Diffusion of Carbamazepine in Hydrophobic Zeolites: A Comparative Study Using Classical and Machine-Learned Potentials

Jakob Brauer, Richard Kendra, Carlos Bornes, Lukáš Grajciar, Michael FischerChemRxiv 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how the pharmaceutical pollutant carbamazepine (CBZ) diffuses within hydrophobic zeolites, crucial for designing effective water treatment materials. By comparing classical force fields with advanced machine-learned potentials (MACE), researchers found that MACE better captures the complex energy landscape, revealing that CBZ can get kinetically trapped in metastable states, influencing its overall diffusion rate.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Carbamazepine (CBZ) is a persistent pharmaceutical pollutant found in wastewater, posing risks to aquatic ecosystems. While hydrophobic zeolites show promise for removing CBZ, their effectiveness depends not only on how much they can adsorb but also on how quickly the pollutant can move within their pores. Understanding this diffusion process is critical for designing efficient zeolite-based water treatment systems. Previous computational studies often focused on static interaction energies, providing an incomplete picture of the dynamic diffusion process. This paper aims to bridge this gap by computationally exploring the free energy barriers that govern CBZ diffusion in various zeolites, comparing traditional methods with cutting-edge machine learning potentials.

Methods

The researchers employed umbrella sampling simulations to map out the free energy surfaces (FES) of CBZ diffusion within a series of all-silica zeolites. This technique is essential for studying rare events like diffusion by biasing the system along a specific reaction coordinate (in this case, the diffusion pathway) and then reweighting the results to obtain the true free energy profile.

They compared two primary computational approaches:

  • Classical Force Fields (FF): These are traditional models that use predefined mathematical functions to describe atomic interactions. The study utilized parameters from the OpenFF Sage 2.0 force field and Emami et al. for zeolite frameworks.
  • Machine-Learned Potential (MACE): This is a more advanced approach where a neural network is trained on a large dataset of atomic configurations and their corresponding energies and forces (often derived from more accurate quantum mechanical calculations). The paper used a fine-tuned foundation model based on the MACE architecture, which is known for its ability to capture complex chemical environments and polarizability.

The study also incorporated equilibrium molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to probe initial mobility and enhanced sampling techniques like simulated annealing to overcome kinetic trapping issues encountered with the MACE potential in certain systems.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The MACE potential was trained on data described in the supporting information, but specific datasets were not detailed in the main text.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • MACE captures kinetic trapping: A crucial finding is that the MACE potential reveals CBZ molecules can become "kinetically trapped" in higher-energy, metastable orientations after passing a transition state. This phenomenon is not as clearly depicted by classical force fields.
  • Beyond static interactions: The study strongly emphasizes that relying solely on static adsorption energies or geometric descriptors (like pore size) is insufficient for predicting diffusion behavior. The complex free energy landscape, including rotational and translational barriers, is key.
  • Desolvation and adsorption energy influence diffusion: The exergonic nature of CBZ adsorption from an aqueous phase can provide excess energy. This energy can lower the effective diffusion barrier by populating metastable states or increasing kinetic energy, making diffusion more facile than predicted by diffusion barriers alone.
  • Shape-selectivity doesn't always mean slow diffusion: Contrary to a potential intuition that strong shape-selective interactions might hinder diffusion, the study shows that even in highly selective zeolites, diffusion can occur, albeit governed by a complex energy landscape.
  • Classical FF limitations in strained environments: While classical force fields provide a qualitative agreement, they struggle to accurately represent the energetics of diffusion in highly confined or strained zeolite environments, where MACE shows superior performance.

Key Results

  • Qualitative agreement between FF and MACE: Both classical force fields and the MACE potential generally showed similar trends in diffusion barriers across different zeolites.
  • MACE predicts higher activation barriers: In most cases, the MACE potential predicted higher activation barriers for CBZ diffusion compared to classical force fields. This is attributed to MACE's better ability to account for the energy penalty of close atomic contacts and molecular deformations at transition states.
  • Significant differences in confined pores: For zeolites with narrower pores (e.g., BEA, IFR, MOR), the MACE potential revealed more pronounced kinetic trapping and asymmetric free energy surfaces, indicating a more complex diffusion pathway than predicted by classical methods.
  • Diffusion barriers vary widely: Activation barriers ranged from ~10 kJ/mol in wider pores (FAU) to over 300 kJ/mol in very narrow pores (MFI), suggesting that diffusion is impossible in the latter.
  • Apparent activation energy is lower: When considering the exergonic adsorption from water, the apparent activation energy for diffusion is significantly reduced, making the process more feasible. For MOR, this reduction brought the predicted half-life in line with experimental observations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations of Classical Force Fields: The study highlights that classical force fields may not accurately capture the energetics of diffusion in highly confined or strained zeolite environments.
  • Kinetic Trapping and Equilibration: The MACE simulations revealed kinetic trapping, requiring enhanced sampling strategies like simulated annealing to achieve proper equilibration and obtain reliable free energy surfaces.
  • Future Work:
    • Explicitly model the adsorption process from an aqueous phase to validate the hypothesis of metastable state population upon desolvation.
  • Extend this validated workflow to investigate a wider range of persistent organic pollutants.
  • Use these insights to guide the rational design of novel, shape-selective zeolite adsorbents for environmental remediation.
  • Further investigate the role of slow relaxation after diffusion events in the overall adsorption process.

Summary updated

Abstract

The persistent pharmaceutical pollutant carbamazepine (CBZ) poses a significant challenge to conventional wastewater treatment, with hydrophobic zeolites emerging as promising selective adsorbents. However, the possibility of diffusion within these tightly confining pores remains poorly understood and computational studies have often been limited to the discussion of interaction energies, conveying only a static picture. Here, we present a computational study using umbrella sampling simulations to obtain free energy surfaces (FES) of CBZ diffusion in a range of all-silica zeolites. We compare results from a classical force field description with a fine-tuned state of the art neural network potential built on the MACE architecture. While both methods show qualitative agreement, the fine-tuned MACE potential consistently predicts higher activation barriers, which we attribute to its ability to capture the significant energetic cost of close-contact molecular deformations at the transition states. Critically, the MACE simulations reveal that CBZ can become kinetically trapped in higher energy, metastable orientations after an initial diffusion event. We propose that the initial exergonic adsorption from an aqueous phase would populate an ensemble of lowest energy and metastable states. This provides a plausible kinetic pathway for diffusion, as the effective activation barrier is substantially lower for molecules starting from these higher-energy states. This work demonstrates that the diffusion of CBZ is governed by a complex landscape of translational and rotational barriers, a picture only accessible by going beyond the interaction energy based evaluation of pollutant zeolite combinations. This work supports the rational choice of shape-selective zeolites as effective adsorbents for environmental remediation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{brauer2025diffusion,
  author = {Jakob Brauer and Richard Kendra and Carlos Bornes and Lukáš Grajciar and Michael Fischer},
  title = {{Diffusion of Carbamazepine in Hydrophobic Zeolites: A Comparative Study Using Classical and Machine-Learned Potentials}},
  booktitle = {ChemRxiv},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.26434/chemrxiv-2025-7x5nf},
}
Figure