Digestibility, textural and sensory characteristics of cookies made from residues of enzyme-assisted aqueous extraction of soybeans

Yang Li, Yufan Sun, Mingming Zhong, Fengying Xie, Huan Wang, Liang Li, Baokun Qi, Shuang ZhangScientific 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Enzyme-assisted aqueous extraction residue (REAE) is a byproduct of soybean processing with high nutritional value but low utilization. This study investigated the potential of REAE as a functional food additive in cookies at substitution levels of 0% to 50%. Results indicate that increasing REAE content leads to lighter color, reduced sweetness and fat, increased hardness, and significantly lower digestibility and glycemic index. Cookies were well accepted by sensory panels at up to 30% REAE substitution. The appropriate use of REAE reduces starch content and improves the nutritional profile of baked goods.

Introduction: Upcycling Soybean Waste

The food industry faces a dual challenge: managing massive amounts of processing byproducts and addressing health crises like Type II diabetes and obesity linked to high-starch diets. Soybean processing for oil or milk produces "okara," a fibrous residue often discarded. This research focuses on REAE, a specific type of okara produced via enzyme-assisted extraction. While nutritionally dense, its high fiber content can negatively impact texture. The study explores whether REAE can create "slow-digestion" cookies that maintain consumer appeal.

Methods

Researchers evaluated cookies with 0%, 10%, 20%, 30%, 40%, and 50% REAE substitution for wheat flour.

  • Physicochemical Analysis: Measured moisture, ash, protein, fat, and dietary fiber using AOAC methods.
  • Structural Analysis: Analyzed disulfide bonds and sulfhydryl groups to understand the protein network (gluten) impact.
  • In Vitro Digestion: Simulated human digestion to track starch hydrolysis and glucose release over 240 minutes.
  • Sensory Evaluation: A 40-member panel rated cookies on color, sweetness, crunchiness, and overall liking.

Results and Discussion

Nutritional and Glycemic Impact

A key finding was the significant reduction in the Glycemic Index (GI) and Hydrolysis Index (HI) as REAE content increased. Cookies with 30% or more REAE were classified as "slow-digestion" foods. This is largely attributed to the high Soluble Dietary Fiber (SDF) in REAE, which slows sugar absorption.

Figure 4: Impact of REAE substitution on Glycemic Index (GI) and Hydrolysis Index (HI).

Structural Changes and Texture

The addition of REAE led to a linear reduction in disulfide bonds, indicating a dilution of the wheat gluten network. This structural change explains the increased hardness and reduced springiness of the cookies. As soy residue replaces flour, the protein network that typically provides structure is weakened.

Figure 5: Changes in sulfhydryl groups and disulfide bonds (SH) across different REAE substitution levels.

The 30% "Sweet Spot"

Sensory panels found the cookies "well accepted" up to the 30% substitution level. At this concentration, the cookies achieved a balance of crunchiness and flavor that testers appreciated. Beyond 30%, the deterioration of dough properties led to lower sensory scores.

Conclusion

REAE is a promising functional additive that can significantly improve the nutritional profile of cookies by reducing starch and lowering the glycemic index. While high substitution levels affect texture due to gluten dilution, a 30% replacement offers an optimal balance of health benefits and consumer acceptance.

Summary updated

Abstract

Enzyme-assisted aqueous extraction residue (REAE) has a lower utilization rate as it is the "waste" produced after the enzyme-assisted aqueous extraction (EAE), but its nutritional value is high. To improve the development and utilization of REAE, in this study, cookies were made by adding REAE (0%, 10%, 20%, 30%, 40%, 50%) as a food additive to a small amount of flour. The AOAC method was used to identify the basic components of REAE, analyze its physical and chemical properties, and characterize the cookie structure change in terms of texture, disulfide bond, and thiol content. An in vitro simulation system and sensory evaluation mechanism were established to analyze the bioavailability and impact of quality. The results show that REAE is a potential food additive. With an increase in the REAE content, the cookies become lighter in color, the sweetness and fat content are reduced, the hardness is increased, and the digestibility and glycerin index are reduced. The change in texture is caused by the reduction of disulfide bonds in the dough. The cookies were 'well accepted' with up to 30% REAE. Therefore, the use of the appropriate amount of REAE as a new food additive will reduce the amount of starch added.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2020digestibility,
  author = {Yang Li and Yufan Sun and Mingming Zhong and Fengying Xie and Huan Wang and Liang Li and Baokun Qi and Shuang Zhang},
  title = {{Digestibility, textural and sensory characteristics of cookies made from residues of enzyme-assisted aqueous extraction of soybeans}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-020-61179-9},
}
Figure