Digitalization of the IOM: A comprehensive cadaveric study for obtaining three-dimensional models and morphological properties of the forearm's interosseous membrane

Fabio Carrillo, Simon Suter, Fabio A. Casari, Reto Sutter, Ladislav Nagy, Jess G. Snedeker, Philipp FürnstahlZurich 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study addresses the critical need for accurate 3D models and biomechanical data of the forearm's interosseous membrane (IOM) for improved surgical planning. By combining micro-CT and standard CT with novel 3D analysis techniques, the researchers generated detailed morphological and tensile property data for individual IOM ligaments, providing a crucial foundation for more realistic forearm simulation models.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Current preoperative planning for forearm orthopedic surgeries is largely limited to bone-related procedures. However, complex pathologies often involve soft tissues, and clinicians are increasingly interested in dynamic models that account for their influence. The interosseous membrane (IOM), a significant ligamentous complex in the forearm, plays a vital role in forearm motion and stability. Despite its importance, existing simulation models of the IOM are often oversimplified or clinically unreliable due to a lack of detailed morphological and biomechanical data. This gap hinders the development of accurate predictive models for surgical outcomes.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-stage approach:

  • Specimen Preparation: Five fresh-frozen cadaveric upper extremities were used. After meticulous dissection to expose the IOM, the humerus and hand were dislocated and removed, leaving the radius and ulna intact.
  • Micro-CT and Standard CT Acquisition: Micro-CT scans were performed on the forearms in full supination to capture detailed IOM structures. Standard CT scans were also acquired for the radius and ulna.
  • 3D Model Generation: DICOM data from micro-CT were processed using segmentation software (Mimics) to create 3D models of the IOM ligaments. Radius and ulna models were generated from standard CT data. These models were then aligned and combined.
  • Ligament Annotation: A senior hand surgeon annotated four key IOM ligament structures: the distal oblique bundle (DOB), distal accessory band (AB), central band (CB), and dorsal oblique accessory cord (DOAC). Surgical clips were used to mark radial and ulnar attachments.
  • 3D Morphological Property Measurement: Novel 3D methods were developed to measure:
  • Fan-out angle: Calculated from radial and ulnar attachment direction vectors.
  • Thickness: Measured continuously along the ligament fibre at proximal, distal, and middle points.
  • Attachment Location: Expressed as a percentage of bone length.
  • Attachment Width: Measured as the longitudinal distance between proximal and distal attachment points.
  • Tensile Property Measurement: Ligament samples were prepared and subjected to pull-out tensile testing on a universal material testing machine. This yielded data on force, displacement, maximum failure force, stiffness, and ultimate strain.
  • Validation: The generated 3D morphological properties were validated against established optical ex-vivo measurements using a digital micrometer and a CCD-Laser scanner.

Datasets

The study utilized data from five fresh-frozen cadaveric upper extremities. The generated 3D models and datasets are made publicly available for download.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The IOM is a complex, multi-component structure: The study meticulously segmented and analyzed four distinct IOM ligaments, highlighting their individual contributions.
  • 3D modeling unlocks detailed morphological analysis: The ability to measure thickness continuously along the entire ligament and to precisely define attachment points and fiber directions is a significant advantage over traditional 2D methods.
  • Biphasic failure response is characteristic: Tensile testing revealed a two-stage failure pattern in the IOM ligaments, consistent with previous findings, indicating initial failure of thinner fibers followed by rupture of the main fiber bundles.
  • Central Band (CB) is the strongest: The CB demonstrated the highest load-bearing capacity, suggesting its primary role in forearm stability.
  • Dorsal Oblique Accessory Cord (DOAC) shows surprising stiffness: Despite a smaller CSA than the CB, the DOAC exhibited significantly higher stiffness, indicating important stabilizing functions in the proximal forearm.

Key Results

  • Morphological Data: Detailed measurements for attachment locations, ligament width, fan-out angles, and thickness were obtained for the CB, AB, and DOAC. The DOB was identified in only one specimen.
  • Width Comparison: 3D and ex-vivo width measurements showed good agreement, with minor discrepancies attributed to measurement method and forearm positioning.
  • Thickness Comparison: Average thickness measurements from 3D methods showed some differences compared to ex-vivo measurements, with potential explanations including differences in forearm positioning and potential folding of ligaments.
  • Tensile Properties:
    • The CB exhibited the highest average ultimate force (187.93 N) and stiffness (43.53 N/mm).
  • The AB showed an average ultimate failure strain of 2.30%.
  • The DOAC demonstrated a high stiffness (77.20 N/mm) despite a smaller CSA.
  • The DOB had an average ultimate failure strain of 1.43%.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Small Sample Size: The study used only five forearms, limiting statistical analysis to descriptive statistics. Future work should involve larger sample sizes.
  • Forearm Positioning Differences: Variations in forearm positioning between micro-CT, standard CT, and ex-vivo measurements introduced minor discrepancies in thickness measurements.
  • POC Missing: The proximal oblique cord (POC) was not identified or was lost during dissection, meaning its properties are not included.
  • Constant CSA Assumption: The study assumed a constant CSA for ligaments, whereas in reality, it changes under load. Future studies should analyze CSA changes during loading.
  • Smoking History: Some cadavers had a smoking history, which could potentially affect tensile properties.
  • Proprioception Not Included: The study focused solely on passive mechanical properties, excluding proprioception.

Future Work Suggestions:

  • Acquire remaining morphological and tensile properties (e.g., rest length, Poisson's ratio).
  • Analyze CSA changes during loading.
  • Develop standardized specimen-specific guides for consistent positioning across measurements.
  • Standardize measurements relative to bone size to account for anatomical variations.
  • Investigate the influence of muscles on forearm motion.
  • Build more complex ligament-bone motion models to simulate abnormal IOM tensioning after trauma.

Summary updated

Abstract

State-of-the-art of preoperative planning for forearm orthopaedic surgeries is currently limited to simple bone procedures. The increasing interest of clinicians for more comprehensive analysis of complex pathologies often requires dynamic models, able to include the soft tissue influence into the preoperative process. Previous studies have shown that the interosseous membrane (IOM) influences forearm motion and stability, but due to the lack of morphological and biomechanical data, existing simulation models of the IOM are either too simple or clinically unreliable. This work aims to address this problematic by generating 3D morphological and tensile properties of the individual IOM structures. First, micro- and standard-CT acquisitions were performed on five fresh-frozen annotated cadaveric forearms for the generation of 3D models of the radius, ulna and each of the individual ligaments of the IOM. Afterwards, novel 3D methods were developed for the measurement of common morphological features, which were validated against established optical ex-vivo measurements. Finally, we investigated the individual tensile properties of each IOM ligament. The generated 3D morphological features can provide the basis for the future development of functional planning simulation of the forearm.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{carrillo2020digitalization,
  author = {Fabio Carrillo and Simon Suter and Fabio A. Casari and Reto Sutter and Ladislav Nagy and Jess G. Snedeker and Philipp Fürnstahl},
  title = {{Digitalization of the IOM: A comprehensive cadaveric study for obtaining three-dimensional models and morphological properties of the forearm's interosseous membrane}},
  booktitle = {Zurich},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3929/ethz-b-000411798},
}
Figure