Development of the colorimetric sensor array for detection of explosives and volatile organic compounds in air

Natalie Kostesha, Tommy Sonne Alstrøm, Carsten Johnsen, K. A. Nilesen, Jan O. Jeppesen, Jan Larsen, Mogens Jakobsen, Anja BoisenProceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE 2010 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel colorimetric sensor array for the rapid and cost-effective detection of explosives (like DNT) and volatile organic compounds (VOCs) in air. By immobilizing chemo-responsive dyes on a solid support, the array generates a unique color "fingerprint" upon exposure to analytes, enabling both screening and identification.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing threat of terrorism and the need for environmental monitoring necessitate portable, sensitive, and specific methods for detecting dangerous chemicals and pollutants. Traditional electronic noses, while useful, can struggle with low analyte concentrations and extreme environmental conditions. Existing colorimetric sensor arrays have shown promise, but this work aims to develop a system specifically for detecting explosives like DNT and TNT, alongside a broad range of VOCs, in a simple, inexpensive, and potentially disposable format. The challenge lies in identifying dyes that selectively react with these target compounds and developing a robust method for their immobilization and analysis.

Methods

The core of this research is a colorimetric sensor array composed of 15 chemo-responsive dyes immobilized on silica gel membranes. When exposed to analytes in the gas phase, these dyes undergo a color change. The researchers capture images of the dye array before and after exposure and process these images to create a "color difference map." This map is generated by calculating the difference in RGB (red, green, blue) values for each dye spot.

To analyze the data, they employ Principal Component Analysis (PCA) to reduce the dimensionality of the color difference maps and identify patterns. Additionally, they introduce an alternative visualization method using cumulative density function (cdf) bar plots, which they argue offers advantages over traditional difference maps by avoiding scaling issues and allowing for the representation of negative values. For analytes with low vapor pressure, like DNT, the sensor array was operated at an elevated temperature (100°C) to increase analyte concentration.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly mention the creation of new benchmark datasets. Instead, it details the preparation and use of specific chemical compounds as analytes for testing the sensor array. These include:

  • Explosives: 2,4-dinitrotoluene (DNT)
  • Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs): Acetone, acetic acid, formic acid, hydrochloric acid, methanol, ethanol, propanol, toluene.

These chemicals were of analytical grade and used without further purification.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Selective Color Change as a Fingerprint: The fundamental idea is that each chemo-responsive dye will react differently with various analytes, creating a unique color signature or "fingerprint" for each compound. This allows for both detection and identification.
  • Dual Detection Capability: The sensor array demonstrates the ability to detect both explosives (specifically DNT) and a range of common VOCs, addressing a dual need for security and environmental monitoring.
  • Temperature as a Variable: The successful detection of DNT at elevated temperatures highlights the potential for developing thermo-sensors that can work in conjunction with chemo-sensors, especially for low-volatility compounds.
  • Alternative Data Visualization: The introduction of cdf difference plots offers a more nuanced and potentially more informative way to visualize the sensor's response compared to traditional color difference maps, especially for distinguishing closely related compounds.
  • Potential for Cost-Effective, Disposable Sensors: The described technology is presented as inexpensive and potentially producible as single-use disposables, making it attractive for widespread deployment.

Key Results

  • Rapid Response: The colorimetric sensor array achieved a signal within 30-60 seconds, indicating a fast detection capability.
  • Distinguishing Similar Compounds: The cdf analysis enabled the distinction of closely related alcohols (methanol, ethanol, propanol) within the same chemical group.
  • PCA for Clustering: PCA successfully grouped analytes with similar chemical properties (e.g., alcohols, acids) and also showed distinct clusters for specific compounds like DNT and HCl.
  • Successful DNT Detection: The array was able to detect DNT, even at elevated temperatures, demonstrating its potential for explosive detection.
  • Broad VOC Detection: The sensor array showed responses to a variety of VOCs, including acids, alcohols, and ketones.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Low Vapor Pressure Analytes: Detecting low-volatility explosives like DNT required heating the sensor, suggesting that ambient temperature detection of such compounds remains a challenge.
  • Complex Mixtures: While the paper suggests the array can distinguish mixtures, the detailed analysis of complex mixtures and their deconvolution is an area for further exploration.
  • Quantification: The current work focuses on detection and identification. Future work could involve developing methods for quantifying the concentration of detected analytes.
  • Environmental Factors: The paper mentions the presence of water vapor as a factor, but a comprehensive study of how humidity and other environmental conditions affect sensor performance would be beneficial.
  • Broader Explosive and VOC Range: The authors express interest in probing a wider range of explosives and VOCs, as well as investigating the kinetics of relevant reactions.
  • Integration with Advanced Tools: The conclusion highlights the need for tools that combine classical and modern techniques for precise, real-time quantification and localization of hidden compounds.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the framework of the research project 'Xsense' at the Technical University of Denmark (DTU) we are developing a simple colorimetric sensor array which can be useful in detection of explosives like DNT and TNT, and identification of volatile organic compounds in the presence of water vapor in air. The technology is based on an array of chemo-responsive dyes immobilized on a solid support. Upon exposure to the analyte in suspicion the dye array changes color. Each chosen dye reacts chemo selectively with analytes of interest. A change in a color signature indicates the presence of unknown explosives and volatile organic compounds (VOCs). We are working towards the selection of dyes that undergo color changes in the presence of explosives and VOCs, as well as the development of an immobilization method for the molecules. Digital imaging of the dye array before and after exposure to the analytes creates a color difference map which gives a unique fingerprint for each explosive and volatile organic compound. Such sensing technology can be used to screen for relevant explosives in a complex background as well as to distinguish mixtures of volatile organic compounds distributed in gas phase. This sensor array is inexpensive, and can potentially be produced as single use disposable.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kostesha2010development,
  author = {Natalie Kostesha and Tommy Sonne Alstrøm and Carsten Johnsen and K. A. Nilesen and Jan O. Jeppesen and Jan Larsen and Mogens Jakobsen and Anja Boisen},
  title = {{Development of the colorimetric sensor array for detection of explosives and volatile organic compounds in air}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1117/12.850310},
}
Figure