‘Diet’ deep canonical correlation analysis for high‐dimensional genetics study of brain imaging phenotypes in Alzheimer’s disease

Shu Yang, Austin Wang, Jingxuan Bao, Shizhuo Mu, Yanbo Feng, Zixuan Wen, Jae Young Baik, Junhao Wen, Bojian Hou, Rongguang Wang, Heng Huang, Andrew J. Saykin, Paul M. Thompson, Christos Davatzikos, Li Shen, for the Adni and Ai4adAlzheimer 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces DietDCCA, a novel deep learning method that effectively tackles the challenge of identifying associations between a vast number of genetic markers (SNPs) and brain imaging features in Alzheimer's disease research. By integrating a "diet" network architecture, DietDCCA significantly improves upon existing methods, demonstrating its potential as a powerful tool for uncovering the genetic underpinnings of AD.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Alzheimer's disease (AD) research is increasingly focused on understanding how genetic variations influence brain structure and function, as revealed by imaging techniques like PET and MRI. While traditional Genome-Wide Association Studies (GWAS) look at individual genetic markers, more sophisticated methods like Canonical Correlation Analysis (CCA) and its deep learning extension (DCCA) aim to find complex relationships between multiple genetic variants and multiple imaging traits simultaneously. However, a major hurdle arises with the explosion of genetic data: we now have far more genetic markers (SNPs) than study participants. This "fat data" problem leads to severe overfitting, where models learn noise rather than true biological signals, making it difficult to reliably identify meaningful genetic associations with brain phenotypes.

Methods

The core innovation of this paper is the development of DietDCCA. This method builds upon the Deep Canonical Correlation Analysis (DCCA) framework by incorporating an efficient model parameterization technique inspired by Mila's "Diet Network" architecture.

Here's a breakdown:

  • Standard DCCA: Aims to find latent variables from two different data modalities (genetics and imaging) that are maximally correlated. It typically uses deep neural networks to learn these representations.
  • DietDCCA's Novelty: The key modification is within the genetics sub-network. Instead of directly feeding all high-dimensional SNP data into a large network, DietDCCA uses a smaller "diet" network. This diet network learns to transform the SNP features into a set of weights. These weights are then used to effectively "prune" or select the most relevant SNP features before they are processed by the main DCCA network. This approach is designed to mitigate overfitting by imposing a more constrained parameterization on the genetics side.
  • Joint Learning: Both the genetics sub-network (with the diet component) and the imaging sub-network are learned jointly to maximize the correlation between their outputs.

Datasets

The study utilizes data from the Alzheimer's Disease Neuroimaging Initiative (ADNI).

  • Subjects: Data from 955 subjects were used.
  • Imaging Data: 68 cortical regions of interest (ROIs) derived from florbetapir (AV45) PET imaging.
  • Genetics Data: Varied numbers of Single Nucleotide Polymorphisms (SNPs), ranging from 810 to 11,938. These SNP sets were curated based on significance thresholds from previous studies.
  • Benchmarking: The paper compares DietDCCA against standard DCCA on nine different datasets, each representing a unique combination of imaging data and a specific set of SNPs. This allows for a direct evaluation of DietDCCA's performance across different scales of genetic data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Fat Data" Problem is Real and Pervasive: The paper highlights that standard DCCA struggles significantly when the number of genetic features (SNPs) vastly outnumbers the samples, a common scenario in AD genetics.
  • Diet Networks Offer a Solution for Overfitting: The integration of the "diet" network architecture is a clever way to regularize the genetics side of the model. By learning to assign weights to SNPs, it implicitly performs feature selection and reduces the model's capacity to memorize noise.
  • Biological Relevance is Key: The success of DietDCCA isn't just about improving correlation scores; it's also about identifying SNPs that are biologically meaningful and have known associations with AD. This suggests the method is capturing genuine biological signals.

