Different Effects of Bacillus thuringiensis Toxin Cry1Ab on Midgut Cell Transmembrane Potential of Mythimna separata and Agrotis ipsilon Larvae

Yingying Wang, Zhaonong Hu, Wenjun WuToxins 2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates why Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) toxin Cry1Ab is much more toxic to the oriental armyworm (Mythimna separata) than the black cutworm (Agrotis ipsilon). By measuring the electrical potential across their midgut cells, researchers found that Cry1Ab causes a dramatic disruption of this potential in M. separata but has a minimal effect on A. ipsilon, explaining the observed toxicity differences and highlighting potential targets for pest control.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) toxins are widely used as biological insecticides and are engineered into crops for pest resistance. However, pests can develop resistance, and the effectiveness of specific Bt toxins varies greatly even among closely related species. The Cry1A family of Bt toxins, for instance, shows significantly different toxicity against insects in the Noctuidae family, but the underlying reasons for this differential susceptibility are not fully understood. This lack of understanding hinders the development of more effective and targeted pest control strategies. This paper aims to elucidate the mechanism behind the differential toxicity of Cry1Ab against two important noctuid pests, Mythimna separata (oriental armyworm) and Agrotis ipsilon (black cutworm), by examining the impact of the toxin on their midgut cell membrane potential.

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of bioassays and electrophysiological techniques.

  • Bioassays: Standard toxicity tests were performed to determine the Lethal Dose 50 (LD50) of Cry1Ab for M. separata and A. ipsilon larvae.
  • Force-feeding experiments: Larvae were fed a specific amount of activated Cry1Ab toxin, and their midgut apical membrane potential (Vam) was measured over time using intracellular microelectrodes. This method simulates ingestion and allows for observation of the toxin's effect in a more in-vivo-like setting.
  • In vitro incubation experiments: Isolated midgut epithelial cells were incubated with varying concentrations of activated Cry1Ab. The electrical membrane potential (both apical, Vam, and basolateral, Vbm) was then measured using microelectrodes. This technique allows for a more controlled assessment of the toxin's direct effects on the cell membrane, independent of other physiological factors.

The key electrophysiological technique used was intracellular recording with a glass microelectrode to measure the electrical potential difference across the midgut epithelial cells. This method, adapted from previous studies on other lepidopteran larvae, allows for precise measurement of Vam and Vbm.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on laboratory-reared insect populations and experimental solutions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Differential Sensitivity is Stark: The most striking finding is the vast difference in sensitivity to Cry1Ab between the two species. M. separata is significantly more susceptible, with an LD50 in the hundreds of nanograms per larva, while A. ipsilon appears largely unaffected even at much higher doses.
  • Apical Membrane is the Target: The primary site of action for Cry1Ab appears to be the apical membrane of the midgut epithelial cells. The toxin causes a significant depolarization (reduction in negative charge) of this membrane in susceptible larvae.
  • Basolateral Membrane is Unaffected: Interestingly, Cry1Ab did not show significant effects on the basolateral membrane potential in either species, suggesting a specific interaction with the apical side.
  • Mechanism of Action Linked to Ion Gradients: The depolarization of the apical membrane is consistent with the known mechanism of Bt toxins, which form pores that disrupt ion gradients across the membrane, leading to cell dysfunction and death. The lack of effect on A. ipsilon suggests a failure in toxin binding, pore formation, or subsequent downstream effects.
  • In Vitro vs. In Vivo: The in vitro experiments revealed an even greater difference in sensitivity than the bioassays or force-feeding, suggesting that the isolated cell system might be more sensitive to detecting subtle effects or that other physiological factors in vivo might offer some limited protection to A. ipsilon.
  • Potential for Targeted Control: Understanding these molecular differences opens avenues for developing more specific Bt toxins or strategies to overcome resistance in pests like A. ipsilon.

