum traits (ASQ), and total intracranial volume as covariates. Voxel-wise analyses were restricted to the striatum, with a statistical threshold of p < .05 (FWE corrected) applied.

Datasets

The study utilized structural MRI data from 82 healthy young adult participants recruited through the Chengdu Gene Behavior Project. This dataset was supplemented with self-report questionnaire data for IGD symptom severity (IGDS9-SF and GDT), depression (BDI-II), and autism spectrum traits (ASQ). No new benchmark datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Striatal Volume as a Neurobiological Correlate: The study provides the first direct evidence linking the proposed diagnostic criteria for IGD (from both APA and WHO) to specific neurobiological markers, namely reduced striatal gray matter volume.
  • Convergence of Diagnostic Frameworks: Despite slight differences in their criteria, both the APA and WHO frameworks for IGD/GD showed convergent associations with striatal volume, suggesting they capture a common underlying neurobiological process.
  • Similarities to Other Addictions: The findings of reduced striatal volume in relation to IGD symptom load echo observations in other addictive disorders, including substance-based addictions and pathological gambling. This strengthens the argument for IGD being a genuine behavioral addiction with shared neurobiological pathways.
  • Ventral Striatum's Role in Early Stages: The greater overlap of APA criteria with ventral striatal regions, which are involved in reward salience and associative learning, suggests that the APA framework might be more sensitive to detecting earlier stages of disordered gaming.

Key Results

  • Higher symptom severity on the IGDS9-SF (APA framework) was significantly associated with lower gray matter volume in the bilateral caudate nucleus.
  • Higher symptom severity on the GDT (WHO framework) was significantly associated with lower gray matter volume in the right caudate nucleus.
  • The IGDS9-SF and GDT shared 114 voxels in the caudate region where significant associations were found.
  • The IGDS9-SF related structural alterations were more extensive than those associated with the GDT, encompassing the GDT-associated regions.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge a key limitation: the high co-linearity between the IGDS9-SF and GDT scores makes it difficult to directly compare the imaging results obtained for each test. This warrants caution when drawing conclusions about specific neural differences between the two psychometric tests.

Future work should focus on:

  • Further investigating the subtle neurobiological differences between the diagnostic frameworks.
  • Integrating findings with the existing literature on disordered gaming, particularly when using the WHO framework.
  • Conducting longitudinal studies to better understand the progressive neuroplastic changes in the striatum associated with the transition from non-disordered to disordered gaming.
  • Exploring the potential for the APA framework to detect earlier stages of disordered gaming due to its association with ventral striatal regions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Growing concerns about the addictive nature of internet and computer games led to the endorsement of Internet Gaming Disorder (IGD) as an emerging disorder by the American Psychological Association (APA) in 2013 and the recognition of Gaming Disorder (GD) as a new diagnosis by the World Health Organization (WHO) in 2019. While the definition of clear diagnostic criteria for IGD is beneficial for clinicians and those in need of treatment, it may also stigmatize normal behavior. Furthermore, the neurobiological mechanisms underlying IGD symptoms, and whether they resemble those of other addictive disorders remains highly debated. To this end the present study employed a dimensional imaging approach to determine associations between IGD symptom-load according to the APA and WHO diagnostic frameworks and brain structure in a comparably large sample of healthy subjects. It was found that higher symptom-load on psychometric tests assessing the APA and WHO diagnostic frameworks convergently associated with lower volumes of the striatum. The present results suggest for the first time a neurobiological foundation of the proposed diagnostic criteria for IGD according to both diagnostic classification systems, further indicating that the transition from non-disordered to disordered gaming is accompanied by progressive neuroplastic changes in the striatum, thus resembling progressive changes in other addictive disorders.
BibTeX
@misc{zhou2019dimensional,
  author = {Xinqi Zhou and Renjing Wu and Congcong Liu and Juan Kou and Yuanshu Chen and Halley M. Pontes and Dezhong Yao and Keith M. Kendrick and Benjamin Becker and Christian Montag},
  title = {{Dimensional neuroimaging: (Internet) Gaming Disorder symptoms according to the WHO and APA frameworks associate with lower striatal volume}},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1101/852855},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure