Differential Phasing between Circadian Clocks in the Brain and Peripheral Organs in Humans

Jacob Hughey, Atul J. ButteJournal of Biological Rhythms 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals a surprising ~8.5-hour phase delay in human brain circadian clock gene expression compared to human blood. This finding challenges the assumption of synchronized peripheral clocks in humans and suggests the human brain clock behaves more like the "master" SCN clock than other peripheral tissues.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Our bodies are governed by internal biological clocks, known as circadian clocks, that regulate a vast array of physiological processes over a roughly 24-hour cycle. These clocks are not confined to a single location but are distributed throughout the body, with a "master clock" in the suprachiasmatic nucleus (SCN) of the brain coordinating peripheral clocks in organs like the liver, heart, and even blood cells. While studies in mice suggest these clocks are generally synchronized (in phase), the situation in humans is less clear. Specifically, it's unknown if human peripheral clocks, like those in the brain and blood, maintain a consistent phase relationship. This lack of understanding is critical because disruptions in circadian timing are linked to various health issues, including metabolic disorders, sleep disturbances, and even cancer.

Methods

The researchers employed a meta-analysis approach, combining data from multiple publicly available gene expression datasets. They focused on "clock genes," which are core components of the circadian machinery and are known to oscillate rhythmically.

Key techniques included:

  • Data Curation and Integration: They gathered data from five human studies (three blood, two brain) and numerous other studies on various mammalian species and organs.
  • Metadata Processing: They standardized time information, converting local times to circadian times (CT) using sunrise times where necessary. Biological sex was also inferred from gene expression data.
  • Expression Data Processing: Microarray data was processed using a tool called "metapredict" for normalization and log-transformation. RNA-seq data was quantified and then made comparable to microarray data.
  • Ortholog Mapping: Genes from non-human species were mapped to their human counterparts to allow for cross-species comparisons.
  • Batch Effect Correction: To account for variations between different studies and individuals, they used ComBat to adjust gene expression values, correcting by subject for blood and by anatomical area for brain data.
  • Circadian Phase Analysis: A periodic smoothing spline (ZeitZeiger) was used to fit gene expression data over circadian time. This allowed them to estimate the time of peak and trough expression for each gene.
  • Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR): This metric was used to quantify the strength of the circadian rhythmicity for each gene.

Datasets

The study utilized a comprehensive collection of publicly available gene expression datasets:

  • Human Data:
    • Five datasets were analyzed for human circadian gene expression:
  • Three from blood (GSE39445, GSE48113, GSE56931) * Two from brain (GSE45642, GSE71620)
    • Additional data from human skin and hair follicles were curated from published results.
  • Non-Human Mammalian Data:
    • Seven datasets from mice and three from rats were analyzed.
  • Published results from nine other mammalian species were included.
  • SCN Data:
    • Studies of clock gene expression in the mammalian suprachiasmatic nucleus (SCN) were curated from published in situ hybridization studies and analyzed from two genome-wide mouse SCN datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Human Brain Clock is "Different": The most striking finding is that the human brain clock's phasing is significantly delayed compared to human blood. This suggests that not all peripheral clocks in humans are synchronized, and the brain clock might operate under a different regulatory principle.
  • Brain Clock Mimics the SCN: Intriguingly, the human brain clock's phasing closely resembles that of the SCN, the master clock. This implies that the brain might maintain a more direct or tightly regulated connection to the SCN's timing signals compared to other peripheral organs.
  • Species-Specific Differences in Clock Alignment: While nocturnal and diurnal mammals generally show a ~12-hour phase difference in peripheral organs (outside the SCN), human brain bucks this trend. This highlights that evolutionary adaptations in circadian timing might extend beyond just the light-dark cycle response to include how different organs coordinate their internal rhythms.
  • Age Matters: The study confirmed previous findings that clock gene expression in the human brain is affected by age, with older individuals showing an advanced phase. This underscores the dynamic nature of circadian rhythms throughout the lifespan.
  • Meta-Analysis Power: The paper demonstrates the significant value of combining data from multiple studies (a meta-analysis) to uncover subtle but important biological patterns that might be missed in individual datasets.

Key Results

  • Human Brain vs. Blood: After controlling for age, human brain clock gene expression was phase-delayed by approximately 8.5 hours relative to human blood.
  • Diurnal vs. Nocturnal Species: In most tissues outside the SCN, clock gene orthologs showed a phase difference of about 12 hours between diurnal and nocturnal species.
  • SCN Phasing: Peak times in the SCN were nearly identical across species, regardless of diurnal or nocturnal behavior.
  • Age-Related Shift: Older individuals (>40 years) showed an advanced phase in brain clock gene expression compared to younger individuals.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Postmortem Tissue: The brain datasets were derived from postmortem tissue. While the authors performed analyses to mitigate potential artifacts from postmortem interval and pH changes, this remains a limitation. They argue that the consistency across genes and datasets, and the rapid death of donors, make this unlikely to be the sole explanation.
  • Limited Human Organ Data: The study had limited data for human peripheral organs beyond blood and brain.
  • SCN Data Limitations: Much of the SCN data was from rodents and relied on in situ hybridization, which measures expression in specific cells rather than whole tissue.
  • Future Directions:
    • Replication of findings in additional studies, particularly using fresh human brain tissue.
  • Further investigation into the mechanisms by which the human brain clock aligns with the SCN and how this differs from other peripheral organs.
  • Exploring the implications of these phase differences for chronotherapy, suggesting that optimal drug timing might be organ-specific.
  • Understanding how environmental factors (e.g., social jetlag, artificial light) might contribute to circadian misalignment within the body.
  • Investigating circadian rhythms in different cell types within the brain and other tissues.

Summary updated

Abstract

The daily timing of mammalian physiology is coordinated by circadian clocks throughout the body. Although measurements of clock gene expression indicate that these clocks in mice are normally in phase with each other, the situation in humans remains unclear. We used publicly available data from five studies, comprising over 1000 samples, to compare the phasing of circadian gene expression in human brain and human blood. Surprisingly, after controlling for age, clock gene expression in brain was phase-delayed by ~8.5 h relative to that of blood. We then examined clock gene expression in two additional human organs and in organs from nine other mammalian species, as well as in the suprachiasmatic nucleus (SCN). In most tissues outside the SCN, the expression of clock gene orthologs showed a phase difference of ~12 h between diurnal and nocturnal species. The exception to this pattern was human brain, whose phasing resembled that of the SCN. Our results highlight the value of a multi-tissue, multi-species meta-analysis, and have implications for our understanding of the human circadian system.
BibTeX
@article{hughey2016differential,
  author = {Jacob Hughey and Atul J. Butte},
  title = {{Differential Phasing between Circadian Clocks in the Brain and Peripheral Organs in Humans}},
  journal = {Journal of Biological Rhythms},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1177/0748730416668049},
}
Figure