Different cryogenic behaviors of ideal Bose gases on scale-free networks with identical degree distribution

Pinchen Xie, Zhongzhi ZhangarXiv 2016 · arXiv

Abstract

We study ideal Bose gas upon two scale-free structures with identical degree distribution. Energy spectra belonging to tight-binding Hamiltonian are exactly solved and the related spectral dimensions of $G_1$ and $G_2$ are obtained as $d_{s_1} = 2$ and $d_{s_2} = 2 \ln 4/ \ln 3$. We show Bose-Einstein condensation will only take place upon $G_2$ instead of $G_1$. The topology and thermodynamical property of the two structures are proven to be totally different.

Introduction

In network science, the degree distribution—the statistical distribution of connections per node—is often considered the primary determinant of a network's physical properties. Scale-free networks, characterized by a power-law degree distribution $P(k) \sim k^{-\gamma}$, are known for their unique robustness and spreading dynamics. However, this paper challenges the assumption that degree distribution alone dictates the criticality of complex systems. By examining a quantum gas on two distinct networks with identical degree distributions, the authors demonstrate that topological differences can lead to fundamentally different thermodynamic behaviors, specifically regarding Bose-Einstein Condensation (BEC).

Network Construction and Methodology

The researchers constructed two deterministic scale-free networks, $G_1$ and $G_2$, using iterative rules. Starting from a single edge at $t=0$, the networks grow according to specific patterns. Both networks were engineered to share the exact same degree distribution $P(k) \sim k^{-2}$ in the thermodynamic limit.

Construction patterns and iterative growth of networks G1 and G2.

To analyze the physical properties, the authors employed a tight-binding Hamiltonian to model non-interacting bosons hopping between nodes. They used an iterative renormalization group (RG) technique to solve for the energy spectra (eigenvalues) of these massive structures, allowing for the analytical calculation of their spectral dimensions ($d_s$).

Topological and Spectral Analysis

Despite their identical degree distributions, $G_1$ and $G_2$ possess distinct topological features. $G_2$ exhibits "small-world" properties with high clustering, whereas $G_1$ does not. This difference is reflected in their spectral dimensions:

  • For $G_1$, the spectral dimension is exactly $d_{s1} = 2$.
  • For $G_2$, the spectral dimension is $d_{s2} = 2 \ln 4 / \ln 3 \approx 2.524$.

In statistical mechanics, the spectral dimension is a critical parameter for phase transitions. For an ideal Bose gas, BEC is generally forbidden in systems where $d_s \leq 2$ at any non-zero temperature. Consequently, $G_1$ sits exactly at the threshold where condensation is prohibited, while $G_2$ comfortably supports a phase transition.

Key Results: Bose-Einstein Condensation

Numerical simulations of the condensed fraction ($f$)—the ratio of particles in the ground state—as a function of normalized temperature ($\tilde{T}$) confirm the analytical predictions.

Condensed fraction f vs temperature T for G2.

As shown in the figure, $G_2$ displays a clear transition where the condensed fraction becomes significant below a critical temperature $T_c$. In contrast, $G_1$ fails to exhibit such a transition, with the condensed fraction vanishing in the thermodynamic limit. For a particle density of $\gamma = 0.2$, the critical temperature for $G_2$ was found to be approximately $0.107$.

Conclusion

This study proves that the degree distribution is insufficient to characterize the thermodynamic properties of complex networks. The spectral dimension, which captures the connectivity and diffusion properties of the graph, serves as a more reliable predictor for phase transitions like BEC. While the occurrence of the transition depends on the spectral dimension, the spatial distribution of the condensate itself is influenced by the degree distribution, suggesting a nuanced interplay between local connectivity and global topology.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study ideal Bose gas upon two scale-free structures with identical degree distribution. Energy spectra belonging to tight-binding Hamiltonian are exactly solved and the related spectral dimensions of $G_1$ and $ G_2$ are obtained as $d_{s_1} = 2$ and $d_{s_2} = 2 \ln 4/ \ln 3$. We show Bose-Einstein condensation will only take place upon $G_2$ instead of $G_1$. The topology and thermodynamical property of the two structures are proven to be totally different.
BibTeX
@misc{xie2016different,
  author = {Pinchen Xie and Zhongzhi Zhang},
  title = {{Different cryogenic behaviors of ideal Bose gases on scale-free networks with identical degree distribution}},
  year = {2016},
  eprint = {1606.03825},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1606.03825},
}
Figure