Key Results

  • Toxicity: M. separata larvae had an LD50 of 258.84 ng/larva for Cry1Ab, while A. ipsilon larvae remained alive even at 2000 ng/larva, indicating A. ipsilon is at least eightfold more tolerant.
  • Force-feeding: In M. separata, oral administration of 1 µg of activated Cry1Ab caused a significant depolarization of the apical membrane potential (Vam) from -82.9 mV to -19.9 mV within 8 hours. In contrast, A. ipsilon showed no obvious changes even with 5 µg of Cry1Ab.
  • In Vitro Depolarization: In M. separata midgut cells, Cry1Ab caused a concentration-dependent depolarization. The time to reach 50% depolarization (PR50) was 14.7 min at 1 µg/mL, 9.8 min at 5 µg/mL, and 7.6 min at 10 µg/mL.
  • Minimal Effect on A. ipsilon In Vitro: Even at a high concentration of 20 µg/mL, Cry1Ab only caused a 26.3% decrease in Vam in A. ipsilon midgut cells after 15 minutes.
  • Basolateral Potential: Cry1Ab had no significant effect on the basolateral membrane potential (Vbm) in either species.
  • Baseline Vam: The resting Vam of A. ipsilon (-33.19 mV) was approximately half that of M. separata (-80.94 mV), suggesting inherent differences in their midgut physiology.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors speculate that the observed differences in sensitivity are likely due to variations in insect habits, as well as diverse physiological or biochemical characteristics of the midgut cell membranes, such as differences in receptor binding affinity or the composition of midgut juice. However, these are speculative associations.

Future work could focus on:

  • Identifying Specific Receptors: Investigating the specific Bt toxin receptors on the midgut apical membranes of each species to understand why Cry1Ab binds effectively to M. separata but not A. ipsilon.
  • Characterizing Midgut Environment: Further characterizing the differences in midgut juice composition, pH, and enzyme activity between the two species, as these factors can influence toxin activation and efficacy.
  • Exploring Other Bt Toxins: Examining the effects of other Bt toxins (e.g., Cry1Ac, Cry2A) on these species to see if the observed differential sensitivity is specific to Cry1Ab or a broader phenomenon.
  • Genetic Basis of Resistance: Investigating the genetic basis for the tolerance of A. ipsilon to Cry1Ab, which could involve mutations in receptor genes or other detoxification mechanisms.

Summary updated

Abstract

Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) Cry toxins from the Cry1A family demonstrate significantly different toxicities against members of the family Noctuidae for unknown reasons. In this study, membrane potential was measured and analyzed in freshly isolated midgut samples from Mythimna separata and Agrotis ipsilon larvae under oral administration and in vitro incubation with Bt toxin Cry1Ab to elucidate the mechanism of action for further control of these pests. Bioassay results showed that the larvae of M. separata achieved a LD50 of 258.84 ng/larva at 24 h after ingestion; M. separata larvae were at least eightfold more sensitive than A. ipsilon larvae to Cry1Ab. Force-feeding showed that the observed midgut apical-membrane potential (V(am)) of M. separata larvae was significantly depolarized from -82.9 ± 6.6 mV to -19.9 ± 7.2 mV at 8 h after ingestion of 1 μg activated Cry1Ab, whereas no obvious changes were detected in A. ipsilon larvae with dosage of 5 μg Cry1Ab. The activated Cry1Ab caused a distinct concentration-dependent depolarization of the apical membrane; V(am) was reduced by 50% after 14.7 ± 0.2, 9.8 ± 0.4, and 7.6 ± 0.6 min of treatment with 1, 5, and 10 μg/mL Cry1Ab, respectively. Cry1Ab showed a minimal effect on A. ipsilon larvae even at 20 μg/mL, and V(am) decreased by 26.3% ± 2.3% after 15 min. The concentrations of Cry1Ab displayed no significant effect on the basolateral side of the epithelium. The V(am) of A. ipsilon (-33.19 ± 6.29 mV, n = 51) was only half that of M. separata (-80.94 ± 6.95 mV, n = 75). The different degrees of sensitivity to Cry1Ab were speculatively associated with various habits, as well as the diverse physiological or biochemical characteristics of the midgut cell membranes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2015different,
  author = {Yingying Wang and Zhaonong Hu and Wenjun Wu},
  title = {{Different Effects of Bacillus thuringiensis Toxin Cry1Ab on Midgut Cell Transmembrane Potential of Mythimna separata and Agrotis ipsilon Larvae}},
  booktitle = {Toxins},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.3390/toxins7124894},
}
Figure