Differential Adsorption Behaviors of Light and Heavy SPM Fractions on Three Antibiotics: Implications for Lacustrine Antibiotic Migration

Hao-Ran Tu, Jinlong Gao, Di Su, Yifeng Wang, Jinyu Gao, Yuran Wang, Hao Li, Qianjiahua Liao, Yufen ZhengWater 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how different components of suspended particulate matter (SPM) in Lake Taihu interact with common antibiotics. They found that the "light fraction" (LF) of SPM is a particularly strong adsorbent for antibiotics like tetracycline and norfloxacin, suggesting it plays a significant role in their transport and potential accumulation in aquatic ecosystems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Antibiotics are increasingly detected in aquatic environments, posing risks to both ecosystems and human health. Suspended particulate matter (SPM) in lakes acts as a major carrier for these contaminants, influencing their movement and fate. However, SPM is not a uniform substance; it's a complex mixture of organic and inorganic materials that can be fractionated. This paper addresses the knowledge gap regarding how different fractions of SPM, specifically light (LF) and heavy (HF) fractions, differentially adsorb and transport antibiotics. Understanding these differences is crucial for predicting antibiotic migration patterns in lakes and assessing associated ecological risks.

Methods

The researchers collected SPM from Lake Taihu and separated it into light fraction (LF) and heavy fraction (HF). The HF was further divided into weakly loose humus (WLH) and tightly bound humus (TH). They then conducted adsorption and desorption experiments using three common antibiotics: tetracycline hydrochloride (TC), norfloxacin (NOR), and trimethoprim (TMP).

Key techniques and analyses included:

  • Density Fractionation: Using sodium iodide (NaI) solutions of specific densities to separate SPM into LF and HF.
  • Sequential Extraction: Employed to further differentiate HF into WLH and TH.
  • Adsorption Kinetics: Experiments were performed over time to determine the rate at which antibiotics were adsorbed onto the SPM fractions. Kinetic models (pseudo-first-order, pseudo-second-order, and intraparticle diffusion) were used to analyze the adsorption process.
  • Adsorption Isotherms: Experiments were conducted at varying antibiotic concentrations to understand the equilibrium adsorption capacity. Langmuir and Freundlich models were applied to describe these isotherms.
  • Desorption Experiments: To assess how strongly the antibiotics were bound to the SPM fractions.
  • Spectroscopic Analysis: Fourier Transform Infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy and solid-state 13C Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) spectroscopy were used to characterize the functional groups present in the SPM fractions and how they changed after antibiotic adsorption.
  • Physicochemical Characterization: Measurements of total organic carbon, nitrogen content, cation exchange capacity (CEC), and specific surface area were performed.
  • Molecular Surface Electrostatic Potential (ESP): Used to understand the electronic properties of the antibiotics.

Datasets

Not applicable. This study involves experimental data generated from collected samples and laboratory analyses, rather than pre-existing datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • LF is a Super-Adsorbent: The light fraction (LF) of SPM consistently showed the highest adsorption rates and capacities for all three antibiotics tested, along with the lowest desorption rates. This suggests LF is a particularly effective "sink" for these contaminants.
  • Antibiotic Properties Matter: The adsorption behavior varied significantly between antibiotics. TC and NOR showed much higher adsorption than TMP, likely due to differences in their molecular structures and functional groups (e.g., presence of hydroxyl and carbonyl groups in TC and NOR that can interact with SPM).
  • Organic Matter is Key, but it's Nuanced: While higher organic matter content generally correlates with better adsorption, the study found that the type and arrangement of organic functional groups, particularly in LF (rich in aromatic carbon and functional groups like -C=O), are more critical than just the total amount.
  • LF's Role in Migration: Because LF remains suspended in the water column for longer periods and has a strong affinity for antibiotics, it poses a significant risk for antibiotic transport within aquatic ecosystems and potential entry into the food chain.
  • Desorption Differences: TMP was more easily desorbed from SPM compared to TC and NOR, indicating weaker binding. This suggests TMP might be more mobile in certain environmental conditions.

Key Results

  • Adsorption Kinetics: All adsorption processes followed a pseudo-second-order kinetic model, indicating that chemical adsorption played a significant role.
  • Adsorption Capacity: LF exhibited the highest adsorption capacity for TC (46.3 mg/g) and NOR (29.98 mg/g). For TMP, while LF still showed good adsorption (6.15 mg/g), other fractions also performed reasonably well.
  • Desorption Ratios: LF had the lowest desorption ratios for all antibiotics (e.g., 3.21% for TC, 2.21% for NOR, 7.21% for TMP), confirming strong binding. In contrast, TH showed the highest desorption ratios (e.g., 8.91% for TC, 8.28% for NOR, 44.01% for TMP).
  • Model Fitting: Langmuir and Freundlich models were used to describe adsorption isotherms, with results indicating a mix of monolayer and multilayer adsorption, often suggesting heterogeneous surfaces.
  • Functional Group Analysis: FTIR and NMR data revealed that LF has a higher proportion of aromatic carbon and specific functional groups (like -C=O) that contribute to its strong adsorption capabilities.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Lake Taihu Specificity: While the findings are significant for Lake Taihu, further research is needed to determine if these patterns hold true for other lake systems with different SPM compositions and environmental conditions.
  • Environmental Factors: The study focused on adsorption under controlled laboratory conditions. Future work should investigate how other environmental factors like pH, temperature, and the presence of other pollutants influence these adsorption behaviors in situ.
  • Long-Term Fate: While adsorption is a key process, the long-term fate and transformation of these antibiotic-SPM complexes in the environment, including their bioavailability and potential for biomagnification, warrant further investigation.
  • Ecological Risk Assessment: The authors highlight the need for increased attention to the ecological risks associated with LF's adsorptive transport, particularly concerning filter-feeding organisms. This suggests a need for more targeted ecological risk assessments.

Summary updated

Abstract

Lakes are important sinks for antibiotics as suspended particulate matters (SPMs) in lakes have become significant carriers of antibiotic adsorption and migration. The light and heavy fractions of SPM are involved in the process of suspension and sedimentation in the aqueous environment. Combined with the adsorption behaviors of antibiotics onto SPM, a basis for the risk of antibiotic migration in lakes will be provided. In this study, SPM from Lake Taihu was collected and grouped according to density as light fraction (LF) and heavy fraction (HF), with heavy fraction including loosely bound humus (WLH) and tightly bound humus (TH). Adsorption studies were carried out with three typical antibiotics: tetracycline hydrochloride (TC), norfloxacin (NOR), and trimethoprim (TMP). The adsorption processes of all particulate fractions towards antibiotics were fast, which is consistent with pseudo-second-order kinetics. The adsorption in the TC and NOR groups was much higher than that in the TMP group, which was mainly related to the properties of the antibiotics. The LF group was the special component with the fastest adsorption rate, the largest adsorption amount, and the lowest desorption ratio, regardless of antibiotics, which is related to the organic matter content and the rich-carbon-containing functional groups in the LF group, such as -C=O. These findings highlight the need for further attention to the high adsorptive transport effect of LF on antibiotics in lake ecosystems.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tu2025differential,
  author = {Hao-Ran Tu and Jinlong Gao and Di Su and Yifeng Wang and Jinyu Gao and Yuran Wang and Hao Li and Qianjiahua Liao and Yufen Zheng},
  title = {{Differential Adsorption Behaviors of Light and Heavy SPM Fractions on Three Antibiotics: Implications for Lacustrine Antibiotic Migration}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/w17131859},
}
Figure