Diatom pyrenoids are encased in a protein shell that enables efficient CO 2 fixation

Ginga Shimakawa, Manon Demulder, Serena Flori, Akihiro Kawamoto, Yoshinori Tsuji, Hermanus Nawaly, Atsuko Tanaka, Rei Tohda, Tadayoshi Ota, Hiroaki Matsui, Natsumi Morishima, Ryosuke Okubo, Wojciech Wietrzyñski, Lorenz Lamm, Ricardo D. Righetto, Clarisse Uwizeye, Benoît Gallet, Pierre‐Henri Jouneau, Christoph Gerle, Genji Kurisu, Giovanni Finazzi, Benjamin D. Engel, Yusuke MatsudabioRxiv 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

Diatoms, crucial players in oceanic carbon fixation, possess specialized cellular compartments called pyrenoids that efficiently capture CO2. This study identifies and characterizes a novel protein shell, "PyShell," that encases these pyrenoids. The PyShell is essential for maintaining pyrenoid structure and function, playing a vital role in the high efficiency of CO2 assimilation in diatoms, which has significant implications for understanding oceanic carbon cycles and climate change.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Diatoms are responsible for a substantial portion of global CO2 fixation, making them critical to Earth's carbon cycle. Their efficiency in this process is partly due to pyrenoids, chloroplast subcompartments that concentrate CO2 around the enzyme Rubisco. However, the molecular mechanisms governing pyrenoid structure and function, particularly in diatoms, have remained poorly understood. This paper aims to elucidate the molecular components and architecture of diatom pyrenoids, focusing on a newly identified protein shell that appears to be key to their specialized CO2-concentrating mechanism (CCM).

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • In vivo photo-crosslinking: This technique was used to identify proteins interacting with Rubisco, the central enzyme in carbon fixation. By feeding diatoms with photo-reactive amino acids and then exposing them to UV light, proteins in close proximity to Rubisco were covalently linked, allowing for their subsequent identification via mass spectrometry.
  • Cryo-electron tomography (cryo-ET): This high-resolution imaging technique was used to visualize the native structure of pyrenoids within intact diatom cells. By freezing cells rapidly and imaging them in 3D, the researchers could observe the pyrenoid's architecture and the surrounding protein shell.
  • Subtomogram averaging (STA): This computational method was used to improve the resolution of the cryo-ET data, allowing for a more detailed understanding of the PyShell's structure.
  • Single particle cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM): Recombinant PyShell proteins were expressed and purified, then subjected to cryo-EM to determine their high-resolution structure. This allowed for the construction of an atomic model of the PyShell.
  • Genome editing (CRISPR/Cas9): To understand the function of the PyShell, the researchers created mutant diatoms lacking PyShell genes. The resulting phenotypes were then analyzed.
  • Fluorescence microscopy and Immunoelectron microscopy: These techniques were used to confirm the subcellular localization of PyShell proteins.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The PyShell is a conserved structural element: The identification of a protein shell (PyShell) encasing diatom pyrenoids, observed in both pennate (P. tricornutum) and centric (T. pseudonana) diatoms, suggests a conserved structural feature critical for pyrenoid organization.
  • PyShell dictates pyrenoid architecture: The PyShell appears to be crucial for establishing the characteristic elongated shape of diatom pyrenoids and for correctly positioning internal structures like specialized thylakoids.
  • PyShell is essential for efficient CO2 fixation: Disrupting PyShell expression leads to a "high-CO2 requiring" phenotype, indicating impaired CO2 concentrating mechanisms and reduced growth under normal atmospheric CO2 levels. This highlights the PyShell's role in optimizing CO2 availability to Rubisco.
  • PyShell self-assembles into a lattice: The recombinant PyShell protein can self-assemble into helical tubes, revealing its inherent structural properties and enabling high-resolution structural determination.
  • Diatom pyrenoids have evolved unique solutions: While sharing the fundamental goal of CO2 concentration with other algae, diatoms utilize a distinct protein shell (PyShell) for pyrenoid organization, showcasing convergent evolution of CCMs with different molecular components.

