Differential Responses of Bacterial and Fungal Community Structure in Soil to Nitrogen Deposition in Two Planted Forests in Southwest China in Relation to pH

Zheng Hou, Xiao‐Hua Zhang, Wen Chen, Ziqi Liang, Keqin Wang, Ya Zhang, Yali SongForests 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigated how nitrogen deposition affects soil microbial communities in two types of planted coniferous forests in Southwest China over four years. It found that nitrogen addition had opposing effects on bacterial and fungal diversity between the two forest types, highlighting the importance of tree species and soil pH in mediating these responses. The research identifies soil pH and nitrogen availability as key drivers of these microbial shifts, offering crucial insights for managing these vital forest ecosystems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Atmospheric nitrogen (N) deposition is a growing global concern, significantly impacting ecosystem nutrient cycling. While it's known that N deposition can alter soil microbial communities, which are crucial for ecosystem functions like carbon and nutrient cycling, our understanding of these responses in subtropical planted forests remains limited. These forests are increasingly common due to afforestation efforts, but they may be more vulnerable to N deposition than natural ecosystems. Specifically, how different tree species in these planted forests respond to prolonged N enrichment, and what factors regulate these responses, is not well understood. This paper aims to fill this knowledge gap by examining the long-term effects of simulated N deposition on soil bacterial and fungal communities in two dominant coniferous species in Southwest China, exploring the roles of soil properties like pH in mediating these changes.

Methods

The study employed a four-year simulated nitrogen addition experiment in two distinct planted coniferous forests: P. yunnanensis Franch. and P. armandii Franch. The experiment involved four treatment levels: a control (CK) and three increasing nitrogen application rates (N10, N20, N25 g N m⁻² yr⁻¹). Soil samples were collected and analyzed for a range of soil physicochemical properties, including pH, soil organic matter (SOM), total nitrogen (TN), ammonium nitrogen (NH₄⁺-N), and nitrate nitrogen (NO₃⁻-N). Microbial community structure was assessed using high-throughput sequencing of bacterial (16S rRNA V3-V4 region) and fungal (ITS region) DNA. Microbial diversity was quantified using alpha-diversity indices (OTUs, Shannon, Chao). Beta-diversity and community composition were analyzed using Principal Coordinate Analysis (PCoA) and Redundancy Analysis (RDA). Co-occurrence network analysis was used to explore interspecies interactions. Statistical analyses included ANOVA, Welch correction, and random forest modeling to identify key drivers of microbial community changes. Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) was used to elucidate the causal pathways between nitrogen addition, soil properties, and microbial communities.

Datasets

The study utilized soil samples collected from the experimental plots. Microbial community data was generated through high-throughput sequencing. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing databases (SILVA for bacteria, UNITE for fungi) were used for taxonomic assignment.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Stand-Specific Responses: The most striking insight is that the two coniferous forest types (P. yunnanensis and P. armandii) exhibited fundamentally different responses to nitrogen addition. This underscores that simply classifying forests as "planted" is insufficient; the specific tree species plays a critical role.
  • Opposing Diversity Trends: Nitrogen addition reduced bacterial diversity in P. yunnanensis but increased it in P. armandii. Conversely, fungal diversity increased in P. yunnanensis but showed mixed responses (decreased OTUs/Chao, increased Shannon) in P. armandii. This highlights the complex and often contrasting impacts on different microbial domains.
  • pH as a Major Regulator: Soil pH emerged as a critical factor. Nitrogen addition increased pH in P. yunnanensis (associated with bacterial diversity loss and fungal diversity gain) and decreased it in P. armandii (associated with the opposite diversity trends). This suggests that N-induced soil acidification is a key mechanism driving microbial shifts.
  • Fungal Sensitivity: Fungal communities, particularly their beta-diversity and network complexity, were more sensitive to nitrogen addition than bacterial communities. This challenges some previous assumptions about fungal resilience.
  • Network Complexity Shifts: Nitrogen addition reduced bacterial interaction complexity in P. yunnanensis but enhanced it in P. armandii. Fungal networks, however, showed increased stability and complexity at lower N levels, with higher levels potentially becoming inhibitory.
  • Threshold Effects: The study suggests potential nutrient limitation thresholds for fungi at higher N levels and a threshold for bacterial community enhancement in P. armandii.

