DFT + U Study of Strain-Engineered CO2 Reduction on a CeO2–x (111) Facet

Jens Vive Kildgaard, Heine Anton Hansen, Tejs VeggeThe Journal of Physical Chemistry C 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have used DFT+U calculations to show that applying compressive strain to ceria (CeO2) can significantly boost its efficiency in converting CO2 to CO. This strain engineering approach leads to a remarkable four-orders-of-magnitude increase in the reaction rate at 800 K, offering a promising pathway for improving CO2 electrolysis technologies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing concentration of atmospheric CO2, coupled with a growing global energy demand, necessitates the development of efficient technologies for CO2 utilization. Electrochemical CO2 reduction, particularly in solid oxide electrolysis cells (SOECs), offers a promising route to convert CO2 into valuable products like CO, which can then be used to synthesize fuels and chemicals. Ceria (CeO2) is a compelling candidate material for SOEC cathodes due to its ability to become a mixed ionic-electronic conductor and its high oxygen storage capacity. However, optimizing ceria's catalytic activity for CO2 reduction remains a challenge. This paper investigates how mechanical strain can be used to engineer the surface properties of ceria and enhance its performance in CO2 electrolysis.

Methods

The study employs Density Functional Theory (DFT) with on-site Coulomb interactions (DFT+U) to model the CO2 reduction reaction on the CeO2(111) facet. This computational approach allows for a detailed investigation of the electronic structure and reaction pathways. Specifically, the authors used the Vienna Atomic Simulation Package (VASP) with the Perdew-Burke-Ernzerhof (PBE) functional for exchange-correlation. They employed the projector augmented-wave (PAW) method for core electrons and a Hubbard U parameter of 4.5 eV for the cerium 4f orbitals, a value chosen to accurately describe electron localization in reduced ceria.

To explore reaction pathways and transition states, the nudged elastic band (NEB) method and its climbing-image variant (CI-NEB) were utilized. The dimer method was applied for final optimization of transition states. The researchers systematically applied biaxial strain to the CeO2(111) surface, varying the stretch ratio (λ) from 0.96 (compressive) to 1.04 (tensile). They also calculated free energies under simulated SOEC conditions, incorporating a low oxygen pressure at elevated temperatures.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on theoretical calculations rather than experimental datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Strain as a Tunable Catalyst Modifier: The core idea is that applying mechanical strain to the ceria surface can fundamentally alter its electronic properties and, consequently, its catalytic activity for CO2 reduction. This moves beyond traditional doping or surface modification strategies.
  • Oxygen Vacancy Formation Energy is Key: The study highlights that strain significantly impacts the energy required to form oxygen vacancies on the ceria surface. This is crucial because oxygen vacancies are believed to play a vital role in the CO2 reduction mechanism.
  • Ce 4f Orbital Tuning: Compressive strain shifts the Ce 4f band center, which is directly linked to the stability of Ce³⁺ ions (formed during reduction). This shift destabilizes the formation of critical oxygen vacancies, making them more accessible for the reaction.
  • Energetic Span Reduction: By influencing vacancy formation and the stability of intermediates, strain effectively reduces the overall energetic span of the CO2 reduction reaction, leading to faster kinetics.
  • SOEC Conditions Matter: The calculations are performed under conditions relevant to SOECs (elevated temperature, low oxygen pressure), which are crucial for understanding the practical implications of the findings.

Key Results

  • Compressive Strain Enhances Activity: Applying 4% compressive strain resulted in a four-orders-of-magnitude increase in the turnover frequency (TOF) for CO2 reduction at 800 K compared to the unstrained ceria surface.
  • Tensile Strain Decreases Activity: Conversely, tensile strain was found to decrease the oxygen vacancy formation energy, which is detrimental to the reaction rate.
  • Strain Affects Vacancy Formation Most: The study found that strain has the most significant impact on the oxygen vacancy formation energy, followed by the transition state and the adsorbed CO species.
  • CO2 Reduction Pathway: The paper elucidates a CO2 reduction pathway involving a bent CO2⁻ intermediate, which is more favorable than pathways involving tridentate carbonate intermediates under the studied conditions.
  • Ce³⁺ Stabilization: Compressive strain destabilizes the Ce³⁺ ions on the defect surface, which is a key factor in enhancing the catalytic activity.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model System: The study focuses on the CeO2(111) facet. While this is a stable and relevant facet, other facets of ceria might exhibit different strain responses. The authors acknowledge that other facets are less dense and thus less likely to show the same degree of Ce³⁺ destabilization.
  • Experimental Validation: The findings are based on theoretical calculations. Experimental validation of these strain-engineered ceria catalysts would be a crucial next step.
  • Complex SOEC Environments: Real SOEC environments involve complex gas mixtures and operating conditions. Further studies could explore the effect of strain in more realistic scenarios.
  • Other Strain Types: The study primarily focuses on biaxial strain. Investigating the effects of uniaxial or triaxial strain could reveal additional insights.
  • Long-Term Stability: The long-term stability of strained ceria under operating SOEC conditions is not addressed and would be an important area for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

Ceria is a promising material for cathodes in high-temperature CO2 electrolysis cells because ceria can become a mixed electronic and ionic conductor through doping, which enables a high surface area for electrocatalysis. Here, we systemically investigate the effect of strain to enhance the activity for electrocatalytic CO2RR on CeO2(111) using density functional theory corrected for on-site Coulomb interactions (DFT + U). We find that tensile strain decreases the oxygen vacancy formation energy due to a downshift of the Ce 4f orbital energy, in agreement with the larger size of the Ce3+ ion than the Ce4+ ion. The corresponding upshift in the Ce f-band center with compressive strain destabilizes the formation energy of the critical surface oxygen vacancies and reduces the energetic span of the reduction reaction, leading to a 4 orders of magnitude higher turnover frequency at 800 K for 4% compressive strain. These findings shed new light on possible pathways to enhance the catalytic activity for CO2RR on CeO2(111) and related catalytic systems by strain engineering.
BibTeX
@article{kildgaard2021dft,
  author = {Jens Vive Kildgaard and Heine Anton Hansen and Tejs Vegge},
  title = {{DFT + <i>U</i> Study of Strain-Engineered CO<sub>2</sub> Reduction on a CeO<sub>2–<i>x</i></sub> (111) Facet}},
  journal = {The Journal of Physical Chemistry C},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1021/acs.jpcc.1c01019},
}
Figure