Differential epithelial and stromal protein profiles in cone and non-cone regions of keratoconus corneas

Gary Hin‐Fai Yam, Matthias Fuest, Lei Zhou, Yu‐Chi Liu, Lu Deng, Anita Sook-Yee Chan, Hon Shing Ong, Wei‐Boon Khor, Marcus Ang, Jodhbir S. MehtaScientific 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that keratoconus (KC), a progressive corneal disease, involves widespread protein changes not just in the thinned "cone" region but also in the topographically normal "non-cone" areas. Using advanced proteomics, researchers found significant alterations in epithelial and stromal proteins, suggesting a peripheral involvement in KC development and offering new avenues for understanding and potentially treating the disease.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Keratoconus (KC) is a debilitating eye condition characterized by progressive thinning and irregular bulging of the cornea, often leading to vision loss and requiring corneal transplantation. While it's known that KC causes significant changes in the cornea, particularly in the "cone" region where thinning and mechanical weakening are most pronounced, it was unclear whether these pathological changes were confined to this localized area or extended to the rest of the cornea. This study aimed to address this gap by investigating the protein profiles of both the abnormal cone region and the topographically normal non-cone region of KC corneas, comparing them to each other and to healthy corneas. Understanding the full extent of molecular changes is crucial for unraveling the complex etiology of KC and developing effective interventions.

Methods

The researchers employed a powerful quantitative proteomics technique called Sequential Windowed Acquisition of All Theoretical Fragment Ion Mass Spectrometry (SWATH-MS). This method allows for the comprehensive and sensitive measurement of thousands of proteins in a sample. They applied this to epithelial and stromal tissue samples carefully dissected from the cone and non-cone regions of four advanced KC corneas, as well as from age-matched normal corneas.

Key steps included:

  • Sample Preparation: Precise manual dissection of cone and non-cone regions from KC corneas, followed by protein extraction.
  • SWATH-MS Analysis: High-throughput proteomic analysis to identify and quantify proteins.
  • Data Analysis: Statistical analysis to identify differentially expressed proteins (those with significant changes in abundance) between different sample groups (e.g., KC cone vs. normal, KC non-cone vs. normal, KC cone vs. KC non-cone). Stringent criteria were used to ensure reliability, requiring consistent changes across all four KC samples.
  • Bioinformatics Analysis: Ingenuity Pathway Analysis (IPA) and DAVID tools were used to interpret the biological functions and pathways affected by the identified protein changes.
  • Validation: Selected protein expressions were confirmed using immunohistochemistry and Western blotting on additional corneal samples.

Datasets

The study utilized corneal tissue samples from:

  • Four patients with advanced keratoconus (KC).
  • Two age-matched normal corneas.
  • For validation, additional archived KC, non-KC (corneal scar), and normal corneal specimens were used.

The data generated from the SWATH-MS analysis, including lists of identified and quantified proteins, are provided in supplemental files.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond the Cone: The most significant finding is that KC-associated protein changes are not limited to the visually apparent "cone" region. The topographically normal "non-cone" regions also exhibit substantial alterations in protein expression, suggesting a more widespread, potentially peripheral, involvement in the disease process.
  • Distinct Molecular Signatures: The epithelial and stromal compartments of the cornea have distinct molecular responses to KC. Epithelial changes were linked to mitochondrial function and metabolic disorders, while stromal changes pointed towards issues in cellular assembly, tissue organization, and connective tissue integrity.
  • Mitochondrial Dysfunction: A recurring theme in the epithelial changes was the involvement of mitochondria, suggesting that energy production and cellular respiration are significantly impacted in KC.
  • Connective Tissue Remodeling: In the stroma, alterations in proteins related to cellular assembly and connective tissue disorders highlight the breakdown and remodeling of the corneal matrix, which is critical for corneal structure and biomechanics.
  • Early Peripheral Involvement: The presence of significant protein changes in the non-cone region, even when it appears topographically normal, implies that the pathological cascade of KC may begin or extend to these areas earlier than previously thought.

Key Results

  • Differential Protein Expression: In all four KC samples, a significant number of proteins were differentially expressed: 20 epithelial proteins and 14 stromal proteins showed changes of at least 2-fold up or 0.5-fold down between the cone and non-cone regions.
  • Epithelial Pathways: Ingenuity Pathway Analysis revealed that altered epithelial proteins were significantly associated with "developmental and metabolic disorders," with "mitochondrion" being a key Gene Ontology (GO) term.
  • Stromal Pathways: The differential stromal proteome was linked to "cellular assembly, tissue organization, and connective tissue disorders," with "endoplasmic reticulum protein folding" identified as a significant GO term.
  • Validation: Immunohistochemistry confirmed the altered expression of selected proteins (NDUFB11, STEAP4, ADH7, IL1RN) in KC tissues, supporting the proteomic findings and highlighting their potential roles in KC pathogenesis. For instance, ADH7 showed stronger expression in KC non-cone stroma compared to cone stroma.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Size: The study acknowledges that it is a pilot study with a limited sample size (four KC patients). A larger cohort would improve the statistical power and confirm the findings more robustly.
  • Normal Cornea Comparison: While comparisons were made between KC cone, KC non-cone, and normal corneas, the normal corneas were analyzed as whole tissues. Future work could investigate potential differences in protein profiles between central and peripheral regions of normal corneas.
  • Manual Dissection: The manual dissection of cone and non-cone regions, while carefully performed, could be subject to variations. Future studies might explore more precise, automated dissection methods.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that future research should focus on larger sample sizes to confirm these findings and to derive potential mechanisms of action. Investigating these early biochemical changes in topographically normal eyes could lead to the identification of new biomarkers for early KC detection. Understanding the specific roles of these differentially expressed proteins could pave the way for novel therapeutic strategies targeting specific molecular pathways.

Summary updated

Abstract

Keratoconus (KC) is an ectatic corneal disease characterized by progressive thinning and irregular astigmatism, and a leading indication for corneal transplantation. KC-associated changes have been demonstrated for the entire cornea, but the pathological thinning and mechanical weakening is usually localized. We performed quantitative proteomics using Sequential Windowed Acquisition of All Theoretical Fragment Ion Mass Spectrometry (SWATH-MS) to analyze epithelial and stromal changes between the topographically-abnormal cone and topographically-normal non-cone regions of advanced KC corneas, compared to age-matched normal corneas. Expression of 20 epithelial and 14 stromal proteins was significantly altered (≥2 or ≤0.5-fold) between cone and non-cone in all 4 KC samples. Ingenuity pathway analysis illustrated developmental and metabolic disorders for the altered epithelial proteome with mitochondrion as the significant gene ontology (GO) term. The differential stromal proteome was related to cellular assembly, tissue organization and connective tissue disorders with endoplasmic reticulum protein folding as the significant GO term. Validation of selected protein expression was performed on archived KC, non-KC and normal corneal specimens by immunohistochemistry. This is the first time to show that KC-associated proteome changes were not limited to the topographically-thinner and mechanically-weakened cone but also non-cone region with normal topography, indicating a peripheral involvement in KC development.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yam2019differential,
  author = {Gary Hin‐Fai Yam and Matthias Fuest and Lei Zhou and Yu‐Chi Liu and Lu Deng and Anita Sook-Yee Chan and Hon Shing Ong and Wei‐Boon Khor and Marcus Ang and Jodhbir S. Mehta},
  title = {{Differential epithelial and stromal protein profiles in cone and non-cone regions of keratoconus corneas}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-019-39182-6},
}
Figure