Abstract
Nowadays, optimum structural design techniques based on CSR have been developed and applied to the preliminary design stage focused on minimum weight and minimum construction cost of ship structure. Optimum structural design algorithm developed before could minimize weight and cost on fixed compartment arrangement. However, to develop more efficient design technique, a designer needs to combine optimized compartment arrangement with optimized ship structural design because compartment arrangement has a large effect on structural design according to the change of still water bending moment as a consequence of compartment arrangement change. In this study, automated algorithm for compartment arrangement of an oil tanker is developed to apply preliminary structural design. The usefulness of developed algorithm is verified with Aframax oil tanker constructed by STX shipbuilding Co.Ltd..
Introduction
In traditional naval architecture, the design process is largely sequential: the internal architecture—including tanks, engine rooms, and bulkheads—is established first, followed by the optimization of the steel structure. However, this approach treats the internal layout as a fixed constraint, overlooking the critical relationship between compartment arrangement and the "Still Water Bending Moment" (SWBM).
Suboptimal compartment layouts can force structural engineers to add significant steel weight to compensate for high bending moments. To achieve a true global optimum, it is necessary to integrate layout automation with structural design. This paper presents an automated algorithm for oil tanker compartment arrangement that allows for dynamic optimization of the ship's internal spaces in tandem with its structural requirements.
Methodology
The developed algorithm automates the compartment layout specifically for oil tankers while ensuring strict adherence to international maritime regulations. The process is divided into three primary functional areas: regulatory compliance, volume maximization, and software integration.
Regulatory Compliance and Automated Logic
The system automatically applies rules from MARPOL (pollution prevention), SOLAS (safety at sea), and CSR (Common Structural Rules). These rules dictate mandatory minimums for double-bottom heights, double-side widths, and the specific placement of collision bulkheads. The algorithm processes the ship in three distinct sections: the after body, the parallel middle body, and the fore body.
Optimization Strategy
- After Body: Focuses on the engine room configuration, including main engine location, peak tank bulkheads, and cooling water tank placement.
- Parallel Middle Body: Prioritizes the determination of ballast and cargo tank volumes. It iteratively modifies cargo tank lengths and web spacing to satisfy trim and stability requirements.
- Fore Body: Determines the collision bulkhead location and fore peak tank volume.
The system utilizes Ez-COMPART, a commercial ship calculation program, to verify volumes and hydrostatic properties in real-time. Once the layout is automated, the results are processed through a Pareto-based structural optimization system to balance the minimization of structural weight against construction costs.
Case Study: Aframax Oil Tanker
The algorithm's effectiveness was verified using a 115k DWT Aframax oil tanker designed by STX Offshore & Shipbuilding Co., Ltd. Initial verification involved re-creating the existing ship's layout; the algorithm achieved a near-perfect match with volume calculation differences of less than 0.2%.
Key Results
When comparing the algorithmically optimized "Design Ship" to the original vessel, significant improvements were observed:
- Cargo Capacity: Increased by 1.22%, representing approximately 1,355 tons of additional cargo per voyage.
- Structural Weight: Reduced by 361 tons (a 2.8% reduction).
- Construction Cost: Estimated savings of $400,000 per vessel.
- Efficiency: The optimized layout successfully lowered Still Water Bending Moments (both hogging and sagging), proving that intelligent bulkhead placement can reduce the need for heavy structural reinforcement.
Conclusion
This research demonstrates that integrating compartment layout automation with structural optimization creates a "win-win" scenario for ship owners and builders. By identifying regulatory "sweet spots" and reducing bending moments through layout adjustments, designers can simultaneously increase cargo capacity and decrease structural weight. Future work will focus on adapting this logic to other vessel types, such as LNG carriers and container ships, and further integrating these preliminary design tools into detailed production phases.
Summary updated