TL;DR
This study reveals that HIV-1 proviruses in children on long-term antiretroviral therapy (ART) have significantly more large internal deletions, particularly in the env gene, compared to adults on ART. This suggests distinct selection pressures shape the viral landscape in children, potentially impacting strategies for measuring the HIV reservoir and achieving remission.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Despite effective antiretroviral therapy (ART), HIV-1 reservoirs persist in infected individuals, posing a significant challenge for achieving a cure. While ART dramatically reduces viral replication, intact proviruses remain integrated into the host genome, acting as a hidden reservoir. Understanding the genetic makeup of these persistent proviruses is crucial for developing strategies to eliminate them. Previous research has characterized these reservoirs in adults and in children with shorter ART durations or prior to treatment. However, a detailed understanding of the proviral landscape in children who have been on long-term ART (several years) was lacking. This gap is critical because children with perinatally acquired HIV face a lifetime on ART, and the long-term effects of HIV and ART on their health and the viral reservoir are not fully understood. This paper aims to fill this gap by characterizing the genetic defects in proviruses from children on long-term ART and comparing them to various other cohorts.
Methods
The researchers employed near-full-length HIV single-genome sequencing (NFL-SGS) to analyze proviral DNA extracted from the peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) of five children on long-term ART. This technique allows for the sequencing of almost the entire HIV-1 genome from individual proviruses. The obtained sequences were then analyzed using the Proviral Sequence Annotation & Intactness Test (ProSeq-IT) tool. This computational tool is designed to identify various genetic defects within proviruses, including insertions, deletions, premature stop codons, and mutations in key regions like the major splice donor (MSD) site and packaging signal. The analysis focused on characterizing the types and frequencies of these defects, comparing the findings to previously published datasets from different cohorts. Statistical analyses, including Fisher's exact test, chi-square tests, and binomial tests, were used to determine the significance of observed differences between groups.
Datasets
The study utilized the following datasets:
- CHER cohort: PBMCs from five children with vertically acquired HIV-1 on long-term ART (approximately 7-9 years). This is the primary dataset for this study.
- Previously published datasets:
- Infants prior to ART initiation (EIT Pre-ART).
- Children on short-term ART (<1 year) after early ART initiation (EIT On-ART).
- Children on short-term ART (<2.5 years) after delayed ART initiation (EIT Delayed-ART).
- Adults on ART for a median of 9.26 years.
These datasets allowed for comparative analysis across different stages of ART treatment and age groups.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Children's reservoirs are heavily "scoured": The most striking finding is the significantly higher proportion of proviruses with large internal deletions in children on long-term ART compared to adults. This suggests a more aggressive selection process against intact or less-defective proviruses in pediatric populations.
- Env gene is a prime target for deletion: The env gene, crucial for viral entry and infectivity, is disproportionately deleted in these children's proviruses. This points to a strong pressure to eliminate proviruses that can express this critical surface protein.
- Defects accumulate over time: Proviruses that are not completely deleted tend to accumulate multiple defects, not just single mutations. This suggests a multi-hit mechanism for viral inactivation on ART.
- MSD and packaging signal are more preserved in children: Interestingly, defects in the major splice donor site (MSD) and packaging signal were less frequent in children on ART compared to adults. This has implications for the reliability of certain diagnostic tools (like IPDA) that rely on these regions.
- Tat is more frequently defective in children: Conversely, the tat gene, involved in viral gene expression, showed a higher frequency of defects in children on ART.
Key Results
- Only 2.5% of proviruses in children on long-term ART were inferred to be sequence-intact, which is significantly lower than in adults on ART (approximately 5.9%).
- Large internal deletions (<7 kb) were found in 82% of defective proviruses in the CHER children, a higher proportion than in adults on ART (71%).
- Among proviruses retaining the env gene, over 80% contained two or more defects, commonly stop codons or gag start mutations.
- Defects in the major splice donor site (MSD) and packaging signal were significantly less frequent in children on ART (less than 21%) compared to adults (around 38%).
- The tat gene was more frequently defective in children on ART.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge the small sample size of five children in their primary cohort, which limits the generalizability of their findings. They also note that their NFL amplification approach precludes the detection of solo LTRs, which are known to constitute a significant portion of the proviral reservoir in some contexts.
Future work suggested by the study includes:
- Larger studies to confirm the observed dynamics and differences between children and adults.
- Further investigation into the role of env expression in the selection of proviruses and its impact on infected cell clone survival.
- Exploring the potential of targeting tat and rev (which are often retained in env-retaining proviruses) for immunotherapy strategies aimed at HIV remission.
- Developing new methods to capture both solo LTRs and proviruses with internal genetic information to fully characterize proviral landscapes.
- Investigating the differential selection pressures that may exist between children and adults, potentially influenced by immune system maturity and HIV-1 subtype.
Summary updated