Digital Economy and 3E Efficiency Performance: Evidence from EU Countries

Shuangjie Li, Wei Wang, Liming Wang, Ge WangSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how the burgeoning digital economy impacts the "3E efficiency" (Energy-Environmental-Economic) of EU countries. It finds that while the digital economy initially hinders 3E efficiency, it becomes a positive driver once a country reaches a certain level of economic development (specifically, a GDP per capita exceeding €15,580), suggesting tailored strategies are needed for different EU economies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the complex interplay between economic development, environmental sustainability, and energy use, often summarized as the "3E" system. While the concept of sustainable development is widely accepted, achieving it remains a challenge. The digital economy is a significant driver of modern economic growth, but its impact on this crucial 3E efficiency – the coordination of energy conservation, emission reduction, and economic progress – is not well understood. Previous research has explored the digital economy's effects on individual components like carbon emissions or energy efficiency, but a comprehensive assessment of its influence on the integrated 3E efficiency is lacking. This paper aims to fill that gap by examining this relationship within EU countries.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach:

  • 3E Efficiency Measurement: They used a Slacks-Based Measure (SBM) model with undesirable outputs. This method is chosen because it can account for both desired outputs (like value of output) and undesired outputs (like greenhouse gas emissions), providing a more accurate picture of efficiency than traditional radial methods.
  • Digital Economy Measurement: A composite index for the digital economy development level was constructed using the entropy method, combining 14 variables across digital infrastructure, innovation environment, and national competitiveness.
  • Econometric Modeling:
    • Benchmark Regression: A static panel data model was used to assess the direct impact of the digital economy on 3E efficiency.
  • Mediation Analysis: A Bootstrap method and Sobel test were employed to examine the indirect impact of the digital economy on 3E efficiency through economic growth (GDP per capita).
  • Threshold Regression: A panel threshold model was used to identify potential non-linear relationships, specifically investigating how the impact of the digital economy on 3E efficiency changes at different levels of economic development (proxied by GDP per capita).

Datasets

The study utilized panel data from 24 EU countries for the period 2011-2019. Data sources included:

  • EU KLEMS database (for capital stock, labor, energy consumption, intermediate materials, value of output)
  • World Development Indicators (WDI)
  • International Telecommunication Union (ITU)
  • E-Government Knowledgebase (EGOVKB)
  • World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO)

Cyprus, Croatia, Luxembourg, Malta, Iceland, and Liechtenstein were excluded due to significant data gaps.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Digital Economy's Double-Edged Sword: The digital economy doesn't have a simple, linear effect on 3E efficiency. Initially, it can be detrimental, likely due to increased energy demand from digital infrastructure and activities.
  • Economic Development as a Turning Point: The crucial insight is that a country's economic development level acts as a threshold. Once a certain GDP per capita is reached, the digital economy shifts from being a hindrance to a facilitator of 3E efficiency. This suggests that the benefits of digitalization for sustainability only materialize after a certain level of economic maturity.
  • Tailored Strategies are Essential: The findings strongly imply that a one-size-fits-all approach to digital economy development and sustainability is ineffective. EU countries need to consider their specific economic context and development stage when formulating policies.
  • Mediating Role of Economic Growth: Economic growth is confirmed as a significant pathway through which the digital economy influences 3E efficiency, both directly and indirectly.

Key Results

  • Overall 3E Efficiency Trend: EU countries, on average, showed an upward trend in 3E efficiency from 2011 to 2019, though with some fluctuations.
  • Digital Economy's Initial Negative Impact: The benchmark regression revealed a statistically significant negative impact of the digital economy on 3E efficiency at a 1% significance level. A 1% increase in digital economy development was associated with a 0.048% decrease in 3E efficiency (Model 1) and a 0.071% decrease (Model 2 with controls).
  • Threshold Effect: The panel threshold regression identified two thresholds for GDP per capita.
  • Below €7,420 GDP per capita, a 1% increase in digital economy development leads to a 0.159% decrease in 3E efficiency.
  • Between €7,420 and €15,580 GDP per capita, the negative impact lessens to a 0.055% decrease.
  • Above €15,580 GDP per capita, the impact turns positive: a 1% increase in digital economy development leads to a 0.032% increase in 3E efficiency.
  • Mediating Effect: Economic growth (GDP per capita) plays a significant mediating role, accounting for approximately 23.46% of the total effect of the digital economy on 3E efficiency.
  • Control Variables: Energy consumption structure, environmental protection investment, and urbanization level were found to positively influence 3E efficiency, while government intervention had a negative impact.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Geographic Scope: The study is limited to EU countries due to data availability. The authors acknowledge that findings might not be generalizable to other regions with different economic structures or levels of development.
  • Future Research: The authors suggest expanding the scope to include more countries and regions to explore variations in the digital economy's impact on 3E efficiency across diverse contexts. They also propose investigating how differences in digital infrastructure might influence these outcomes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Nowadays, sustainability has become an important and widely accepted concept. Energy conservation and emission reduction are closely related to sustainable economic development. Therefore, a 3E efficiency approach, based on the “Energy–Environmental–Economic” (3E) system, can assess the coordination relationships among these three factors from the perspective of energy conservation and emission reduction. The digital economy is a new driving force for economic growth, but few studies have dealt with the question on whether it affects 3E efficiency. The purpose of this paper is to examine the relationship between the digital economy and 3E efficiency in EU countries. The empirical results indicate that: (1) overall 3E efficiency of EU countries showed an upward trend from 2011 to 2019; (2) in terms of the relationship between the digital economy and 3E efficiency, the digital economy has direct and indirect (through economic growth) impacts on 3E efficiency; when GDP per capita exceeds EUR 15,580, the influence coefficient of the digital economy on 3E efficiency changes from negative to positive. This suggests that EU countries with different levels of economic development should adopt different strategies to ensure the simultaneous development of their digital economy and 3E efficiency.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2023digital,
  author = {Shuangjie Li and Wei Wang and Liming Wang and Ge Wang},
  title = {{Digital Economy and 3E Efficiency Performance: Evidence from EU Countries}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su15075661},
}
Figure