Key Results

  • Identification of PyShell: A novel protein, PyShell, was identified as a key component of the diatom pyrenoid.
  • Structural characterization: Cryo-ET revealed a lattice-like protein sheath (PyShell) surrounding the Rubisco matrix in both P. tricornutum and T. pseudonana. High-resolution cryo-EM determined the atomic structure of the PyShell, revealing a self-assembling helical lattice.
  • Functional significance: T. pseudonana mutants lacking PyShell exhibited significantly impaired growth and carbon fixation efficiency under ambient CO2 conditions, requiring much higher CO2 concentrations to achieve maximal photosynthetic rates. These mutants also showed altered pyrenoid morphology, with fragmentation and mislocalization of internal thylakoids.
  • PyShell's role in thylakoid positioning: The PyShell was found to be necessary for correctly positioning specialized thylakoids along the long axis of the Rubisco matrix, which is crucial for delivering CO2 to Rubisco.

Limitations and Future Work

  • PyShell structure: The N-terminal 68 residues of the PyShell protein were disordered and not resolved in the in vitro structure, leaving questions about their role and potential interactions. Further studies are needed to understand if the inner and outer surfaces of the PyShell are distinct in vivo.
  • PyShell heterogeneity: Multiple homologous PyShell genes exist, and while the study focused on a single isoform for structural analysis, it's possible that other isoforms hetero-oligomerize in situ. Further research is needed to investigate this heterogeneity and its functional significance.
  • PyShell permeability: The in vitro structure revealed small gaps in the lattice, raising questions about the PyShell's permeability to gases (CO2, O2) and metabolites. In-depth functional studies are required to assay this.
  • Pyrenoid biogenesis: The study provides a detailed look at the steady-state architecture but lacks insight into how pyrenoids grow and establish this architecture. Future work should investigate the mechanisms of pyrenoid growth and the role of the PyShell in this process.
  • Luminal particle identity: The identity of dense particles within the lumen of pyrenoid-traversing thylakoids remains unknown.
  • Thylakoid function in mutants: It is unclear why thylakoids in mutants acquire luminal particles but fail to traverse the Rubisco matrix.
  • PyShell prevalence and diversity: While bioinformatic analysis suggests widespread distribution, it's biased towards sequenced species. Capturing the architectural variations across diverse algae will require extensive cryo-ET.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Pyrenoids are subcompartments of algal chloroplasts that concentrate Rubisco enzymes and their CO 2 substrate, thereby increasing the efficiency of carbon fixation. Diatoms perform up to 20% of global CO 2 fixation, but their pyrenoids remain poorly characterized at a molecular level. Here, we used in vivo photo-crosslinking to catalogue components of diatom pyrenoids and identified a pyrenoid shell (PyShell) protein, which we localized to the pyrenoid periphery of both the pennate diatom, Pheaodactylum tricornutum , and the centric diatom, Thalassiosira pseudonana . In situ cryo-electron tomography (cryo-ET) revealed that the pyrenoids of both diatom species are encased in a lattice-like protein sheath. Disruption of PyShell expression in T. pseudonana resulted in the absence of this protein sheath, altered pyrenoid morphology, and a high-CO 2 requiring phenotype, with impaired growth and reduced carbon fixation efficiency under standard atmospheric conditions. Pyrenoids in mutant cells were fragmented and lacked the thylakoid membranes that normally traverse the Rubisco matrix, demonstrating how the PyShell plays a guiding role in establishing pyrenoid architecture. Recombinant PyShell proteins self-assembled into helical tubes, enabling us to determine a 3.0 Å-resolution PyShell structure. We then fit this in vitro structure into an in situ subtomogram average of the pyrenoid’s protein sheath, yielding a putative atomic model of the PyShell within diatom cells. The structure and function of the diatom PyShell provides a new molecular view of how CO 2 is assimilated in the ocean, a crucial biome that is on the front lines of climate change.
BibTeX
@misc{shimakawa2023diatom,
  author = {Ginga Shimakawa and Manon Demulder and Serena Flori and Akihiro Kawamoto and Yoshinori Tsuji and Hermanus Nawaly and Atsuko Tanaka and Rei Tohda and Tadayoshi Ota and Hiroaki Matsui and Natsumi Morishima and Ryosuke Okubo and Wojciech Wietrzyñski and Lorenz Lamm and Ricardo D. Righetto and Clarisse Uwizeye and Benoît Gallet and Pierre‐Henri Jouneau and Christoph Gerle and Genji Kurisu and Giovanni Finazzi and Benjamin D. Engel and Yusuke Matsuda},
  title = {{Diatom pyrenoids are encased in a protein shell that enables efficient CO <sub>2</sub> fixation}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1101/2023.10.25.564039},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure