Different Circulation Pattern of Multiple Respiratory Viruses in Southern China During the COVID-19 Pandemic

Zhiqi Zeng, Wenda Guan, Yong Liu, Zhengshi Lin, Wenhua Liang, Jingyi Liang, Bingqian Chen, Tong Tong Wu, Yutao Wang, Chunguang Yang, Qiubao Wu, Zhitong Mai, Jinchao Zhou, Junhou Zhou, Zhoulang Wang, Zhijie Lin, Chaohui Hu, Chunqiu Wu, Pengyuan Zhu, Canxiong Chen, Nanshan Zhong, Eric H. Y. Lau, Chitin Hon, Yaoming Liang, Zifeng Yang, Jianxing HeFrontiers in Microbiology 2022 · DOI

Abstract

China implemented stringent non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) in spring 2020, which effectively suppressed SARS-CoV-2. In this study, we utilized data from routine respiratory virus testing requests from physicians and examined the circulation of 11 other respiratory viruses in Southern China from January 1, 2018, to December 31, 2020. A total of 58,169 throat swabs from patients with acute respiratory tract infections (ARTIs) were collected and tested. We found that while the overall activity of respiratory viruses was lower during the period with stringent NPIs, virus activity rebounded shortly after the NPIs were relaxed and social activities resumed. Only influenza was effectively suppressed with very low circulation extending to the end of 2020. Circulation of other respiratory viruses in the community was maintained even during the period of stringent interventions, especially for rhinovirus. Our study shows that NPIs against COVID-19 have different impacts on respiratory viruses.

Introduction

The implementation of non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs)—including mandatory mask-wearing, school closures, and travel restrictions—to combat the COVID-19 pandemic created an unprecedented natural experiment in community ecology. While these measures were designed to curb SARS-CoV-2, they fundamentally altered the transmission landscape for a wide array of common respiratory pathogens. This study investigates whether all respiratory viruses responded uniformly to NPIs and maps the "rebound" patterns of 11 different viruses in Southern China across a three-year period (2018–2020).

Methods

This retrospective study analyzed clinical data from Guangdong province, a major economic hub. The sample population consisted of 58,169 patients presenting with acute respiratory tract infections (ARTIs). Virological testing was performed using TaqMan real-time PCR assays on throat swabs to detect Influenza A & B (IAV, IBV), Respiratory Syncytial Virus (RSV), Rhinovirus (RHV), Adenovirus (ADV), Human Metapneumovirus (HMPV), Parainfluenza (PIV), and four seasonal Human Coronaviruses (HCoVs). The 2020 timeline was categorized into periods of stringent NPIs (lockdown) and subsequent phases of gradual relaxation and school reopening. Social activity was proxied using railway and road passenger flow data.

Results and Discussion

Overall Viral Activity and COVID-19 Correlation

The study found that 20.4% of the total patients tested positive for at least one of the 11 viruses. As shown in Figure 1, the overall positive rate of respiratory viruses plummeted during the period of "Strict Control" in early 2020, coinciding with the initial surge of COVID-19 cases. However, as NPIs were relaxed, a significant rebound in viral activity was observed.

Figure 1: Weekly positive rate of 11 common respiratory viruses compared to COVID-19 case counts from 2018 to 2020.

Differential Impact by Viral Structure

A key finding was the differential impact of NPIs based on viral characteristics. Enveloped viruses, such as influenza, were highly susceptible to interventions. IAV detection rates dropped from a 13.0% baseline to 0.0% by the end of 2020, likely due to their fragile lipid bilayer and the lack of "re-seeding" from international travel.

In contrast, non-enveloped viruses like Rhinovirus (RHV) and Adenovirus (ADV) proved remarkably resilient. RHV detection only dipped slightly from 9.7% to 9.2% during the strictest lockdown, suggesting robust household transmission or higher environmental stability. The timing and intensity of rebounds varied significantly by pathogen (Figure 2).

Figure 2: Positive rates of specific respiratory viruses (IAV, IBV, RSV, RHV, ADV, HMPV, PIV, HCoV) by age group and local mobility levels.

Pathogen-Specific Rebound Dynamics

RSV, which typically peaks in the spring in Southern China, saw its 2020 peak suppressed by lockdown measures. However, it experienced a massive late-summer surge to 21.6% once schools reopened, far exceeding historical levels. This suggests that the virus remained latent in the community and surged once social contact resumed.

Conclusion

NPIs against COVID-19 have had a profound but varied impact on the respiratory virus landscape. While influenza was nearly eradicated in the study region through 2020, other pathogens like rhinovirus and RSV persisted or rebounded aggressively. These findings highlight the importance of considering viral structure and transmission dynamics when designing public health interventions. The "missing" seasons for certain viruses may have also contributed to an "immunity debt," necessitating close monitoring of future outbreaks as social behaviors fully normalize.

Limitations

The study population skewed toward pediatric patients (median age 3.0 years), which may not fully reflect adult transmission. Additionally, testing was based on clinical suspicion rather than universal screening, potentially underestimating co-infections. The continued suppression of influenza is also tied to specific border policies that may change over time.

Summary updated

Abstract

China implemented stringent non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) in spring 2020, which has effectively suppressed SARS-CoV-2. In this study, we utilized data from routine respiratory virus testing requests from physicians and examined circulation of 11 other respiratory viruses in Southern China, from January 1, 2018 to December 31, 2020. A total of 58,169 throat swabs from patients with acute respiratory tract infections (ARTIs) were collected and tested. We found that while the overall activity of respiratory viruses was lower during the period with stringent NPIs, virus activity rebounded shortly after the NPIs were relaxed and social activities resumed. Only influenza was effectively suppressed with very low circulation which extended to the end of 2020. Circulation of other respiratory viruses in the community was maintained even during the period of stringent interventions, especially for rhinovirus. Our study shows that NPIs against COVID-19 have different impacts on respiratory viruses.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zeng2022different,
  author = {Zhiqi Zeng and Wenda Guan and Yong Liu and Zhengshi Lin and Wenhua Liang and Jingyi Liang and Bingqian Chen and Tong Tong Wu and Yutao Wang and Chunguang Yang and Qiubao Wu and Zhitong Mai and Jinchao Zhou and Junhou Zhou and Zhoulang Wang and Zhijie Lin and Chaohui Hu and Chunqiu Wu and Pengyuan Zhu and Canxiong Chen and Nanshan Zhong and Eric H. Y. Lau and Chitin Hon and Yaoming Liang and Zifeng Yang and Jianxing He},
  title = {{Different Circulation Pattern of Multiple Respiratory Viruses in Southern China During the COVID-19 Pandemic}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Microbiology},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fmicb.2021.801946},
}
Figure