Differences in beginner and expert neurointerventionalists” heart rate variability during simulated neuroangiographies

Dominik Hinzmann, Maximilian Singer, Valerie Schmelter, Kornelia Kreiser, Kim Gehling, Lea Ströber, Jan S. Kirschke, Christian Schulz, F SchneiderInterventional 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigated whether heart rate variability (HRV) can differentiate between beginner and expert neurointerventionalists during simulated procedures. They found significant differences in HRV metrics, suggesting that decreased HRV in experts might reflect a cardiovascular correlate of their focused effort and cognitive engagement, aligning with theories of neurovisceral integration.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The demand for interventional treatments for conditions like stroke is increasing, necessitating a skilled workforce of interventional neuroradiologists. Simulation training is a crucial tool for developing and assessing these skills. While work experience is known to correlate with improved performance in various fields, including medicine, the physiological underpinnings of this advantage, particularly during complex procedures, are not fully understood. Heart rate variability (HRV) has emerged as a promising non-invasive measure of autonomic nervous system activity, workload, and cognitive function. However, its specific application in differentiating expertise levels within neurointerventional radiology during simulated procedures remained largely unexplored. This paper aims to bridge this gap by examining HRV differences between novice and expert neurointerventionalists during simulated neuroangiographies.

Methods

The researchers recruited ten participants: six beginners (little to no experience in interventional neuroradiology) and five experts (extensive experience). Participants performed ten simulated diagnostic neuroangiographies on a high-fidelity Vascular Interventional System Trainer (VIST) simulator. Alongside standard performance metrics like total time and fluoroscopy time, heart rate variability (HRV) was continuously recorded using a chest belt. The NASA-Task Load Index (NASA-TLX) was administered after each simulation to assess subjective workload.

HRV analysis involved processing electrocardiogram (ECG) data using specialized software (ARTiiFACT 2.2) to extract inter-beat intervals (IBIs). Both time-domain (e.g., RMSSD, NN50) and frequency-domain (e.g., LF/HF ratio, HF%) HRV metrics were computed. Statistical analysis included independent samples t-tests and Mann-Whitney-U tests for group comparisons, and multivariate regression was used to assess the influence of age and expert status on HRV metrics.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized a VIST simulator as the training environment and collected physiological data from participants.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • HRV as a Biomarker of Expertise: The study strongly suggests that HRV metrics can serve as physiological markers to distinguish between varying levels of expertise in neurointerventional radiology.
  • Decreased HRV in Experts: Counterintuitively, experts exhibited decreased HRV in several key metrics. This finding challenges the common assumption that higher HRV always equates to better performance or lower stress. Instead, it supports the idea that reduced HRV in experts might reflect a more focused, efficient, and perhaps even resource-optimized cardiovascular state during demanding tasks.
  • Vagal Tone and Cognitive Load: The observed differences, particularly in frequency-domain metrics influenced by vagal activity, align with the neurovisceral integration model. This model posits a link between autonomic nervous system activity, particularly vagal tone, and cognitive-executive functions. The findings suggest that experts may be employing a different physiological strategy, potentially involving a more controlled autonomic response, to manage cognitive load during complex procedures.
  • Experience Over Age: Multivariate regression analysis indicated that differences in HRV were primarily driven by expert status rather than participant age, reinforcing the significance of acquired skill and experience.

Key Results

  • Significant HRV Differences: Experts and beginners showed significant differences in three time-domain HRV metrics (RMSSD, NN50, pNN50) and six frequency-domain HRV metrics, including the LF/HF ratio.
  • LF/HF Ratio: The LF/HF ratio, often interpreted as an index of sympathovagal balance, was significantly different, with experts showing a different pattern than beginners.
  • High Frequency (HF) Components: Beginners showed increased high-frequency (HF) components of HRV compared to experts. While typically associated with vagal activity, the authors suggest this might reflect a less automated or more effortful response in beginners.
  • No Subjective Workload Difference: Despite physiological differences, subjective workload as measured by the NASA-TLX did not significantly differ between the groups, highlighting the potential of objective physiological measures like HRV to reveal subtle differences not captured by self-report.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Size: The study acknowledges a small sample size (N=10) and heterogeneity within the beginner group. However, they argue their findings are supported by larger studies.
  • Simulation vs. Real-World: The authors note that the simulation, lacking real patients and radiation, likely resulted in lower workload levels than in actual clinical practice. This limits the direct transferability of the findings to real-world scenarios.
  • Baseline HRV: Baseline HRV was not recorded, assuming comparable external workload. However, external factors could have influenced results.
  • Future Directions: The paper emphasizes the need for future research to focus on real-time HRV analysis and the definition of individual thresholds to detect work overload. This could enable remote monitoring and timely expert support, ultimately preventing adverse events. Identifying thresholds to differentiate between beginners and advanced practitioners is crucial to minimize "false alarms" and optimize intervention.

Summary updated

Abstract

The HRV of beginners and expert neurointerventionalists significantly differed during simulated endovascular neuroradiological procedures. Experts presented decreased HRV, this could be a cardiovascular surrogate to the effort the subjects expend on their performance. It is in line with previous studies on vagal influences on the heart and cognitive-executive performance.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hinzmann2022differences,
  author = {Dominik Hinzmann and Maximilian Singer and Valerie Schmelter and Kornelia Kreiser and Kim Gehling and Lea Ströber and Jan S. Kirschke and Christian Schulz and F Schneider},
  title = {{Differences in beginner and expert neurointerventionalists” heart rate variability during simulated neuroangiographies}},
  booktitle = {Interventional},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1177/15910199221128439},
}
Figure