DEVELOPMENT OF AN OPTIMIZATION TOOL FOR WELL PLACEMENT OPTIMIZATION IN GEOLOGICAL CARBON DIOXIDE SEQUESTRATION BY METAHEURISTICS —SPEED-UP BY LEVERAGING PARALLEL COMPUTING TECHNIQUE—

Atsuhiro Miyagi, Hajime Yamamoto, Youhei AkimotoJournal of Japan Society of Civil Engineers Ser A2 (Applied Mechanics (AM)) 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Geological Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS) requires the strategic placement of deep injection wells to maximize $CO_2$ storage while maintaining reservoir integrity. This study develops a high-performance optimization tool combining the Covariance Matrix Adaptation Evolution Strategy (CMA-ES) with the TOUGH2-MP simulator. By implementing a two-level parallel computing approach on the Oakforest-PACS supercomputer, the researchers significantly reduced the computational time for finding optimal well configurations from months to weeks, demonstrating the feasibility of real-scale optimization in practical timeframes.

Introduction

Mitigating climate change through CCS involves injecting millions of tons of $CO_2$ into deep underground formations. A primary engineering challenge is determining the optimal placement of injection wells to maximize capacity and prevent excessive pressure buildup that could fracture rock or cause leaks. Traditional optimization methods are often computationally prohibitive due to the need for thousands of complex 3D fluid dynamics simulations. This research addresses the bottleneck of computational time by leveraging massive parallel computing and metaheuristic algorithms to automate and accelerate the design process.

Methods

The proposed tool utilizes a "double-layered" parallel computing architecture implemented on the Oakforest-PACS supercomputer:

  1. Optimization Algorithm (CMA-ES): The Covariance Matrix Adaptation Evolution Strategy was selected for its parameter-free nature and efficiency in exploring complex search spaces. It works by evolving a population of potential well layouts based on the performance of previous generations.
  2. Simulation Engine (TOUGH2-MP): To evaluate each layout, the tool uses a parallelized version of the industry-standard TOUGH2 simulator, which models the 3D flow of water and supercritical $CO_2$ in porous media.
  3. Two-Level Parallelism: The core innovation lies in parallelizing both the fluid simulations and the optimization process itself. By evaluating 20 different well-placement candidates simultaneously, with each simulation utilizing 64 CPU cores, the system utilizes 1,280 cores at once to explore the search space rapidly.
Flowchart of the CMA-ES based optimization process for well placement.

The study evaluated the tool using a realistic 3D reservoir model (8 km x 12 km x 0.15 km) featuring heterogeneous porosity and permeability based on actual seismic data.

Key Insights and Results

The optimization process demonstrated a dynamic search strategy. Initially, the algorithm explores a wide area (high variance) to identify potential regions of interest. As it identifies "sweet spots" with high permeability and low initial pressure, it narrows its focus to fine-tune the coordinates.

Visualization of the optimization progress across six iterations, showing the convergence of candidate solutions.

Performance and Capacity Gains

  • Massive Speedup: For a 3-well placement problem, the traditional approach (parallelizing only the simulation) would have taken roughly 105 days. The new two-level parallel approach completed the task in just 13 days.
  • Increased Efficiency: The optimized layout increased the total $CO_2$ injection amount by 10% compared to a manual "best guess" by an engineer.
  • Pressure Management: The tool highlighted that adding "pressure relief" wells to pump out brine can be more effective than simply adding more injection wells. In specific cases, this strategy increased $CO_2$ storage capacity by 30%.

Discussion and Conclusion

While the tool offers massive speedups, it currently necessitates access to supercomputing resources or large cloud clusters to be practical. Future work will focus on improving load balancing to ensure that CPU cores do not sit idle while waiting for the slowest simulations in a batch to finish. Despite these requirements, the development of this tool marks a significant step toward making large-scale CCS site design practical and efficient for real-world applications.

Reference: Miyagi, A., Yamamoto, H., & Akimoto, Y. (2021). Development of an Optimization Tool for Well Placement Optimization in Geological Carbon Dioxide Sequestration by Metaheuristics. Journal of JSCE A2 (Applied Mechanics), Vol. 77, No. 1, 21-34.

Summary updated

Abstract

二酸化炭素地中貯留では,大量のCO2を地中深部に圧入するために大深度坑井(深さ1km以上)を複数配置する必要がある.費用対効果に優れた坑井配置を設計するためにメタヒューリスティクスと言われる最適化手法と数値シミュレーションを組み合わせた最適化ツールの適用が試みられている.しかし,その実用化においては最適解探査に要する膨大な計算時間を短縮することが課題となっている.そこで今回,並列計算処理により最適解探査を大幅に高速化する手法を提案した.本研究で開発した最適化ツールを超並列計算機に実装してケーススタディーを行った結果,メタヒューリスティクスの一つであるCMA-ES(Covariance Matrix Adaptation Evolution Strategy)による実用規模の坑井配置探査を実用的な時間内で実行できることがわかった.
BibTeX
@article{miyagi2021development,
  author = {Atsuhiro Miyagi and Hajime Yamamoto and Youhei Akimoto},
  title = {{DEVELOPMENT OF AN OPTIMIZATION TOOL FOR WELL PLACEMENT OPTIMIZATION IN GEOLOGICAL CARBON DIOXIDE SEQUESTRATION BY METAHEURISTICS —SPEED-UP BY LEVERAGING PARALLEL COMPUTING TECHNIQUE—}},
  journal = {Journal of Japan Society of Civil Engineers Ser A2 (Applied Mechanics (AM))},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.2208/jscejam.77.1\_21},
}
Figure