Different factors drive the assembly of pine and Panax notoginseng-associated microbiomes in Panax notoginseng-pine agroforestry systems

Weijia Jia, Shu Wang, Xiahong He, Xiaoyan ZhaoFrontiers in Microbiology 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how converting pine forests into Panax notoginseng (P.n.)-pine agroforestry systems impacts the microbial communities associated with both pine trees and P.n. They found that the plant compartment (root, soil, etc.) is the primary driver of microbial assembly, with P.n. cultivation also influencing pine microbiomes and even transferring beneficial endophytes. These findings highlight the complex microbial dynamics crucial for sustainable agroforestry.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Agroforestry systems are promoted as sustainable land-use practices, but their impact on the intricate microbial communities living within and around plants is not well understood. These plant-associated microbes are vital for plant health, nutrient uptake, and overall ecosystem function. Specifically, this paper addresses the knowledge gap regarding how the conversion of traditional monoculture pine forests into mixed Panax notoginseng-pine agroforestry systems affects the microbial communities of both the pine trees and the medicinal P.n. plant. Understanding these shifts is key to optimizing agroforestry for both ecological sustainability and agricultural productivity.

Methods

The researchers employed high-throughput sequencing (16S rRNA for bacteria and fungal ITS for fungi) to analyze microbial communities. They collected samples from different plant compartments (roots, stems, leaves) and soil (rhizosphere and bulk soil) across four distinct land-use types: pure Pinus kesiya (P.k.) forest, pure Pinus armandii (P.a.) forest, P.n.-P.k. agroforestry system, and P.n.-P.a. agroforestry system. Statistical analyses, including PERMANOVA and RDA, were used to determine the influence of factors like compartment, pine species, P.n. cultivation, and genotype on microbial diversity and community structure.

Datasets

The study utilized microbial community data generated from 16S rRNA and fungal ITS gene sequencing of plant and soil samples collected from the field sites. The sequence data has been deposited in the National Center for Biotechnology Information Sequence Read Archive under Accession Numbers PRJNA821648 (16S RNA data) and PRJNA821834 (ITS data). No new benchmark datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Compartment is King: The physical location within the plant (root, soil, etc.) is the most significant factor shaping both pine and P.n. microbial communities, acting as a primary filter for microbial recruitment.
  • Fungi are More Sensitive: Fungal communities, particularly in pine trees, showed greater sensitivity to land-use changes (conversion to agroforestry) than bacterial communities.
  • P.n. Influences Pine: The presence of P.n. in the agroforestry system not only affects its own microbial community but also influences the assembly of pine-associated microbiomes, especially fungal diversity.
  • Microbial Transfer is Real: There's evidence of P.n. endophytes transferring to pine roots, and importantly, beneficial microbes known for plant growth promotion were found to increase in pine roots within the agroforestry system.
  • Pine Species Matters for Fungi: While pine genotype had limited impact, the specific pine species (P.k. vs. P.a.) did influence the community structure of pine-associated fungi.

Key Results

  • Conversion to P.n.-pine agroforestry systems significantly altered the diversity of pine-associated fungi but not their community structure. Conversely, P.n.-associated fungi showed altered community structure but not diversity.
  • Compartment was identified as the primary driver for both pine and P.n. microbial assembly, outweighing the influence of genotype.
  • P.n. cultivation significantly impacted the assembly of pine-associated microbiomes.
  • A transfer of P.n. endophytes to pine roots was observed, and beneficial microbes like Massilia, Marmoricola, and Herbaspirillum were enriched in pine roots.
  • Fungal communities were generally more responsive to land-use changes than bacterial communities.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that while P.n. cultivation significantly affected pine fungal diversity, its impact on pine bacterial communities was less pronounced. Future work could delve deeper into the functional roles of these transferred beneficial microbes and explore the specific mechanisms of endophyte transmission between P.n. and pine. Further research could also investigate the long-term stability and ecological implications of these microbial shifts in established agroforestry systems. The study focused on two pine species; expanding this to a wider range of pine species could provide a more comprehensive understanding of pine genotype effects.

Summary updated

Abstract

Land-use conversion affects the composition and assembly of plant-associated microbiomes, which in turn affects plant growth, development, and ecosystem functioning. However, agroforestry systems, as sustainable land types, have received little attention regarding the dynamics of different plant-associated microbes. In this study, we used high-throughput sequencing technology to analyze the assembly mechanisms and the driving factors of pine- and <i>Panax notoginseng</i> (<i>P.n.</i>)-associated microbiomes during the conversion of different pine forests (<i>Pinus kesiya</i> var. <i>langbianensis</i> and <i>Pinus armandii</i>) into <i>P.n.</i>-pine agroforestry systems. The results showed that the conversion of pure pine forest into <i>P.n.</i>-pine agroforestry systems significantly altered the diversity of pine-associated fungi rather than the community structure, and the community structure of <i>P.n.</i>-associated fungi rather than the diversity. Additionally, plant-associated fungi were more responsive to land-use change than bacteria. Main effect analysis revealed that compartment rather than genotype was the driving factor of pine- and <i>P.n.</i>-associated microbiomes, but <i>P.n.</i> cultivation also significantly affected the assembly of pine-associated microbiomes. In addition, there was a transfer of <i>P.n.</i> endophytes to pine trees in agroforestry systems and the beneficial microbiomes (Massilia, Marmoricola, Herbaspirillum, etc.) were enlarged in pine roots. Therefore, the diversity of the assembly mechanisms of <i>P.n.</i>- and pine-associated microbiomes played an important role in the <i>P.n.</i>--pine agroforestry systems and were the basis for the sustainable development of the <i>P.n.</i>--pine agroforestry systems.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jia2022different,
  author = {Weijia Jia and Shu Wang and Xiahong He and Xiaoyan Zhao},
  title = {{Different factors drive the assembly of pine and Panax notoginseng-associated microbiomes in Panax notoginseng-pine agroforestry systems}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Microbiology},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fmicb.2022.1018989},
}
Figure