Differences in Ureolytic Bacterial Composition between the Rumen Digesta and Rumen Wall Based on ureC Gene Classification

Di Jin, Shengguo Zhao, Nan Zheng, Dengpan Bu, Yves Beckers, Stuart E. Denman, Christopher S. McSweeney, Jiaqi WangFrontiers in Microbiology 2017 · DOI

Abstract

Ureolytic bacteria play a vital role in the rumen by producing urease enzymes that convert urea into ammonia, a critical precursor for microbial protein synthesis. Despite their importance, the diversity and spatial distribution of these microorganisms remain poorly understood. This study investigated the ureC gene profiles of ureolytic bacteria in dairy cows across three rumen fractions: liquid-associated bacteria (LAB), solid-adherent bacteria (SAB), and wall-adherent bacteria (WAB). High-throughput sequencing revealed that the WAB community is taxonomically distinct and significantly less diverse than the LAB and SAB communities. Notably, over 55% of the ureC sequences could not be assigned to known taxa, highlighting a substantial gap in our knowledge of the rumen microbiome. Urea supplementation did not significantly alter the bacterial composition, suggesting a stable community structure. These findings identify the rumen wall as a unique ecological niche and provide a foundation for managing urea hydrolysis to improve nitrogen efficiency in livestock.

Introduction: The Challenge of Nitrogen Efficiency

Urea is frequently used as a cost-effective nitrogen supplement in cattle diets. Rumen bacteria hydrolyze this urea into ammonia, which is then used to synthesize microbial protein. However, this process is often inefficient; rapid urea hydrolysis can lead to ammonia levels that exceed the bacteria's capacity for uptake, resulting in nitrogen waste and environmental pollution. Managing this process requires a precise understanding of the microbes involved. Because many rumen bacteria are unculturable, traditional methods fall short. This study addresses this gap by mapping the diversity and spatial distribution of these bacteria using the functional ureC gene as a marker.

Methods and Data Collection

The study involved six fistulated Holstein dairy cows in a two-period cross-over trial, comparing a control diet to one supplemented with 180g of urea per day. Researchers sampled three distinct rumen environments:

  1. Liquid-Associated Bacteria (LAB): Microbes in the rumen fluid.
  2. Solid-Adherent Bacteria (SAB): Microbes attached to feed particles.
  3. Wall-Adherent Bacteria (WAB): Microbes attached to the rumen lining (papillae).

The team targeted the ureC gene, the largest subunit of the urease enzyme, for sequencing. Using Illumina MiSeq and the GraftM bioinformatics tool, they analyzed 1,059,496 high-quality reads, identifying 588 Operational Taxonomic Units (OTUs) at 97% similarity.

Key Insights: A Specialized Niche on the Rumen Wall

The study revealed that the rumen wall is a specialized ecological niche. The WAB community differed significantly from the LAB and SAB communities in both composition and structure. This distinctiveness is likely driven by the host's secretion of urea through the rumen wall, creating a unique micro-environment.

Furthermore, the "unknown" majority is a striking finding: more than 55% of ureC sequences did not match known taxonomically assigned genes. This suggests that most urea-degrading bacteria in the rumen remain uncharacterized. Interestingly, while urea supplementation increased ammonia peaks, it did not change the community composition, indicating that these microbial populations are remarkably stable.

Results: Diversity and Taxonomy

Statistical analysis confirmed that the rumen wall (WAB) possesses significantly lower alpha diversity compared to the digesta fractions.

Figure 1: Alpha diversity measures (Observed, Chao1, and Shannon) for ureC rumen microbiomes across different treatments and fractions.

As shown in Figure 1, the Chao1 and Shannon indices for WAB were lower than those for SAB and LAB ($P < 0.01$). Beta diversity analysis (PCoA) also showed clear clustering of WAB samples away from the other fractions ($P = 0.001$). The most abundant classified families included Methylococcaceae, Clostridiaceae, Paenibacillaceae, and Helicobacteraceae. Genera such as Methylophilus and Marinobacter were notably more abundant in the WAB fraction.

Limitations and Future Directions

While DNA sequencing identifies the presence of microbes, it does not confirm their activity. Future research using transcriptomics (RNA sequencing) is necessary to determine which ureC genes are actively expressed. The high proportion of unclassified sequences underscores the need for improved reference databases and efforts to culture these "dark matter" microbes. Understanding these specific populations is a critical step toward developing targeted strategies to moderate urea hydrolysis and enhance nitrogen efficiency in dairy production.

Summary updated

Abstract

Ureolytic bacteria are key organisms in the rumen producing urease enzymes to catalyze the breakdown of urea to ammonia for the synthesis of microbial protein. However, little is known about the diversity and distribution of rumen ureolytic microorganisms. The urease gene (<i>ureC</i>) has been the target gene of choice for analysis of the urea-degrading microorganisms in various environments. In this study, we investigated the predominant <i>ureC</i> genes of the ureolytic bacteria in the rumen of dairy cows using high-throughput sequencing. Six dairy cows with rumen fistulas were assigned to a two-period cross-over trial. A control group (<i>n</i> = 3) were fed a total mixed ration without urea and the treatment group (<i>n</i> = 3) were fed rations plus 180 g urea per cow per day at three separate times. Rumen bacterial samples from liquid and solid digesta and rumen wall fractions were collected for <i>ureC</i> gene amplification and sequencing using Miseq. The wall-adherent bacteria (WAB) had a distinct ureolytic bacterial profile compared to the solid-adherent bacteria (SAB) and liquid-associated bacteria (LAB) but more than 55% of the <i>ureC</i> sequences did not affiliate with any known taxonomically assigned urease genes. Diversity analysis of the <i>ureC</i> genes showed that the Shannon and Chao1 indices for the rumen WAB was lower than those observed for the SAB and LAB (<i>P</i> < 0.01). The most abundant <i>ureC</i> genes were affiliated with Methylococcaceae, Clostridiaceae, Paenibacillaceae, Helicobacteraceae, and Methylophilaceae families. Compared with the rumen LAB and SAB, relative abundance of the OTUs affiliated with <i>Methylophilus</i> and <i>Marinobacter</i> genera were significantly higher (<i>P</i> < 0.05) in the WAB. Supplementation with urea did not alter the composition of the detected ureolytic bacteria. This study has identified significant populations of ureolytic WAB representing genera that have not been recognized or studied previously in the rumen. The taxonomic classification of rumen <i>ureC</i> genes in the dairy cow indicates that the majority of ureolytic bacteria are yet to be identified. This survey has expanded our knowledge of <i>ureC</i> gene information relating to the rumen ureolytic microbial community, and provides a basis for obtaining regulatory targets of ureolytic bacteria to moderate urea hydrolysis in the rumen.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jin2017differences,
  author = {Di Jin and Shengguo Zhao and Nan Zheng and Dengpan Bu and Yves Beckers and Stuart E. Denman and Christopher S. McSweeney and Jiaqi Wang},
  title = {{Differences in Ureolytic Bacterial Composition between the Rumen Digesta and Rumen Wall Based on ureC Gene Classification}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Microbiology},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3389/fmicb.2017.00385},
}
Figure