Dialing the glenosphere eccentricity posteriorly to optimize range of motion in reverse shoulder arthroplasty

Stefan Bauer, Arnaud Meylan, Jaad Mahlouly, Wei Shao, William G. BlakeneyJSES 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses computer modeling to investigate how adjusting the position of the glenosphere (the "ball socket" component) in reverse shoulder arthroplasty affects the range of motion and potential for impingement. They found that moving the glenosphere posteriorly improves extension and external rotation but can reduce internal rotation, while a lower neck-shaft angle (NSA) and baseplate lateralization generally enhance overall motion.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Reverse shoulder arthroplasty (RSA) is a common procedure for treating severe shoulder arthritis and rotator cuff tears. A key challenge in RSA is "notching," where the prosthetic components rub against the scapula, potentially leading to pain, loosening, and worse patient outcomes. This notching is often caused by friction between the components during movement. The glenosphere's position is a critical factor influencing this impingement. While eccentric glenospheres (those with an off-center socket) have been introduced to mitigate notching, the optimal positioning of these eccentric glenospheres to maximize functional range of motion (ROM) without causing impingement remains an open question. This paper aims to address this by systematically evaluating different glenosphere eccentricity positions using a computer model.

Methods

The researchers employed a computer modeling approach, analyzing CT scans from 10 de-identified female patients. They created 18 distinct virtual models for each patient, systematically varying several key prosthetic parameters:

  • Neck-Shaft Angle (NSA): Two angles were tested: 145° (standard) and 135°.
  • Baseplate (BP) Lateralization: Standard (0 mm) and +3 mm lateralized baseplates were used.
  • Glenosphere Eccentricity (ECC) Position: The glenosphere was positioned in five different locations relative to a neutral (0°) reference: 30° posterior, 50° posterior, 30° anterior, and 50° anterior. A 39-mm concentric (non-eccentric) glenosphere was also included as a control.

The models simulated glenohumeral rigid body motion to record the range of motion for extension (EXT), external rotation (ER), internal rotation (IR), and adduction (ADD). The primary outcome variables were combined motion values (EXT + IR and ER + IR), while total combined motion (EXT + IR + ER + ADD) served as a secondary outcome.

Datasets

The study utilized de-identified CT scans from 10 female patients. These scans were used to create comparative computer models of the shoulder anatomy. No new benchmark datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Dialing" Effect: Adjusting the glenosphere's eccentricity position has a direct and predictable impact on specific ranges of motion.
  • Posterior Dialing Trade-off: Moving the glenosphere posteriorly significantly improves extension and external rotation, which are crucial for reaching behind the body. However, this comes at the cost of reduced internal rotation.
  • Anterior Dialing Trade-off: Conversely, dialing the glenosphere anteriorly enhances internal rotation but compromises extension and external rotation.
  • NSA is a Major Player: A lower neck-shaft angle (135° vs. 145°) appears to be a more significant factor in increasing overall impingement-free motion than fine-tuning the glenosphere eccentricity, especially when combined with baseplate lateralization.
  • Lateralization Boosts Motion: Baseplate lateralization, even by a modest 3 mm, generally increases the range of motion across various configurations.
  • Larger Glenosphere as a "Safe Bet": A larger, non-eccentric glenosphere (39 mm) can serve as a reliable option to prevent extreme ECC positioning outliers, potentially offering a good balance of motion without the risks associated with very anterior or posterior placements.

Key Results

  • 145° NSA (No Lateralization):
    • 30° posterior ECC improved mean ER (40° vs. 38°) and EXT (35° vs. 34°) compared to neutral, but at the expense of IR (83° vs. 87°).
  • 30° anterior ECC increased IR (90° vs. 87°) but decreased ER (33° vs. 38°) and EXT (24° vs. 34°).
  • Neutral position yielded the best combined EXT + IR (121°) and IR + ER (125°) motion.
  • 145° NSA (+3mm Lateralization):
    • 30° posterior ECC showed improved EXT (57° vs. 47°) and ER (51° vs. 49°) compared to neutral, but with a significant decrease in IR (87° vs. 91°).
  • 135° NSA (No Lateralization):
    • 30° posterior ECC improved ER (57° vs. 54°) compared to neutral.
  • Neutral ECC outperformed 30° posterior and the 39-mm glenosphere in IR.
  • Overall Impact: Lowering the NSA from 145° to 135°, especially with +3mm lateralization, most effectively increased the total combined ROM (EXT + IR + ER + ADD).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computer Modeling: The study is based on computer modeling and does not account for real-world factors like scapulothoracic motion, soft tissue influences, or patient-specific biomechanics.
  • Clinical Applicability of Extreme Positions: The authors acknowledge that achieving the more extreme ECC positions (50° anterior/posterior) might be technically challenging or impossible in a surgical setting, particularly with certain surgical approaches (e.g., delto-pectoral).
  • Statistical Significance vs. Clinical Significance: While many differences were statistically significant (with large effect sizes), the authors question whether some smaller ROM changes would translate to a noticeable clinical benefit for patients.
  • Future Work: The study suggests that understanding the effects of implant position changes on postoperative ROM is crucial for surgeons. Future research could explore the clinical implications of these findings and the practical feasibility of achieving optimal ECC positions in surgery. The potential for instability with a 135° NSA was also noted as a consideration for future investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Posterior dialing of the ECC increases EXT and ER but at the expense of IR. Lateralization, but most effectively a 135° NSA, increase impingement-free motion. A larger noneccentric glenosphere on the same BP is a safe all-round solution to prevent ECC positioning outliers.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bauer2024dialing,
  author = {Stefan Bauer and Arnaud Meylan and Jaad Mahlouly and Wei Shao and William G. Blakeney},
  title = {{Dialing the glenosphere eccentricity posteriorly to optimize range of motion in reverse shoulder arthroplasty}},
  booktitle = {JSES},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1016/j.jseint.2024.09.003},
}
Figure