Differences in phyllosphere microbiomes among different Populus spp. in the same habitat

Jiaying Liu, Weixi Zhang, Yuting Liu, Wenxu Zhu, Zhengsai Yuan, Xiaohua Su, Changjun DingFrontiers in Plant Science 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

Even when growing side-by-side in the same soil and climate, different poplar (Populus) species cultivate distinct bacterial "neighborhoods" on their leaves. This study reveals that host-specific leaf chemistry—particularly carbon, nitrogen, and soluble sugars—acts as a primary filter, determining which microbes thrive in the harsh, nutrient-limited environment of the phyllosphere.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The "phyllosphere"—the total above-ground surface of plants—is one of the most extensive microbial habitats on Earth. While we know that host species significantly influence these microbial communities, it is often difficult to disentangle the effects of host genetics from environmental factors like microclimate, soil quality, and geographic location.

The authors addressed this by using a "common garden" approach. By studying six different Populus species and hybrids planted at the same time in the same location (Tongzhou, Beijing), they isolated the host's biological influence. They sought to answer two main questions: Do different poplar species host different bacterial communities under identical conditions? And which specific leaf traits (nutrients and sugars) drive these differences?

Methods

The researchers selected six Populus genotypes and collected leaf samples from the middle of the canopy. To characterize the microbial communities, they used 16S rRNA gene amplicon sequencing (targeting the V3–V4 region), a standard but robust technique for identifying bacterial taxa.

What sets this study apart is the integration of microbial data with physicochemical leaf analysis. They measured:

  • Total Carbon (C), Nitrogen (N), and Phosphorus (P).
  • Soluble sugars and starch content.
  • C/N ratios.

They then employed Redundancy Analysis (RDA) to statistically link these chemical "resource maps" to the microbial community structure. Finally, they used PICRUSt2 to predict the metabolic functions of the identified bacteria based on their genomic signatures.

Datasets

  • Primary Data: Newly generated 16S rRNA sequencing data, deposited in the NCBI SRA database under accession number PRJNA924105.
  • Reference Databases: The Silva_132 database was used for taxonomic classification, and the MetaCyc functional database was used for metabolic pathway prediction.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Host Identity is a Strong Filter: Despite "breathing the same air" and sharing the same soil, the six poplar species hosted significantly different bacterial communities. This confirms that the plant isn't just a passive landing pad; it actively (or chemically) selects its residents.
  • The Leaf as a Nutrient Buffet: The phyllosphere is generally considered a nutrient-poor "desert." The study found that leaf-borne nutrients are the primary drivers of community structure. Specifically, soluble sugars and starch were the main factors influencing alpha-diversity (the richness and evenness of species within a sample).
  • Nitrogen and Phosphorus as Gatekeepers: While sugars influenced diversity, leaf nitrogen and phosphorus levels were the main factors affecting the relative abundance of specific bacterial groups. This suggests that while sugars might allow many types of bacteria to survive, N and P levels determine who dominates the population.
  • Functional Stability: Interestingly, while the who (species composition) changed between hosts, the predicted what (metabolic function) was relatively consistent. Most bacteria were involved in biosynthesis pathways, suggesting that the core survival strategies required for life on a leaf are universal across these poplar species.

Key Results

  • Taxonomic Diversity: The study identified 31 phyla and 940 species. Proteobacteria (59–77%) and Actinobacteria (14–27%) were the dominant players across all samples.
  • The "YA" Outlier: Populus × euramaricana ‘Bofeng 3 hao’ (YA) exhibited the highest microbial richness and diversity, suggesting its leaf traits are particularly conducive to a broad range of bacteria.
  • Chemical Drivers: RDA showed that the six measured leaf nutrient factors explained 67.53% of the variation in bacterial community diversity.
  • Quantitative Significance: Soluble sugar ($p = 0.004$) and starch ($p = 0.046$) had the most statistically significant impact on diversity indices. At the phylum level, leaf nitrogen content was the standout driver ($p = 0.008$).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Snapshot in Time: The study relied on a single sampling event in August. Phyllosphere communities are known to shift seasonally, and a longitudinal study would provide a more dynamic view of these relationships.
  • Epiphytes vs. Endophytes: The methods focused on surface-dwelling bacteria (epiphytes). Future research could compare these to endophytes (bacteria living inside the leaf) to see if the same chemical drivers apply.
  • Prediction vs. Reality: Functional roles were predicted using PICRUSt2. While useful, these predictions should be validated with metatranscriptomics or proteomics to see which genes are actually being expressed on the leaf surface.
  • Causality: While the correlations between nutrients and microbes are strong, experimental manipulation (e.g., "painting" specific sugars onto leaves) would be needed to prove that these chemicals directly cause the observed community shifts.

Summary updated

Abstract

Previous studies have shown that a large proportion of the variation in the composition of phyllosphere microbial communities was explained by the hosts themselves. In contrast, leaf-borne nutrients were an available resource for bacteria living on the leaf surface, thus influencing the community structure of phyllosphere bacteria. These were similar to the conclusions obtained in this study. This study provides theoretical support for the study of the composition and structure of phyllosphere bacterial communities in woody plants and the factors influencing them.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2023differences,
  author = {Jiaying Liu and Weixi Zhang and Yuting Liu and Wenxu Zhu and Zhengsai Yuan and Xiaohua Su and Changjun Ding},
  title = {{Differences in phyllosphere microbiomes among different Populus spp. in the same habitat}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Plant Science},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fpls.2023.1143878},
}
Figure