Different DNA End Configurations Dictate Which NHEJ Components Are Most Important for Joining Efficiency

Howard H. Chang, Go Watanabe, C.a. Gerodimos, Takashi Ochi, Tom L. Blundell, Stephen P. Jackson, Michael R. LieberJournal of Biological Chemistry 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel in vitro system to dissect the complex nonhomologous DNA end-joining (NHEJ) pathway. They demonstrate that the specific configuration of DNA breaks, rather than just the presence of all NHEJ proteins, dictates which components are essential for efficient repair, leading to a more nuanced model of this critical cellular process.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) are a constant threat to genomic integrity, arising from various sources like radiation and replication errors. The primary repair mechanism for these breaks in eukaryotes is nonhomologous DNA end-joining (NHEJ). While the core components of NHEJ (Ku, XRCC4, DNA ligase IV) are well-established, the roles of accessory factors like Artemis, DNA-PKcs, polymerases (Pol μ, Pol λ), XLF, and PAXX are less clear, especially in vivo, where cellular context can confound interpretations. Previous in vitro studies often lacked a complete set of components or the sensitivity to analyze ligation efficiency and junctional sequences directly. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a comprehensive in vitro reconstitution system to precisely define the requirements for NHEJ depending on the specific DNA end structure.

Methods

The authors developed a sophisticated in vitro NHEJ reconstitution system. This involved incubating purified NHEJ proteins with radiolabeled DNA substrates representing different types of DSB ends (blunt, 5' overhangs, 3' overhangs, and combinations thereof). The key innovation here is the inclusion of a complete set of known NHEJ factors, including nucleases (Artemis), polymerases (Pol μ, Pol λ), and ligases (XRCC4-DNA ligase IV complex), along with accessory proteins (Ku, DNA-PKcs, XLF, PAXX).

NHEJ products were resolved using denaturing polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE). To quantify efficiency, the intensity of the ligated product bands relative to the substrate was measured. For detailed mechanistic insights, the ligated products were excised from the gel, PCR amplified, TA cloned, and sequenced. This allowed for the analysis of microhomology usage, nucleotide addition, and overall junctional integrity.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilizes in vitro synthesized DNA substrates with defined end configurations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • End Configuration is King: The most striking finding is that the specific structure of the DNA break dictates the minimal set of NHEJ proteins required for efficient repair. This challenges the notion that all NHEJ factors are always needed.
  • Artemis and DNA-PKcs for Resection: For DNA ends with 3' overhangs that can form microhomology (RD-compatible ends), the Artemis-DNA-PKcs complex is crucial for processing these overhangs to reveal the microhomology, which then facilitates ligation.
  • Pol μ as a Microhomology Generator: For incompatible 3' ends, where no inherent microhomology exists, Pol μ plays a critical role by adding nucleotides, thereby creating the necessary microhomology for ligation. This highlights its function beyond simple template-dependent synthesis.
  • Blunt Ends are Simple: Blunt-ended DNA breaks are repaired most efficiently by a minimal set of Ku and XRCC4-DNA ligase IV, suggesting a direct ligation mechanism that doesn't require extensive processing or accessory factors.
  • XLF and PAXX: Specific Roles: XLF and PAXX appear to have more specialized roles, with PAXX showing a stimulatory effect on blunt-end ligation and both XLF and PAXX synergistically enhancing the joining of 5' overhangs to blunt ends, potentially by stabilizing ends that don't rely on microhomology.

Key Results

  • RD-compatible 3' overhangs: Require Artemis and are strongly stimulated by Ku and DNA-PKcs, with efficiencies reaching 18% in the presence of all components.
  • Incompatible 3' ends: Show very weak joining without Pol μ, which stimulates it to ~4.6%.
  • Blunt ends: Are efficiently ligated by Ku and XRCC4-DNA ligase IV alone, with efficiencies around 12%, and are further stimulated by PAXX.
  • 5' overhang to blunt end: Is maximally repaired with Ku, DNA-PKcs, Artemis, X4·LIV, XLF, and PAXX, showing efficiencies up to 3%.
  • Sequencing data: Revealed that RD-compatible ends are processed to expose microhomology, while incompatible 3' ends rely on Pol μ for microhomology generation. Blunt ends undergo direct ligation, and 5' overhangs are resected to blunt ends before ligation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • In vitro vs. In vivo: While this system provides unprecedented resolution, it's an in vitro model. The authors acknowledge that in vivo studies can be confounded by cellular context, and future work could aim to bridge this gap further.
  • Specific Interactions: The paper proposes a model for how different end configurations dictate protein requirements. Further studies could explore the precise molecular interactions and dynamics of these protein complexes at various DNA break types.
  • Other DNA Break Types: The study focused on specific end configurations. Investigating a wider range of complex break structures, including those with gaps or more intricate overhangs, could provide a more complete picture of NHEJ.
  • The role of PAXX and XLF: While their roles are elucidated, their precise mechanisms of action, particularly how they interact with Ku and XRCC4/LIV, warrant further investigation.

The authors suggest that their findings support a flexible model of NHEJ, where the cellular machinery adapts its composition based on the nature of the DNA damage, a hypothesis they had previously put forth.

Summary updated

Abstract

The nonhomologous DNA end-joining (NHEJ) pathway is a key mechanism for repairing dsDNA breaks that occur often in eukaryotic cells. In the simplest model, these breaks are first recognized by Ku, which then interacts with other NHEJ proteins to improve their affinity at DNA ends. These include DNA-PK<sub>cs</sub> and Artemis for trimming the DNA ends; DNA polymerase μ and λ to add nucleotides; and the DNA ligase IV complex to ligate the ends with the additional factors, XRCC4 (X-ray repair cross-complementing protein 4), XLF (XRCC4-like factor/Cernunos), and PAXX (paralog of XRCC4 and XLF). In vivo studies have demonstrated the degrees of importance of these NHEJ proteins in the mechanism of repair of dsDNA breaks, but interpretations can be confounded by other cellular processes. In vitro studies with NHEJ proteins have been performed to evaluate the nucleolytic resection, polymerization, and ligation steps, but a complete system has been elusive. Here we have developed a NHEJ reconstitution system that includes the nuclease, polymerase, and ligase components to evaluate relative NHEJ efficiency and analyze ligated junctional sequences for various types of DNA ends, including blunt, 5' overhangs, and 3' overhangs. We find that different dsDNA end structures have differential dependence on these enzymatic components. The dependence of some end joining on only Ku and XRCC4·DNA ligase IV allows us to formulate a physical model that incorporates nuclease and polymerase components as needed.
BibTeX
@article{chang2016different,
  author = {Howard H. Chang and Go Watanabe and C.A. Gerodimos and Takashi Ochi and Tom L. Blundell and Stephen P. Jackson and Michael R. Lieber},
  title = {{Different DNA End Configurations Dictate Which NHEJ Components Are Most Important for Joining Efficiency}},
  journal = {Journal of Biological Chemistry},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1074/jbc.m116.752329},
}

Loading related content...

Figure