Key Results

  • Bacterial Diversity: P. yunnanensis showed a significant decrease in bacterial α-diversity (OTUs, Shannon, Chao) with increasing N addition, while P. armandii showed an increase, particularly at the N10 level.
  • Fungal Diversity: P. yunnanensis exhibited increased fungal α-diversity (OTUs, Shannon, Chao) with N addition, with N20 showing the most significant enhancement. P. armandii showed decreased fungal OTUs and Chao index but an increased Shannon index.
  • Soil pH: P. yunnanensis soils showed an increase in pH with N addition (from ~4.17 to ~4.35), while P. armandii soils showed a decrease (from ~4.71 to ~4.18).
  • Network Complexity: Bacterial network complexity decreased in P. yunnanensis but increased in P. armandii (peaking at N20). Fungal networks showed increased stability and complexity at lower N levels.
  • Key Drivers: Random forest and SEM analyses identified soil pH, NH₄⁺-N, and TN as the primary factors regulating microbial communities in response to N addition.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the study was conducted in a specific subtropical region and that findings may not be universally applicable. While the four-year experiment provides valuable insights into long-term effects, even longer-term studies would be beneficial to fully understand the resilience and adaptation of these microbial communities. Future research could focus on:

  • Investigating the specific mechanisms behind the differential responses of P. yunnanensis and P. armandii to N deposition, including detailed analyses of root exudates and their interactions with soil microbes.
  • Exploring the ecological roles and competitive strategies of specific microbial taxa, particularly fungi like Rozellomycota, which showed unique responses.
  • Expanding similar experiments to other forest types and geographical regions to build a more comprehensive global understanding of N deposition impacts on soil microbiomes.
  • Further elucidating the complex interactions between soil properties (especially pH and nutrient availability) and microbial community dynamics under various N deposition scenarios.

Summary updated

Abstract

Increased nitrogen deposition profoundly impacts ecosystem nutrient cycling and poses a significant ecological challenge. Soil microorganisms are vital for carbon and nutrient cycling in ecosystems; however, the response of soil microbial communities in subtropical planted coniferous forests to nitrogen deposition remains poorly understood. This study carried out a four-year nitrogen addition experiment in the subtropical montane forests of central Yunnan to explore the microbial community dynamics and the primary regulatory factors in two coniferous forests (P. yunnanensis Franch. and P. armandii Franch.) under prolonged nitrogen addition. We observed that nitrogen addition elicited different responses in soil bacterial and fungal communities between the two forest types. In P. yunnanensis Franch. plantations, nitrogen supplementation notably reduced soil bacterial α-diversity but increased fungal diversity. In contrast, P. armandii Franch. forests showed the opposite trends, indicating stand-specific differences. Nitrogen addition also led to significant changes in soil nutrient dynamics, increasing soil pH in P. yunnanensis Franch. forests and decreasing it in P. armandii Franch. forests. These changes in soil nutrients significantly affected the diversity, community structure, and network interactions of soil microbial communities, with distinct responses noted between stands. Specifically, nitrogen addition significantly influenced the β-diversity of fungal communities more than that of bacterial communities. It also reduced the complexity of bacterial interspecies interactions in P. yunnanensis Franch. forests while enhancing it in P. armandii Franch. forests. Conversely, low levels of nitrogen addition improved the stability of fungal networks in both forest types. Using random forest and structural equation modeling, soil pH, NH4+-N, and total nitrogen (TN) were identified as key factors regulating bacterial and fungal communities after nitrogen addition. The varied soil nutrient conditions led to different responses in microbial diversity to nitrogen deposition, with nitrogen treatments primarily shaping microbial communities through changes in soil pH and nitrogen availability. This study provides essential insights into the scientific and sustainable management of subtropical plantation forest ecosystems.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hou2024differential,
  author = {Zheng Hou and Xiao‐Hua Zhang and Wen Chen and Ziqi Liang and Keqin Wang and Ya Zhang and Yali Song},
  title = {{Differential Responses of Bacterial and Fungal Community Structure in Soil to Nitrogen Deposition in Two Planted Forests in Southwest China in Relation to pH}},
  booktitle = {Forests},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/f15071112},
}
Figure