Digital Technology and Green Development in Manufacturing: Evidence from China and 20 Other Asian Countries

Zhu Lin, Xiaoming Li, Yao Huang, Fangyuan Liu, Chengji Yang, Dongyang Li, Hongpeng BaiSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how the digital economy impacts green development in manufacturing across China and 20 other Asian countries. It finds that while China sees a direct positive link, Belt and Road countries experience a delayed, U-shaped effect, highlighting the crucial roles of human capital and trade competitiveness as thresholds for realizing digital benefits.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The world is increasingly focused on environmental protection and sustainable development, particularly within the manufacturing sector. While the digital economy is rapidly transforming industries, its specific impact on the green development of manufacturing remains underexplored. This paper aims to fill this gap by analyzing how digital technologies influence Green Total Factor Productivity (GTFP) in manufacturing, considering the unique contexts of China and other Asian nations along the "Belt and Road" initiative. The authors highlight that despite growing global concern, empirical research on this nexus is scarce, leaving policymakers with limited guidance on leveraging digital advancements for environmental sustainability in manufacturing.

Methods

The researchers employed a two-way fixed-effects model for panel data analysis. They constructed three distinct models:

  1. Model (1): Focused on China's manufacturing GTFP, using the digital economy as the core explanatory variable.
  2. Model (2): Examined China's overall industry GTFP, comparing it with the manufacturing-specific findings.
  3. Model (3): Analyzed the GTFP of 20 Asian countries along the "Belt and Road" initiative, considering the spatial spillover effects of the digital economy.

To account for potential endogeneity, they also utilized a threshold effect model, incorporating human capital and manufacturing trade competitiveness as moderating variables. Additionally, they performed stationarity tests (LLC, Fisher-ADF, Hadri) and robustness checks using instrumental variables and a two-step least squares (2SLS) method.

Datasets

The study utilized panel data from 2008 to 2019.

  • China Data: Covered 30 provinces, excluding Hong Kong, Macao, Taiwan, and Tibet.
  • Asian Countries Data: Included 20 countries along the Belt and Road initiative: Bangladesh, Brunei, Cambodia, Cyprus, India, Indonesia, Iran, Israel, Jordan, Lebanon, Malaysia, Oman, Pakistan, Philippines, Singapore, Sri Lanka, Thailand, Turkey, Kazakhstan, and Kyrgyzstan.

Data sources included the EPS database, World Development Indicators (WDI) database, BP World Energy Statistical Yearbook, World Bank database, and Penn World Table.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Delayed Gratification of Digitalization: The digital economy's positive impact on green development isn't immediate. It takes time for its eco-friendly value to materialize, often appearing after a lag of two periods. This suggests that initial investments in digital infrastructure and adoption may not yield instant green returns.
  • U-Shaped Trend in Belt and Road Countries: Unlike China's direct positive association, the digital economy's impact on GTFP in Belt and Road countries follows a U-shaped curve. This implies that initial stages might see a dip or stagnation before a potential rise, possibly due to existing structural challenges.
  • Human Capital as an Amplifier: Augmented human capital is crucial for unlocking the full potential of the digital economy for green development. Highly skilled individuals are better equipped to leverage digital innovations for environmental sustainability.
  • Trade Competitiveness as a Catalyst: Trade competitiveness also acts as a threshold. As it increases, the positive influence of the digital economy on green development becomes more pronounced, suggesting that integration into global value chains can drive greener practices.
  • Digital Divide in Asia: A significant digital divide exists among Asian Belt and Road countries, with many lagging in digital infrastructure and adoption, hindering their ability to realize digital dividends for green growth.

Key Results

  • China: A positive and statistically significant association was found between the digital economy and both overall GTFP and manufacturing GTFP.
  • Belt and Road Countries: The digital economy exhibited a U-shaped trend in GTFP, with a delayed impact.
  • Threshold Effects:
    • When human capital exceeds a certain threshold, the digital economy's positive effect on GTFP is amplified.
  • Similarly, when trade competitiveness exceeds a threshold, the digital economy's positive impact on green development becomes visible.
  • Control Variables: Factors like government actions (gov) and industrial scale (sca) showed negative impacts on GTFP in China, suggesting that current policies and the dominance of heavy industries pose challenges to green development. Environmental regulation (en) and technological innovation (ino) showed positive impacts, though the latter's contribution was less substantial in China's manufacturing sector.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the digital economy's impact on green development is complex and varies significantly across industries and nations. They note that while China's manufacturing sector has seen growth, it still faces challenges with industrial structure and innovation capacity. For Belt and Road countries, the digital divide, weak infrastructure, and policy support are significant barriers.

Future work could delve deeper into the specific mechanisms through which digital technologies drive green innovation and explore sector-specific impacts. Further research could also focus on developing more targeted policy recommendations for different groups of countries to bridge the digital divide and accelerate green development. The study also suggests that the "U-shaped" nexus for Belt and Road countries implies that achieving environmental friendliness through digitalization may require initial sacrifices in resources and investment costs.

Summary updated

Abstract

The global interest in environmental protection and sustainable development has grown steadily in recent years, sparking widespread concern about green development in the manufacturing industry among governments, enterprises, and scholars around the world. Despite this heightened interest, research on the influence of the digital economy on the manufacturing industry’s green development remains scarce. This article analyzes the impact of the digital economy on the green development of the manufacturing industry and examines the role of human capital and trade competitiveness in this context. Using a two-way fixed-effects model of panel data analysis, we investigated the GTFP (Green Total Factor Productivity) of the Chinese manufacturing industry, as well as that of the overall industry and 20 other Asian countries along the “Belt and Road”. Our findings indicate a positive association between the digital economy and both the overall GTFP and the manufacturing GTFP in China. The countries situated along the Belt and Road experience a U-shaped trend in their GTFP due to the impact of the digital economy. The digital economy displays a delayed impact, and its eco-friendly value is realized, to different extents, after two sequential periods. In addition, human capital and trade competitiveness are threshold variables in the relationship between the digital economy and the green development of the manufacturing industry. When human capital exceeds a certain threshold and trade competitiveness exceeds a certain threshold, the digital economy has a positive effect on GTFP. This study offers unique insights into the impact of the digital economy on the green development of the manufacturing industry. By addressing this research gap, this study gives policymakers the ability to leverage these findings to promote sustainable practices across the industry. Ultimately, the valuable insights provided by this study may contribute to the ongoing efforts to advance the green development of the manufacturing industry.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lin2023digital,
  author = {Zhu Lin and Xiaoming Li and Yao Huang and Fangyuan Liu and Chengji Yang and Dongyang Li and Hongpeng Bai},
  title = {{Digital Technology and Green Development in Manufacturing: Evidence from China and 20 Other Asian Countries}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su151712841},
}
Figure