Dimensional Analysis: Overview and applications to problems of Soil-Structure Interaction

Joaquin Garcia‐Suarez, Danilo S. Kusanovic, Domniki Asimaki2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper argues for the underutilization of Dimensional Analysis (DA) in geotechnical engineering, particularly for Soil-Structure Interaction (SSI) problems. It provides a tutorial on DA, demonstrates its application to SSI through illustrative examples, and uses finite element simulations to showcase how DA can simplify complex systems and reveal crucial parameter relationships, leading to more efficient modeling and understanding.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The authors highlight that while Dimensional Analysis is a well-established tool in many engineering disciplines, its application in geotechnical engineering, specifically for Soil-Structure Interaction (SSI), has been limited. This underutilization means that the potential of DA to clarify parameter influences, identify dominant response regimes, and simplify complex multi-parameter systems is not being fully leveraged. The paper aims to bridge this gap by introducing DA to geotechnical engineers and demonstrating its practical utility in understanding and modeling SSI phenomena.

Methods

The paper introduces Dimensional Analysis through the lens of Buckingham's Pi Theorem. It explains the concept of a dimensional basis and how to form dimensionless groups. The authors then apply these principles to two key areas:

  1. Illustrative Examples: They present simplified dynamic systems (e.g., a single-degree-of-freedom system) to demonstrate how DA can reduce the number of parameters controlling the response, even without explicit knowledge of the governing physical laws.
  2. Soil-Structure Interaction (SSI) Application: The core of the paper applies DA to a complex SSI problem involving a building, foundation, and soil half-space subjected to seismic loading. They identify all relevant physical parameters, establish a dimensional basis, and derive a set of dimensionless groups that govern the system's behavior. Finite element simulations are used to demonstrate the concept of physical similarity, where different physical configurations yielding the same dimensionless parameters exhibit identical responses.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical application and demonstration using numerical simulations rather than empirical datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • DA as a Powerful Simplifier: The paper strongly emphasizes that DA is not just about unit conversion; it's a fundamental tool for understanding the underlying physics of a system by identifying the essential dimensionless parameters that govern its behavior.
  • Underappreciated in Geotechnical Engineering: The authors make a compelling case that DA has been underutilized in geotechnical earthquake engineering and SSI, despite its significant potential to clarify complex interactions.
  • Physical Similarity is Key: The concept of physical similarity, where systems with the same dimensionless parameters behave identically, is crucial. This allows for the creation of scaled models and the interpretation of simulation results across different physical scales.
  • Parameter Importance Revealed: DA helps identify which dimensionless parameters are most influential on the system's response, allowing researchers to focus their efforts and potentially neglect less significant ones.
  • Caution in Characteristic Value Selection: The paper highlights that the choice of characteristic values for normalization is critical and can significantly impact the interpretation of results, as illustrated in Section 3.3.

Key Results

  • The paper successfully derives a set of dimensionless groups that govern the Soil-Structure Interaction problem, significantly reducing the parameter space from 13 physical variables to 10 dimensionless groups.
  • Through finite element simulations, the authors demonstrate physical similarity: different configurations of soil-foundation-structure models, when designed to have the same dimensionless parameters, exhibit virtually identical responses (Figures 4-7).
  • A sensitivity analysis (Table 3) confirms that certain dimensionless parameters (specifically $\Pi_1$, $\Pi_2$, and $\Pi_4$) have a much greater influence on the structural response than others, validating the insights gained from DA.
  • The study shows that DA can guide the selection of parameters for physically similar simulations, reducing the need for extensive parametric studies.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simplifications in SSI Model: The authors acknowledge that their simplified SSI model, which focuses on first modal properties and neglects certain aspects like axial column stiffness, introduces some discrepancies in numerical results (Section 4.3.2).
  • Assumptions for Parameter Reduction: While DA reduces the parameter space, further assumptions are often needed to isolate the most critical parameters. The paper discusses some of these assumptions (e.g., neglecting certain parameters, taking limits) but notes that these require careful justification.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that a more detailed analysis of the influence of parameters like embedment depth ($\Pi_3$) would be beneficial for deeper foundations. It also implies that the methodology can be extended to other complex parametric problems in soil mechanics and beyond. The authors also point out that while DA reveals controlling parameters, it doesn't yield the functional form of the response, which often requires further analysis (e.g., perturbation methods).

Summary updated

Abstract

Dimensional Analysis is a long-established tool widely used in many branches of engineering and science. However, applications in geotechnical engineering, and in particular soil-structure interaction (SSI), have barely been explored, in spite of the method's potential to clarify parameter influence and shed light on the range of response regimes. The purpose of this text is twofold: (a) it intends to provide a brief introduction to Dimensional Analysis specifically tailored to geotechnical engineers by carefully choosing illustrative examples, (b) it uses Dimensional Analysis to study the parameter space in soil-building interaction problems, emphasizing modeling choices and using a finite-element model to demonstrate the concept of physical similarity. The suitability of using certain dimensionless parameters over others is discussed based on and their magnitude and sensitivity analysis.
BibTeX
@misc{garciasuarez2019dimensional,
  author = {Joaquin Garcia‐Suarez and Danilo S. Kusanovic and Domniki Asimaki},
  title = {{Dimensional Analysis: Overview and applications to problems of Soil-Structure Interaction}},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.31224/osf.io/m3ycp},
}
Figure