Diagnosis and Efficacy Improvement of Staff Training in Medium- and Small-Sized Private Enterprises

Lujian Zheng, Jianmin WangAmerican 2018 · DOI

Abstract

Socioeconomic development has intensified inter-enterprise competition and made human resource exploitation extremely important for all enterprises. As a major part of the market economy, private enterprises play an increasingly important role. Staff training, a key step of human resource development, is critical for improving individual performances and overall corporate performance & yield. However, the staff training of medium- and small-sized private enterprises is faced by many problems that restrict the training efficacy. To further diagnose the training-related problems faced by medium- and small-sized private enterprises, here the author analyzed the current situations of staff training in M and identified the problems. Together with relevant knowledge and theories, the author analyzed underlying causes and proposed appropriate suggestions, aiming to provide some references and guidance for improving the training system of M.

Introduction

In the modern knowledge economy, human capital is a primary driver of competitive advantage. While large corporations often have robust, data-driven human resource development pipelines, medium- and small-sized private enterprises (SMEs) frequently struggle to implement effective staff training. This research addresses the gap between the critical need for skilled personnel in SMEs and the reality of their often ineffective, highly formalized training programs.

A major root cause of poor training efficacy is leadership's perception of training as a short-term financial cost and operational time-sink, rather than a long-term capital investment. This "Cost vs. Investment" fallacy often throttles funding and systemic support, leading to programs that fail to translate into improved employee performance.

Case Study Methodology: Company M

The researchers employed a qualitative organizational diagnosis approach, utilizing a single-case study methodology focused on "Company M," a medium-sized private tire manufacturing enterprise in Beijing with over 1,000 employees. The study involved on-site observations and employee interviews to audit the company's existing two-tier training architecture.

The organizational structure of staff training and management at Company M, illustrating the hierarchy from professional management down to specific staff categories.

The audit mapped the company's current practices against established human resource development theories to diagnose root causes of training friction. The structure, as shown in the organizational chart, divides training into two levels, targeting business management, professional technical, skill, and administrational staff.

Diagnostic Findings

The analysis identified five core systemic failures within Company M's training ecosystem:

  1. The Danger of "Overformalization": Treating training needs assessments as a mere bureaucratic checkbox undermines the program. For example, frontline workers' surveys were often filled out by group leaders rather than the workers themselves, leading to generic, irrelevant training modules.
  2. Lack of Content Pertinence: Training often failed to address actual employee pain points, focusing on top-down mandates rather than practical operational skills.
  3. Domain Expertise vs. Teaching Ability: Relying on highly skilled senior employees or expensive foreign experts often fails if they lack pedagogical skills. Expert lectures were frequently found to be overly theoretical and detached from practical manufacturing needs.
  4. Incomplete Assessment Mechanisms: There was a notable absence of post-training evaluations to measure knowledge retention or skill acquisition.
  5. Zero Incentive Structures: Without tying training performance to promotions or bonuses, both trainers and trainees lacked the motivation to engage meaningfully with the material.

Proposed Framework for Improvement

To transform corporate training from a "cost center" into a strategic investment, the authors proposed a comprehensive restructuring plan:

  • Multi-faceted Needs Assessment: Implementation of a detailed "Staff Training Needs Survey" designed to capture actual employee requirements, including stress management, teamwork, and practical operational skills.
  • Diversified Evaluation Strategy: Shifting from zero evaluation to a mixed-methods approach. This includes written examinations for knowledge-based training and on-site simulated tests for skill-based training.
  • Incentive Alignment: Establishing clear links between training outcomes and career advancement or financial rewards to foster a culture of continuous learning.

Conclusion

While this research is based on a single sample (Company M), it highlights systemic issues common in the SME sector. Future work should involve broader case studies across various industries to validate these diagnostic frameworks and tailor training improvement strategies to different organizational contexts. By addressing these structural flaws, SMEs can better leverage their human capital for long-term competitive advantage.

Summary updated

Abstract

Socioeconomic development has intensified inter-enterprise competition and made human resource exploitation extremely important for all enterprises. As a major part of the market economy, private enterprises play an increasingly important role. Staff training, a key step of human resource development, is critical for improving individual performances and overall corporate performance & yield. However, the staff training of medium- and small-sized private enterprises is faced by many problems that restrict the training efficacy. To further diagnose the training-related problems faced by medium- and small-sized private enterprises, here the author analyzed the current situations of staff training in M and identified the problems. Together with relevant knowledge and theories, the author analyzed underlying causes and proposed appropriate suggestions, aiming to provide some references and guidance for improving the training system of M.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zheng2018diagnosis,
  author = {Lujian Zheng and Jianmin Wang},
  title = {{Diagnosis and Efficacy Improvement of Staff Training in Medium- and Small-Sized Private Enterprises}},
  booktitle = {American},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.4236/ajibm.2018.83048},
}
Figure