Differential occupational risks to healthcare workers from SARS-CoV-2 observed during a prospective observational study

David W. Eyre, Sheila Lumley, Denise O’Donnell, Mark Campbell, Elizabeth Sims, Elaine Lawson, Fiona C Warren, Tim James, Stuart Cox, Alison Howarth, George Doherty, Stephanie B. Hatch, James Kavanagh, Kevin Chau, Philip W. Fowler, Jeremy Swann, Denis Volk, Fan Yang-Turner, Nicole Stoesser, Philippa C. Matthews, Maria Dudareva, T. J. Davies, R. H. Shaw, Leon Peto, Louise Downs, Alexander Vogt, Ali Amini, Bernadette Young, Philip G. Drennan, Alexander J. Mentzer, Donal Skelly, Fredrik Karpe, Matt J. Neville, Monique Andersson, Andrew Brent, Nicola Jones, Lucas Martins Ferreira, Thomas Christott, Brian D. Marsden, Sarah Hoosdally, Richard J. Cornall, Derrick W. Crook, David I. Stuart, Gavin Screaton, Adam Watson, A Taylor, Alan Chetwynd, Alexander Grassam-Rowe, Alexandra Mighiu, Angus Livingstone, Annabel Killen, Caitlin Rigler, Callum Harries, Cameron East, Charlotte Lee, Chris Mason, Christian Holland, Connor Thompson, Conor Hennesey, Constantinos Savva, David Kim, Edward Harris, Euan J McGivern, Evelyn Qian, Evie Rothwell, Francesca Back, Gabriella Kelly, Gareth Watson, Gregory Howgego, Hannah Chase, Hannah Danbury, Hannah Laurenson-Schafer, Harry Ward, Holly Hendron, Imogen C Vorley, Isabel Tol, James Gunnell, Jocelyn Ward, Jonathan Drake, Joseph D. Wilson, Joshua Morton, Julie Dequaire, Katherine O’Byrne, Kenzo Motohashi, Kirsty Harper, Krupa Ravi, Lancelot Jamie Millar, Liam J Peck, Madeleine Oliver, Marcus Rex English, Mary Kumarendran, Matthew Wedlich, Olivia Ambler, Oscar Deal, Owen Sweeney, Philip Cowie, Rebecca te Water Naudé, Rebecca Young, Rosie Freer, Samuel ScotteLife 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigated the occupational risks of SARS-CoV-2 infection among healthcare workers (HCWs) at a UK teaching hospital. It found that while household contact and working in COVID-19-facing areas significantly increased risk, specific roles like porters and cleaners, and certain ethnic groups (Black and Asian staff), faced higher risks even after accounting for these factors. Intensive care unit (ICU) staff, however, showed a reduced risk, likely due to comprehensive personal protective equipment (PPE) protocols.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As the COVID-19 pandemic unfolded, a critical question emerged: who among healthcare workers was most at risk of infection, and why? Understanding these differential risks was crucial for implementing targeted infection control measures, protecting staff, and ensuring the continuity of healthcare services. While early studies suggested higher incidence in HCWs compared to the general population, there was a need for a comprehensive analysis within a single institution that examined a wide range of occupational roles, demographics, and exposure scenarios, including both symptomatic and asymptomatic infections. This paper aims to fill that gap by providing a detailed breakdown of COVID-19 risk factors among a large cohort of hospital staff.

Methods

The study employed a prospective observational design, utilizing voluntary COVID-19 testing programs for both symptomatic and asymptomatic staff at Oxford University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust (OUH). This involved:

  • Nasopharyngeal/Oropharyngeal PCR testing: To detect active SARS-CoV-2 infections.
  • Immunoassays for IgG antibodies: To identify past infections.
  • Questionnaires: To collect data on potential risk factors, including demographics (age, gender, ethnicity), occupational role and specialty, working location (COVID-19-facing vs. non-facing areas), household contact with confirmed cases, and self-reported symptoms.

Statistical analysis involved univariable and multivariable logistic regression to identify risk factors associated with infection. The study also analyzed the duration of PCR positivity and explored the relationship between patient infectious pressure and staff infection rates at both hospital building and ward levels.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from the voluntary COVID-19 testing program at Oxford University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust (OUH). This included:

  • PCR test results: For 10,034 staff members.
  • Serology (IgG antibody) test results: For 9,958 staff members.
  • Questionnaire data: Collected from 10,032 asymptomatic staff, covering demographics, occupational details, and exposure history.

This dataset represents a comprehensive collection of testing and risk factor information from a large healthcare institution during the early stages of the pandemic.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond the obvious: While working in COVID-19-facing areas was a significant risk factor, the study revealed that even in non-COVID-19 areas, there were sporadic outbreaks, suggesting that staff-to-staff transmission played a notable role.
  • The protective effect of ICUs: Intensive care unit (ICU) staff, despite being in close proximity to critically ill patients, showed a significantly lower risk of infection. This highlights the power of a comprehensive "bundle" of infection control measures, including rigorous PPE protocols, training, and dedicated facilities.
  • Socioeconomic and ethnic disparities: The study underscored existing health disparities, showing that Black and Asian staff, as well as porters and cleaners, faced higher risks, even after accounting for other factors. This points to the influence of socioeconomic factors and potential structural inequalities.
  • Household contact as a major driver: A confirmed household contact with a COVID-19 case was one of the strongest predictors of infection among staff, emphasizing the importance of community transmission impacting healthcare workers.

