Differences in Privacy-Protective Behaviors by Internet Users in Korea and China

Chao Zhang, Lili Wan, Daihwan Min, Seong-Taek RimJournal of the Korea Society of IT Services 2012 · DOI

Abstract

Privacy-protective behavior can be classified into passive behavior and active behavior. Passive behavior includes refusal, misrepresentation, and removal, while word-of-mouth, complaint, and seeking for help belong to active behavior. Internet users in different countries may take different types of privacy-protective behavior because of cultural and social differences. This study analyzes the differences in Internet users' privacy-protective behavior between Korea and China. Korean Internet users take refusal, complaint, and seeking to protect their privacy information, while misrepresentation is not an option for Korean Internet users. Chinese Internet users take refusal, complaint, seeking, and misrepresentation to protect their privacy information. In Korea, passive behavior (refusal) is chosen more often than active behavior (complaint and seeking for help), while in China active behavior (complaint and seeking for help) is preferred to passive behavior (refusal and misrepresentation). The differences of privacy-protective behavior in the two countries may provide some implications for online companies, if they want to avoid the business risk due to privacy concerns and to take appropriate steps to deal with privacy-protective behavior by Internet users.

Introduction

While "privacy concern" is a well-documented psychological state, how that concern translates into actual behavior varies significantly across different regions. Most early research focused on Western populations, leaving a gap in our understanding of how users in major Asian markets react when they feel their data is at risk. This study investigates why users in two geographically close but culturally distinct nations—Korea and China—choose different "fight or flight" responses to privacy threats.

Categorizing Privacy-Protective Behaviors

The researchers categorized privacy-protective behaviors into two primary buckets: passive (refusal, misrepresentation, removal) and active (word-of-mouth, complaint, seeking help). Passive behaviors generally involve avoidance or obfuscation, while active behaviors involve external engagement to resolve the privacy threat.

Table 1: Initial constructs and dimensions of privacy-protective behavior.

Methodology

The study utilized a survey-based approach with 496 participants (250 from Korea and 246 from China), primarily consisting of undergraduate and graduate students. The researchers employed Exploratory Factor Analysis (EFA) to group behaviors and Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) to test the strength of the relationship between privacy concern and specific behaviors.

During the statistical refinement process, "removal" and "negative word-of-mouth" were dropped from the final model because they did not statistically distinguish themselves from other behaviors in this specific dataset. The remaining constructs showed high internal consistency and validity.

Table 2: Factor loadings for the refined measurement model.

Key Insights: Cultural and Regulatory Drivers

The analysis revealed that cultural values and local regulations significantly shape how users protect their data.

The "Real-Name" Barrier in Korea

One of the most striking findings is that misrepresentation (providing fake info) is not a significant strategy for Korean users. This is attributed to Korea’s "Internet real-name policy," which requires identity verification for many services. Because users cannot easily lie to systems that verify their ID numbers, they simply "refuse" to sign up instead.

Cultural Values (Hofstede’s Dimensions)

  • Korea: Higher Uncertainty Avoidance leads users to prefer the safety of passive refusal. If a site looks risky, they are more likely to walk away entirely.
  • China: Higher Masculinity and Long-term Orientation drive users toward active behaviors. They are more likely to complain or seek help to "fix" the situation or improve the service for the future, rather than just abandoning the platform.

Statistical Results

The SEM analysis provided standardized regression weights (path coefficients) that highlight these national differences:

  • Korea: The path from privacy concern to Refusal was the strongest (0.452), while Misrepresentation (0.128) was statistically insignificant.
  • China: All four behaviors were significant. Complaint (0.356) and Seeking (0.332) were the most prominent responses, outstripping Refusal (0.293) and Misrepresentation (0.252).

The final research model showed high statistical validity (GFI = 0.933, CFI = 0.957), suggesting the categorization of active vs. passive behavior is a robust framework for analyzing privacy responses.

Conclusion and Limitations

This study highlights that a "one-size-fits-all" approach to privacy management is insufficient for global online companies. While the study provides a strong foundation, it is limited by a sample heavily favored toward college students. Future work should aim to bridge the gap between Western and Eastern cultural values to create a truly global model of privacy behavior, incorporating more diverse demographics and refined behavioral factors.

Summary updated

Abstract

Privacy-protective behavior can be classified into passive behavior and active behavior. Passive behavior includes refusal, misrepresentation, and removal, while word-of-mouth, complaint, and seeking for help belong to active behavior. Internet users in different countries may take different types of privacy-protective behavior because of cultural and social differences. This study analyzes the differences in Internet users' privacy-protective behavior between Korea and China. Korean Internet users take refusal, complaint, and seeking to protect their privacy information, while misrepresentation is not an option for Korean Internet users. Chinese Internet users take refusal, complaint, seeking, and misrepresentation to protect their privacy information. In Korea, passive behavior (refusal) is chosen more often than active behavior (complaint and seeking for help), while in China active behavior(complaint and seeking for help) is preferred to passive behavior (refusal and misrepresentation). The differences of privacy-protective behavior in the two countries may provide some implications for online companies, if they want to avoid the business risk due to privacy concerns and to take appropriate steps to deal with privacy-protective behavior by Internet users.
BibTeX
@article{zhang2012differences,
  author = {Chao Zhang and Lili Wan and Daihwan Min and Seong-Taek Rim},
  title = {{Differences in Privacy-Protective Behaviors by Internet Users in Korea and China}},
  journal = {Journal of the Korea Society of IT Services},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.9716/kits.2012.11.1.093},
}
Figure