Development of Brain Network Connectivity in Risky Drinkers During Adolescence

Simon Baker, Murat Yücel, Alex Fornito, Andrew Zalesky, Sarah Whittle, Nicholas B. Allen, Dan I. LubmanmedRxiv 2020 · DOI

Introduction

Adolescence represents a pivotal "construction zone" for the human brain. During this period, white matter—the fatty insulation known as myelin that coats axonal fibers—undergoes significant maturation. This process is essential for improving neural processing speed and the integration of functionally specialized brain regions. However, this period of rapid development often coincides with the onset of alcohol consumption, raising concerns about the potential neurodevelopmental impact of "binge drinking" patterns.

While previous research has identified focal microstructural changes in specific brain regions associated with heavy alcohol use, these studies often fail to capture the broader picture. This study, originally published in medRxiv and later peer-reviewed, shifts the focus to the connectome: the comprehensive map of all inter-regional structural connections in the brain.

The Study: Tracking the Adolescent Connectome

Researchers utilized data from the Orygen Adolescent Development Study, a community-based longitudinal cohort in Melbourne, Australia. They tracked 39 participants across a critical developmental window, from approximately age 16.5 to 18.8.

The participants were divided into two groups:

  • Frequent Risky Drinkers (n=20): Individuals who engaged in 12 or more risky drinking episodes (defined as 5+ standard drinks in one sitting) in the year prior to the follow-up.
  • Comparison Group (n=19): Individuals who engaged in two or fewer risky drinking episodes during the same period.

To map the brain's architecture, the team employed Diffusion-Weighted Magnetic Resonance Imaging (dMRI) and High Angular Resolution Diffusion Imaging (HARDI). They generated "tractograms" consisting of one million streamlines per participant and analyzed the data using two different parcellation schemes (82-region and 530-region maps) to ensure the results were not biased by how brain regions were defined.

Key Findings: Resilience in the Face of Risk

The primary finding of the study was unexpected: there were no significant differences in the development of structural connectivity between the frequent risky drinkers and the comparison group.

This "null" result held true across five different scalar metrics used to quantify connectivity:

  • Streamline count: The number of modeled fiber pathways.
  • Fractional Anisotropy (FA): A measure of the directionality of water diffusion, often used as a proxy for white matter integrity.
  • Mean, Axial, and Radial Diffusivity (MD, AD, RD): Measures of the magnitude and direction of water diffusion within the tissue.

Even when the researchers relaxed the statistical threshold for the Network Based Statistic (NBS)—a method designed to identify clusters of interconnected edges while controlling for false positives—no significant group-by-time effects emerged.

Discussion: Potholes vs. Bridge Collapses

The authors suggest an insightful analogy to explain these findings: the "pothole vs. bridge collapse" model. Previous studies using voxel-based analysis have found microscopic "potholes" in the white matter of heavy drinkers. However, this connectome-wide study looked for "bridge collapses"—large-scale failures in the brain's highway system—and found none.

This suggests that while alcohol may cause focal, subtle damage, the brain's overall structural network appears relatively resilient to moderate-to-heavy community-level drinking during late adolescence. The "wiring" of the brain may be robust enough to withstand these insults, or perhaps the cumulative damage only becomes visible at a macroscopic level later in life, such as during "emerging adulthood" (ages 18–25) when drinking patterns often intensify.

Limitations and Future Directions

While the study is robust in its multi-metric approach, it does have limitations. The sample size (n=39) may have limited the statistical power to detect very subtle effects. Additionally, the "risky" drinking levels in this community sample might not reach the extremes seen in clinical populations with alcohol use disorders.

The two-year follow-up period is also relatively short. Future research should aim for longer-term longitudinal tracking to determine if focal microstructural changes eventually aggregate into systemic network disturbances as individuals move into their 20s.

Conclusion

This study provides a reassuring, yet cautious, perspective on adolescent brain development. While risky drinking is undoubtedly a health concern, it does not appear to cause a large-scale "re-wiring" of the brain's structural connectome between the ages of 16 and 18. Understanding the limits of this resilience will be crucial for developing targeted interventions for youth at risk of long-term neurological impact.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Alcohol consumption is common in adolescence, a time when the human brain undergoes substantial development, raising concerns about the neurodevelopmental impact of drinking alcohol, especially at high levels. Risky drinking may adversely affect the developing white matter, comprised of axonal fibre pathways that integrate anatomically distributed, and functionally specialised, neural systems. We used diffusion-weighted magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to perform the first prospective, comprehensive and regionally unbiased connectome-wide analysis of longitudinal changes in inter-regional structural connectivity between 16.5 and 18.8 years of age, comparing adolescents who reported frequent risky drinking ( n = 20) with those who reported limited risky drinking ( n = 19) across this developmental period. We found no difference in the development of structural connectivity between these groups, regardless of whether inter-regional connections were quantified using streamline count, fractional anisotropy, mean diffusivity, axial diffusivity, or radial diffusivity. These findings suggest that risky drinking may have limited adverse effects on the development of inter-regional structural connectivity during mid to late adolescence.
BibTeX
@misc{baker2020development,
  author = {Simon Baker and Murat Yücel and Alex Fornito and Andrew Zalesky and Sarah Whittle and Nicholas B. Allen and Dan I. Lubman},
  title = {{Development of Brain Network Connectivity in Risky Drinkers During Adolescence}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.10.22.20217992},
  howpublished = {medRxiv},
}
Figure