Key Results

  • Overall prevalence: 11.2% (1128/10,034) of staff had evidence of COVID-19 at some time.
  • Household contact: Staff with a confirmed household contact were at the greatest risk (aOR 4.82).
  • COVID-19-facing areas: Staff working in these areas had a higher rate of infection (22.6% vs. 8.6% elsewhere; aOR 2.47).
  • Specific hospital areas: Acute medicine wards showed higher rates (aOR 1.52), while COVID-19 intensive care units (ICUs) were protective (aOR 0.44).
  • Occupational roles: Porters and cleaners had the highest rates (aOR 2.06).
  • Ethnic groups: Black staff (aOR 1.66) and Asian staff (aOR 1.51) had increased risk, independent of other factors.
  • PCR positivity duration: 24% of staff remained PCR-positive at ≥6 weeks post-diagnosis.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Cross-sectional nature and recall bias: The study relied on retrospective data for serology and self-reported symptoms, which can be subject to recall bias. Reconstructing week-by-week incidence was partially based on symptomatic staff testing and staff recall.
  • Unknown antibody response: The proportion of staff who mounted no detectable antibody response or whose antibodies waned by the time of testing is unknown.
  • Voluntary testing: The voluntary nature of the testing program might have introduced selection bias if staff with perceived higher risk were more likely to participate.
  • Single institution: Findings are from one UK teaching hospital and may not be generalizable to all settings.

The authors suggest that future viral genome sequencing studies could help elucidate the relative contributions of patient-to-staff versus staff-to-staff transmission. They also emphasize the need for further research into the role of social inequality in COVID-19 transmission and the potential impact of immunity on future surges. The study's large cohort provides a valuable resource for future investigations into antibody-mediated protection.

Summary updated

Abstract

We conducted voluntary Covid-19 testing programmes for symptomatic and asymptomatic staff at a UK teaching hospital using naso-/oro-pharyngeal PCR testing and immunoassays for IgG antibodies. 1128/10,034 (11.2%) staff had evidence of Covid-19 at some time. Using questionnaire data provided on potential risk-factors, staff with a confirmed household contact were at greatest risk (adjusted odds ratio [aOR] 4.82 [95%CI 3.45-6.72]). Higher rates of Covid-19 were seen in staff working in Covid-19-facing areas (22.6% vs. 8.6% elsewhere) (aOR 2.47 [1.99-3.08]). Controlling for Covid-19-facing status, risks were heterogenous across the hospital, with higher rates in acute medicine (1.52 [1.07-2.16]) and sporadic outbreaks in areas with few or no Covid-19 patients. Covid-19 intensive care unit staff were relatively protected (0.44 [0.28-0.69]), likely by a bundle of PPE-related measures. Positive results were more likely in Black (1.66 [1.25-2.21]) and Asian (1.51 [1.28-1.77]) staff, independent of role or working location, and in porters and cleaners (2.06 [1.34-3.15]).
BibTeX
@inproceedings{eyre2020differential,
  author = {David W. Eyre and Sheila Lumley and Denise O’Donnell and Mark Campbell and Elizabeth Sims and Elaine Lawson and Fiona C Warren and Tim James and Stuart Cox and Alison Howarth and George Doherty and Stephanie B. Hatch and James Kavanagh and Kevin Chau and Philip W. Fowler and Jeremy Swann and Denis Volk and Fan Yang-Turner and Nicole Stoesser and Philippa C. Matthews and Maria Dudareva and T. J. Davies and R. H. Shaw and Leon Peto and Louise Downs and Alexander Vogt and Ali Amini and Bernadette Young and Philip G. Drennan and Alexander J. Mentzer and Donal Skelly and Fredrik Karpe and Matt J. Neville and Monique Andersson and Andrew Brent and Nicola Jones and Lucas Martins Ferreira and Thomas Christott and Brian D. Marsden and Sarah Hoosdally and Richard J. Cornall and Derrick W. Crook and David I. Stuart and Gavin Screaton and Adam Watson and A Taylor and Alan Chetwynd and Alexander Grassam-Rowe and Alexandra Mighiu and Angus Livingstone and Annabel Killen and Caitlin Rigler and Callum Harries and Cameron East and Charlotte Lee and Chris Mason and Christian Holland and Connor Thompson and Conor Hennesey and Constantinos Savva and David Kim and Edward Harris and Euan J McGivern and Evelyn Qian and Evie Rothwell and Francesca Back and Gabriella Kelly and Gareth Watson and Gregory Howgego and Hannah Chase and Hannah Danbury and Hannah Laurenson-Schafer and Harry Ward and Holly Hendron and Imogen C Vorley and Isabel Tol and James Gunnell and Jocelyn Ward and Jonathan Drake and Joseph D. Wilson and Joshua Morton and Julie Dequaire and Katherine O’Byrne and Kenzo Motohashi and Kirsty Harper and Krupa Ravi and Lancelot Jamie Millar and Liam J Peck and Madeleine Oliver and Marcus Rex English and Mary Kumarendran and Matthew Wedlich and Olivia Ambler and Oscar Deal and Owen Sweeney and Philip Cowie and Rebecca te Water Naudé and Rebecca Young and Rosie Freer and Samuel Scott},
  title = {{Differential occupational risks to healthcare workers from SARS-CoV-2 observed during a prospective observational study}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.60675},
}
Figure