TL;DR
This paper tackles the challenge of training machine learning models with differential privacy while using sparsity-inducing regularizers, which are often non-differentiable. The authors provide new theoretical bounds for differentially private algorithms, specifically output perturbation and a private Frank-Wolfe algorithm for dual optimization, showing that privacy guarantees depend on the "Gaussian width" of the dual norm's unit ball.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
In machine learning, we often use Empirical Risk Minimization (ERM) to train models on data. However, this data might contain sensitive personal information. Differential privacy offers a way to protect this information by ensuring that the output of a learning algorithm doesn't reveal too much about any single data point. A common technique to improve model performance and interpretability is using sparsity-inducing regularizers (like L1 norm), which encourage models to use fewer features. The problem is that these regularizers are often non-differentiable, making standard differentially private optimization algorithms tricky to apply and analyze. Existing differentially private ERM methods often have excess risk bounds that depend on the dimensionality of the data, which can be problematic for high-dimensional datasets. This paper aims to bridge this gap by analyzing differentially private ERM with non-smooth, sparsity-inducing regularizers and deriving new excess risk bounds that are independent of dimensionality, depending instead on a geometric property of the dual norm.
Methods
The paper analyzes three standard differentially private algorithms:
- Output Perturbation: This is a common method where noise is added to the final output of the optimization process. The authors extend existing analyses to handle non-smooth regularizers and derive new excess risk bounds that depend on the Gaussian width of the unit ball of the dual norm of the sparsity-inducing regularizer.
- Frank-Wolfe Algorithm (Private Version): The authors propose a differentially private version of the Frank-Wolfe algorithm to optimize the dual of the ERM problem. This is a novel approach, as most prior work focused on the primal problem. They derive utility guarantees for this private dual optimization.
- Objective Perturbation: This method involves adding noise to the objective function itself. The paper shows an interesting equivalence: objective perturbation of the primal ERM problem is equivalent to output perturbation of its dual optimization problem.
A key theoretical tool used is the concept of submodular functions and their Lovász extensions, which provide tight convex relaxations for structured sparsity-inducing norms. The Gaussian width of a set is also a crucial concept, measuring its "spread" in a probabilistic sense, and it plays a central role in the derived excess risk bounds.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The analysis is theoretical and focuses on general properties of data distributions and loss functions.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Sparsity and Privacy are Compatible: The paper demonstrates that it's possible to achieve differential privacy even when using complex, non-smooth regularizers that induce structured sparsity.
- Dual Optimization for Privacy: Applying differentially private algorithms to the dual of the ERM problem, specifically using a private Frank-Wolfe algorithm, is a novel and effective strategy.
- Geometric Interpretation of Privacy Bounds: The excess risk bounds are shown to depend on the Gaussian width of the unit ball of the dual norm. This provides a geometric understanding of how the structure of the regularizer influences the privacy-utility trade-off.
- Objective Perturbation Equivalence: The surprising equivalence between objective perturbation of the primal and output perturbation of the dual simplifies analysis and offers new perspectives.
- Dimensionality Independence: The derived bounds are independent of the data dimensionality, which is a significant advantage for high-dimensional machine learning tasks.
Key Results
- Output Perturbation Bounds: The paper derives new excess risk bounds for output perturbation with non-smooth, sparsity-inducing regularizers. These bounds depend on the Gaussian width of the symmetric submodular polyhedron (the unit ball of the dual norm).
- Private Frank-Wolfe for Dual Optimization: A differentially private Frank-Wolfe algorithm is proposed for optimizing the dual ERM problem. Its utility guarantee is analyzed and shown to depend on the Gaussian width of the dual polytope.
- Objective Perturbation Equivalence: Proposition 2 formally shows that objective perturbation of the primal ERM is equivalent to output perturbation of the dual ERM.
Limitations and Future Work
- Excess Risk for Objective Perturbation: While the paper shows the equivalence of objective perturbation of the primal to output perturbation of the dual, it doesn't derive explicit excess risk bounds for objective perturbation itself. The authors suggest that if the loss function is strongly convex, this might be achievable.
- Mirror Descent: The paper mentions that Frank-Wolfe is related to mirror descent and suggests analyzing mirror-descent-based differentially private algorithms for ERM with non-smooth regularizers as future work.
- Combinatorial Penalties: Extending the proposed methods to solve ERM problems with combinatorial penalties is also identified as a future research direction.
- Practical Implementation: The paper is primarily theoretical. Future work could focus on the practical implementation and empirical evaluation of these algorithms.
Summary updated