Differences in topological progression profile among neurodegenerative diseases from imaging data

Sara Garbarino, Marco Lorenzi, Neil P. Oxtoby, Elisabeth J. Vinke, Razvan Marinescu, Arman Eshaghi, M. Arfan Ikram, Wiro J. Niessen, Olga Ciccarelli, Frederik Barkhof, Jonathan M. Schott, Meike W. Vernooij, Daniel C. Alexander, for the Alzheimer’s Disease Neuroimaging InitiativeeLife 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces "topological profiles" – unique combinations of brain network properties that characterize how neurodegenerative diseases spread. By analyzing the full progression of atrophy over time, they show these profiles are distinct for Alzheimer's disease (AD), multiple sclerosis (MS), and normal aging, offering new insights into disease mechanisms and potentially aiding in early diagnosis.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Neurodegenerative diseases like Alzheimer's and MS involve the spread of pathology through the brain. Researchers have long suspected that the brain's structural connectivity plays a key role in mediating this spread. Previous attempts to model this often focused on individual network properties (like "centrality" or "network proximity") in isolation and typically used only late-stage disease data. This approach has limitations: it doesn't account for multiple spreading mechanisms acting simultaneously, and relying on end-stage data is like trying to understand a movie from just the final scene. This paper aims to overcome these limitations by developing a more comprehensive model that considers multiple network properties together and utilizes the full temporal trajectory of disease progression.

Methods

The core of this work is the development and application of a "topological profile" estimation method. This involves:

  1. Structural Connectome Generation: Using diffusion MRI data (from the Human Connectome Project), they construct an average structural connectome representing the brain's wiring.
  2. Topological Descriptor Calculation: They compute nine network metrics across five topological descriptors (centrality, segregation, network proximity, cortical proximity, and constant progression) for each region in the connectome. These descriptors aim to capture different ways pathology might spread.
  3. Disease Progression Modeling (DPM): They employ a Gaussian Process (GP) Progression Model to estimate the temporal evolution of brain atrophy from T1-weighted MRI data for AD, Primary Progressive Multiple Sclerosis (PPMS), and healthy aging (HA) cohorts. This model captures the full trajectory of atrophy, not just the end-stage.
  4. Topological Profile Estimation: They then estimate both cohort-level and individual-level topological profiles. These profiles are defined as a linear combination of the topological descriptors, where the weights (β) are learned to best match the observed atrophy progression rates derived from the DPM. This allows them to identify which combination of network properties best explains the observed disease spread.

Datasets

The study utilizes three main datasets:

  • Alzheimer's Disease Neuroimaging Initiative (ADNI): A large, well-established dataset for Alzheimer's disease research, including individuals with healthy control (HC), mild cognitive impairment (MCI), and Alzheimer's disease (AD) diagnoses.
  • UCL Queen Square Institute of Neurology: Data from individuals with Primary Progressive Multiple Sclerosis (PPMS) and healthy controls.
  • Rotterdam Scan Study (RSS): A prospective cohort study providing data on healthy aging (HA) individuals.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond Single Descriptors: The idea that a single network property can explain disease spread is too simplistic. Neurodegeneration likely involves a complex interplay of different mechanisms, best captured by a combination of topological descriptors.
  • The Power of Temporal Data: Using the full disease progression trajectory, rather than just late-stage snapshots, provides a much richer and more accurate picture of how pathology spreads and how network properties influence it.
  • Disease-Specific Signatures: Each disease (AD, PPMS, HA) exhibits a unique "topological profile," suggesting distinct underlying mechanisms of propagation. This is a significant finding that goes beyond simply observing different atrophy patterns.
  • Individual Variability and Clinical Relevance: While cohort profiles are distinct, individual profiles tend to cluster around their respective cohort profiles. Deviations from the cohort profile ("outliers") correlate with clinical features, hinting at potential for early risk stratification and diagnosis.

Key Results

  • Improved Model Fit: Topological profiles, as combinations of descriptors, explained the observed atrophy progression data significantly better than any single descriptor across all cohorts.
  • Distinct Cohort Profiles: The study identified unique topological profiles for AD, PPMS, and HA. For example, AD's profile was dominated by centrality and network proximity, while PPMS involved centrality, segregation, and cortical proximity. HA showed a strong component of cortical proximity and constant progression.
  • Individual Profile Clustering: Most individuals' topological profiles clustered around their cohort's profile when estimated using the full temporal data. This clustering was less pronounced when using only late-stage data.
  • Clinical Correlations:
    • AD outliers whose profiles were closer to the HA profile showed better cognitive function (higher MMSE).
  • HA individuals with profiles closer to the AD profile showed signs of cognitive impairment (lower MMSE) and a higher incidence of developing dementia.
  • Classification Accuracy: Using the GP Progression Model-driven topological profiles led to significantly higher correct classification rates for individuals into their respective cohorts compared to using late-stage data alone.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Connectome Simplification: The study used an average structural connectome from young healthy individuals, not subject-specific connectomes. While justified by the focus on underlying propagation mechanisms, future work could explore how individual connectome variations influence profiles.
  • Network Metric Interdependence: Some network metrics are highly correlated, potentially leading to overlapping progression patterns. The study acknowledges this but includes multiple metrics to capture variability.
  • Heterogeneity within Cohorts: The current approach models cohort-level profiles. Future work could explore topological profiling for more homogeneous subgroups within cohorts to better capture individual differences.
  • Clinical Utility: The authors suggest that topological profiles could be clinically useful for identifying individuals at risk, informing treatment, and potentially discriminating between different disease subtypes or progression trajectories. Further validation and application to broader patient groups are recommended.
  • Mechanistic Links: While the topological descriptors are linked to potential biological mechanisms (e.g., centrality to nodal stress), the authors note these links are simplistic and graph-theory metrics don't fully capture all biological nuances. Future work could explore more sophisticated models and integrate other data modalities.

Summary updated

Abstract

The spatial distribution of atrophy in neurodegenerative diseases suggests that brain connectivity mediates disease propagation. Different descriptors of the connectivity graph potentially relate to different underlying mechanisms of propagation. Previous approaches for evaluating the influence of connectivity on neurodegeneration consider each descriptor in isolation and match predictions against late-stage atrophy patterns. We introduce the notion of a <i>topological profile</i> - a characteristic combination of topological descriptors that best describes the propagation of pathology in a particular disease. By drawing on recent advances in disease progression modeling, we estimate topological profiles from the full course of pathology accumulation, at both cohort and individual levels. Experimental results comparing topological profiles for Alzheimer's disease, multiple sclerosis and normal ageing show that topological profiles explain the observed data better than single descriptors. Within each condition, most individual profiles cluster around the cohort-level profile, and individuals whose profiles align more closely with other cohort-level profiles show features of that cohort. The cohort-level profiles suggest new insights into the biological mechanisms underlying pathology propagation in each disease.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{garbarino2019differences,
  author = {Sara Garbarino and Marco Lorenzi and Neil P. Oxtoby and Elisabeth J. Vinke and Razvan Marinescu and Arman Eshaghi and M. Arfan Ikram and Wiro J. Niessen and Olga Ciccarelli and Frederik Barkhof and Jonathan M. Schott and Meike W. Vernooij and Daniel C. Alexander and for the Alzheimer’s Disease Neuroimaging Initiative},
  title = {{Differences in topological progression profile among neurodegenerative diseases from imaging data}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.49298},
}

Loading related content...

Figure