Development of custom measurement system for biomechanical evaluation of independent wheelchair transfers

Alicia M Koontz, Yen‐Sheng Lin, Padmaja Kankipati, Michael L. Boninger, Rory A. CooperThe Journal of Rehabilitation Research and Development 2011 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel, custom-built system for precisely measuring the biomechanics of wheelchair transfers, a crucial but understudied activity for individuals with spinal cord injury (SCI). The system captures both the forces exerted by the hands and the 3D motion of the trunk and upper limbs, demonstrating good reliability for future research into preventing upper-limb injuries.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Individuals with spinal cord injury (SCI) heavily rely on their upper limbs for daily activities, including transfers from their wheelchairs. These transfers are physically demanding and are associated with a high incidence of upper-limb pain and injury. Despite their importance, the biomechanics of wheelchair transfers are not well understood, with limited research focusing on synchronized kinetic and kinematic data. Existing measurement systems often fail to incorporate the user's own wheelchair, restrict transfer angles, or don't capture forces during hand grasps, limiting their ecological validity. This study aims to address these gaps by developing and validating a comprehensive system for evaluating the biomechanics of sitting-pivot wheelchair transfers.

Methods

The core of this research is a custom-designed measurement system that integrates several components:

  • 3D Motion Capture: A seven-camera Vicon motion capture system was used to record the 3D kinematics of the trunk, shoulder, and elbow. Anatomical landmarks on the body were tracked using passive markers.
  • Force Measurement: A custom load-sensing beam, adjustable in height and position, was integrated with a six-component load cell to measure forces exerted by the hand gripping the beam. This allowed for the measurement of forces during a realistic hand grasp.
  • Wheelchair Integration: The system was designed to incorporate the participant's own wheelchair, allowing for self-selected angles relative to the target surface, which enhances the ecological validity of the transfers.
  • Synchronized Data Collection: Kinetic and kinematic data were synchronized, with force data collected at 360 Hz and kinematic data at 60 Hz.
  • Transfer Setup: Participants performed a self-selected sitting-pivot transfer from their wheelchair to a height-adjustable tub bench. The wheelchair was secured at a 30° angle for nondisabled subjects, while SCI participants used their own self-selected angles.

The study focused on the "lift phase" of the transfer, defined by specific force plate readings. Reliability was assessed by comparing data from consecutive transfer trials.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from two groups of participants:

  • 5 individuals with spinal cord injury (SCI).
  • 12 nondisabled individuals.

No pre-existing datasets were used; the data was generated specifically for this study using the developed measurement system.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Realistic Transfer Simulation: The system's ability to incorporate the participant's own wheelchair and allow for self-selected transfer angles is a significant improvement over previous methods, making the captured data more representative of real-world transfers.
  • Force Measurement During Grasp: Measuring forces during a hand grasp on the custom beam is crucial for understanding the forces that contribute to upper-limb loading, a key factor in injury development.
  • Reliability is Key for Future Research: The study's focus on reliability is essential for establishing the validity of the system and ensuring that future interventions or studies can be based on consistent and trustworthy data.
  • SCI vs. Nondisabled Differences: While not the primary focus, the paper provides comparative data that can inform future studies on the biomechanical differences between these groups during transfers.

Key Results

  • High Reliability for Most Variables: A majority of the biomechanical variables (trunk, shoulder, and elbow kinematics, and most hand reaction forces) demonstrated moderate to excellent reliability (ICC > 0.6) when comparing transfer trials.
  • Specific Reliability Exceptions: The peak posterior-anterior hand reaction forces in the SCI group showed lower reliability, potentially due to balance deficits. Some shoulder variables in the nondisabled group also showed lower reliability, possibly due to task naivety.
  • Force Magnitudes: Large vertically directed forces ( > 29% body weight) were observed under both hands during transfers, with horizontal forces being considerably lower.
  • Minimum Trials Recommendation: The study recommends a minimum of five transfer trials to obtain a reliable measure of an individual's transfer technique.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Sample Size: The study had a small sample size, particularly for the SCI group (n=5), which limits the generalizability of the findings.
  • Foot Forces Not Measured: The initial system did not measure forces at the feet, which would provide a more complete picture of load distribution during transfers. The authors note that they have since integrated a third force plate to address this.
  • Grasp Point Estimation: While the custom beam allows for realistic grasps, precisely determining the point of force application can be challenging, requiring assumptions or marker-based estimations.
  • Nondisabled Subject Coaching: Nondisabled subjects were instructed not to use their legs, but the system lacked instrumentation to verify this adherence.

Future work could involve larger sample sizes, incorporating foot force measurements, and investigating the impact of different transfer surfaces and wheelchair orientations. The system's ability to measure forces during hand grasps also opens avenues for studying the effectiveness of assistive devices or transfer training programs.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study describes a new custom measurement system designed to investigate the biomechanics of sitting-pivot wheelchair transfers and assesses the reliability of selected biomechanical variables. Variables assessed include horizontal and vertical reaction forces underneath both hands and three-dimensional trunk, shoulder, and elbow range of motion. We examined the reliability of these measures between 5 consecutive transfer trials for 5 subjects with spinal cord injury and 12 nondisabled subjects while they performed a self-selected sitting pivot transfer from a wheelchair to a level bench. A majority of the biomechanical variables demonstrated moderate to excellent reliability (r > 0.6). The transfer measurement system recorded reliable and valid biomechanical data for future studies of sitting-pivot wheelchair transfers.We recommend a minimum of five transfer trials to obtain a reliable measure of transfer technique for future studies.
BibTeX
@article{koontz2011development,
  author = {Alicia M Koontz and Yen‐Sheng Lin and Padmaja Kankipati and Michael L. Boninger and Rory A. Cooper},
  title = {{Development of custom measurement system for biomechanical evaluation of independent wheelchair transfers}},
  journal = {The Journal of Rehabilitation Research and Development},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.1682/jrrd.2010.09.0169},
}
Figure