TL;DR
This paper proposes a novel method for efficiently encoding dictionaries into Tagged Sentential Decision Diagrams (TSDDs), a type of decision diagram that offers a compact representation. By leveraging tries to accelerate the encoding process and exploring different encoding strategies, the authors demonstrate that TSDDs are particularly well-suited for representing dictionaries, achieving smaller sizes compared to other decision diagram variants.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Storing and operating on large dictionaries (millions of words) can be computationally expensive, with common operations like searching, adding, or removing words often having a time complexity of O(n). To address this, researchers have explored using decision diagrams, which offer efficient representations and operations. While previous work has shown the feasibility of encoding dictionaries into Binary Decision Diagrams (BDDs) and their variants, this paper aims to investigate a specific type of decision diagram, Tagged Sentential Decision Diagrams (TSDDs), which combine features of both standard and zero-suppressed trimming rules, potentially leading to more compact representations. The goal is to develop an efficient encoding algorithm and demonstrate the superiority of TSDDs for dictionary representation.
Methods
The paper introduces a novel algorithm for encoding dictionaries into TSDDs. The core idea involves:
- Representing Dictionaries with Boolean Functions: Words in a dictionary are first transformed into Boolean functions.
- Leveraging Tries for Acceleration: Instead of directly encoding words into decision diagrams, the authors first construct a trie (a prefix tree) from the dictionary. This trie is then compressed by merging nodes with the same depth and children, significantly reducing its size.
- Transforming Tries to TSDDs: The compressed trie is then converted into a TSDD. The algorithm processes trie nodes from bottom to top, computing TSDDs for each node and combining them using logical operations (conjunction and disjunction).
- Encoding Strategies: Four encoding methods are explored: compact code (binary and one-hot) and ASCII code (binary and one-hot). The binary encoding methods are shown to be more efficient in terms of variable usage.
- Decoding Algorithm: An algorithm is also presented to reconstruct the original dictionary from a TSDD.
The paper also defines the syntax and semantics of Sentential Decision Diagrams (SDDs), Zero-Suppressed Decision Diagrams (ZSDDs), and Tagged Sentential Decision Diagrams (TSDDs), detailing their compression and trimming rules.
Datasets
The paper uses several real-world dictionaries for evaluation:
- The English words file
/usr/share/dict/wordson a MacOS system (235,886 words). - A password list (979,247 words).
- Other word lists from a provided GitHub repository.
For experimental comparison, specific subsets of these dictionaries (20,000, 30,000, and 40,000 words) were used to test encoding times with and without tries.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Tries are Crucial for Efficiency: The use of tries significantly accelerates the dictionary encoding process, reducing encoding times from hours to seconds, especially for large dictionaries.
- TSDDs Excel in Compactness (Binary Encoding): When dictionaries are encoded using binary representations (compact or ASCII), TSDDs consistently achieve the smallest node counts among all tested decision diagram variants. This suggests TSDDs are highly effective at representing the inherent structure of dictionaries in a compact form.
- One-Hot Encoding is Less Efficient: While one-hot encoding is explored, it leads to significantly larger decision diagrams and longer encoding times due to the increased number of variables required. Binary encoding is preferred for its efficiency.
- Trade-off Between Encoding Time and Size: TSDDs might not always have the fastest encoding times, but they offer superior compactness (node count). The authors argue this trade-off is worthwhile for achieving more efficient dictionary representations.
- No Single "Best" Diagram for All Cases: The experiments show that different decision diagram types perform best under different encoding schemes and dictionary types. However, TSDDs emerge as a strong contender, particularly for binary encodings.
Key Results
- Encoding Speedup: Using tries reduced encoding times for a 40,000-word dictionary from over 1000 seconds to under 10 seconds.
- Node Count Comparison (Binary Encoding): For binary encodings (compact or ASCII), TSDDs consistently achieved the minimum node count across various dictionaries. For instance, for the "dutch-wordlist" dictionary with ASCII binary encoding, the TSDD node count was 273,022, while the next smallest was 976,921 (over 3 times larger).
- Node Count Comparison (One-Hot Encoding): In one-hot encoding, TSDDs' node counts were generally within 1.5 times the minimum node count of other diagrams, demonstrating good performance.
- Encoding Time: While TSDDs didn't always have the fastest encoding times, they could encode dictionaries within half an hour, which is often faster than other methods that might exceed an hour.
Limitations and Future Work
- Decoding Limitations: The proposed decoding algorithm is effective for binary encoded decision diagrams but struggles with one-hot encoded ones, taking over an hour for dictionaries with over 10,000 words.
- Further Improvements: The authors suggest several directions for future research:
- More Compact Symbol Representation: Finding ways to represent characters and symbols with fewer variables to further reduce node counts.
- Optimizing Algorithms: Improving algorithms for node count reduction and encoding time.
- Enhanced Decoding: Developing a more efficient decoding algorithm for one-hot encoded decision diagrams.
- Broader Applications: Exploring the use of decision diagrams for storing other types of symbolic data.
Summary updated