Key Results

  • Superior Performance: DietDCCA consistently outperformed standard DCCA across all nine tested datasets, even when dealing with approximately 10,000 SNPs. The improvement in test correlations was described as "large."
  • Identification of Key Genetic Markers: When analyzing the learned weights in the diet net layer, DietDCCA successfully identified the APOE4 SNP (rs429358) as a highly important feature in most cases.
  • Discovery of Other Relevant SNPs: Beyond APOE4, DietDCCA also highlighted SNPs in other genes previously implicated in AD research, such as ABCA7, APOC2, CLPTM1, and NECTIN2. This provides further validation for the method's ability to uncover biologically relevant genetic associations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations: The paper focuses on a specific type of imaging data (AV45 PET ROIs) and a particular set of genetic markers. The performance might vary with different imaging modalities or genetic data sources. While the method shows promise, the "fat data" problem is complex, and further validation across diverse datasets and cohorts would be beneficial.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that DietDCCA is a novel and effective tool for studying the genetic basis of AD imaging phenotypes. Future analyses could involve applying this method to larger and more diverse datasets, exploring different imaging modalities (e.g., MRI structural data), and investigating the functional implications of the identified genetic associations. The method could also be extended to other complex diseases with similar "fat data" challenges.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background Understanding the relationship between genetic variations and brain imaging phenotypes is an important issue in Alzheimer's disease (AD) research. As an alternative to GWAS univariate analyses, canonical correlation analysis (CCA) and its deep learning extension (DCCA) are widely used to identify associations between multiple genetic variants such as SNPs and multiple imaging traits such as brain ROIs from PET/MRI. However, with the recent availability of numerous genetic variants from genotyping and whole genome sequencing data for AD, these approaches often suffer from severe overfitting when dealing with ‘fat’ genetics data, e.g. large numbers of SNPs with much smaller numbers of samples. Methods Here, we propose to tackle the challenge by integrating an efficient model parameterization approach from Mila’s Diet Network architecture into DCCA to handle high dimensional SNP data in AD imaging‐genetics study (Figure 1). The new method, DietDCCA, was applied to nine datasets derived from 955 subjects in the ADNI data. Each dataset contains 68 FreeSurfer cortical ROIs from the florbetapir (AV45) PET imaging and varied numbers of SNPs from 810 to 11,938 based on different significance thresholds derived from previous studies. Results Firstly, we compared our DietDCCA with DCCA on each of the nine datasets to demonstrate the improvement on test correlations (Figure 2). DietDCCA outperformed DCCA by a large margin on all datasets even when the SNPs are as many as ∼10k. Next, we sought to verify if the detected correlations were contributed by meaningful SNPs and extracted the SNP feature that has the largest weight in each neuron of the diet net layer (Figure 3). DietDCCA successfully selected the APOE4 SNP (rs429358) for most cases and also picked out SNPs in other genes (ABCA7, APOC2, CLPTM1, NECTIN2) that were previously reported to associate with AD. Conclusions We introduced a novel method, DietDCCA, to handle high‐dimensional SNP features in AD imaging‐genetics study. The initial investigation of DietDCCA on the ADNI data showed promises in detecting correlation signals with AV45 ROIs from biologically meaningful SNPs. The study supplies a novel and effective tool to study the genetic basis of AD imaging phenotypes for future analyses.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yang2024diet,
  author = {Shu Yang and Austin Wang and Jingxuan Bao and Shizhuo Mu and Yanbo Feng and Zixuan Wen and Jae Young Baik and Junhao Wen and Bojian Hou and Rongguang Wang and Heng Huang and Andrew J. Saykin and Paul M. Thompson and Christos Davatzikos and Li Shen and for the ADNI and AI4AD},
  title = {{‘Diet’ deep canonical correlation analysis for high‐dimensional genetics study of brain imaging phenotypes in Alzheimer’s disease}},
  booktitle = {Alzheimer},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1002/alz.092330},
}
Figure