Development of an endogenous promoter-driven CRISPR/Cas9 system for genome editing in <i>Fraxinus mandshurica</i>

Shangzhu Gao, Mingwen Zhao, Siyu Sun, Xing Fan, Jinyue Yan, Ying Xin, Yaguang Zhan, Fansuo ZengForestry 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a robust, species-specific CRISPR/Cas9 system for genome editing in Fraxinus mandshurica (Manchurian ash). By optimizing endogenous promoters, sgRNA design, and environmental conditions like temperature and light, they achieved significant editing efficiency, paving the way for faster trait improvement in this valuable timber species.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Fraxinus mandshurica is a highly valued timber species in China, crucial for national reforestation efforts and germplasm improvement due to its desirable traits and adaptability. However, traditional breeding methods for woody species are slow and challenging due to long generation times, large genomes, and high heterozygosity. While CRISPR/Cas9 has revolutionized genome editing in many plants, its application in recalcitrant woody species like F. mandshurica has been limited. Developing a precise, efficient, and species-specific genome editing system is essential to overcome these hurdles and accelerate the development of improved varieties for forestry.

Methods

The core of this work is the development and optimization of a CRISPR/Cas9 system tailored for F. mandshurica. Key methodological advancements include:

  • Endogenous Promoter Engineering: Instead of relying on promoters from other species (like Arabidopsis), the researchers identified and characterized endogenous promoters for both sgRNA (FmU6 variants) and Cas9 (FmECP3) expression. Truncated versions of FmU6 promoters (FmU6-6-4 and FmU6-7-4) were found to significantly boost sgRNA expression compared to the standard AtU6-26 promoter. Similarly, the FmECP3 promoter showed substantially higher Cas9 expression than the commonly used 35S promoter.
  • sgRNA Optimization: They screened multiple sgRNA sequences targeting the Phytoene desaturase (PDS) gene, a common target for observing albino phenotypes, and identified sgRNA4 as highly active.
  • Environmental Condition Optimization: The study investigated the impact of temperature and light quality on editing efficiency. A heat treatment of 37°C significantly enhanced Cas9 cleavage efficiency, and specific light quality combinations (red and blue light ratios) were found to improve regeneration rates.
  • Transformation Strategies: Both transient and stable transformation methods were employed. Transient transformation allowed for rapid gene function analysis and mutant generation, while stable transformation aimed for heritable edits.
  • Mutation Identification: Advanced sequencing techniques (Sanger, HI-TOM) were used to identify and characterize the types of mutations (insertions, deletions, substitutions) induced by the CRISPR/Cas9 system.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Power of Endogenous Promoters: This study strongly emphasizes that using species-specific endogenous promoters (FmU6 and FmECP3) is critical for achieving high expression levels of sgRNA and Cas9 in F. mandshurica, leading to significantly improved editing efficiency compared to heterologous promoters.
  • Synergistic Optimization is Key: The most impressive results were achieved not by optimizing a single component, but by combining optimized endogenous promoters, a well-chosen sgRNA, and carefully controlled environmental conditions (heat treatment and specific light regimes). This highlights the multi-faceted nature of successful genome editing in challenging plant species.
  • PDS as a Reliable Reporter: Targeting the PDS gene proved effective for demonstrating the system's functionality, as its disruption leads to a clear albino phenotype, allowing for easy visual identification of edited individuals.
  • Cross-Species Applicability: The identified endogenous promoters (FmU6 and FmECP3) also showed activity in other woody species like tobacco, birch, and poplar, suggesting their potential utility beyond F. mandshurica.

Key Results

  • Truncated FmU6 promoters (FmU6-6-4 and FmU6-7-4) drove sgRNA expression 3.36 and 3.11 times higher than the AtU6-26 promoter.
  • The endogenous FmECP3 promoter showed 5.48 times greater Cas9 activity than the positive control (35S promoter).
  • sgRNA4 targeting FmPDS1/2 achieved a cleavage efficiency of 36.10%.
  • Heat treatment at 37°C increased Cas9 cleavage efficiency by 7.77 times compared to 22°C.
  • An overall editing efficiency of 18.2% was achieved, resulting in chimeric albino mutants with reduced chlorophyll content (46.44%-58.88%).
  • Mutations included insertions, deletions, and substitutions, leading to premature termination codons.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Chimeric Mutants and Functional Redundancy: The study obtained chimeric mutants, indicating that FmPDS1 and FmPDS2 may have functional redundancy. A double mutant was not achieved, suggesting that simultaneous editing of both paralogs might inhibit adventitious shoot regeneration, preventing seedling formation.
  • Need for Double Mutants: Future work should focus on developing strategies to achieve double mutants for a more complete understanding of PDS gene function.
  • Tissue-Specific and Inducible Promoters: While endogenous constitutive promoters were effective, the authors suggest exploring tissue-specific and inducible promoters for more precise control over gene editing, especially for genes with complex expression patterns.
  • Codon-Optimized Cas9: The Cas9 protein used was codon-optimized for Arabidopsis. Applying F. mandshurica-specific codon-optimized Cas9 could further enhance mutation efficiency.
  • DNA-Free Editing: While transient transformation yielded chimeric mutants, the authors acknowledge the need for further development to achieve DNA-free editing strategies for generating transgene-free woody plants, which is important for regulatory reasons.

Summary updated

Abstract

CRISPR/Cas9-mediated genome editing has revolutionized tree improvement by enabling precise trait modification, accelerating breeding cycles, and enhancing forestry sustainability. <i>Fraxinus mandshurica</i>, valued for its desirable traits and adaptability, serves as a strategic focus for the National Reserve Forest Project (NRFP) and forestry germplasm resource breeding and quality improvement in China. Developing a species-specific genome editing system is crucial for valuable yet recalcitrant species like <i>F. mandshurica</i>. In this study, the development of a species-specific CRISPR/Cas9 platform is presented for <i>F. mandshurica</i>, which incorporates endogenous promoter engineering, sgRNA optimization, light quality modulation, and temperature control protocols to enhance genome editing efficiency. Truncated endogenous <i>FmU6</i> promoter variants (<i>FmU6-6-4</i> and <i>FmU6-7-4</i>) drove sgRNA expression at levels 3.36 and 3.11 times higher than that of the <i>AtU6-26</i> promoter. The expression of Cas9 was controlled by the endogenous constitutive <i>FmECP3</i> promoter, exhibiting an activity 5.48 times greater than the positive control. A highly active sgRNA4 targeting <i>FmPDS1/2</i> was identified, demonstrating a cleavage efficiency of 36.10%. Heat treatment at 37 °C effectively increased the Cas9 cleavage efficiency to 7.77 times that observed at 22 °C. Chimeric albino mutants with an editing efficiency of 18.2% were obtained through transient and stable transformations, combined with light quality optimization and heat treatment during different regeneration stages. The mutation types included nucleotide insertions, deletions, and substitutions, leading to early termination codons and truncated FmPDS1/2 protein. Additionally, mutations in <i>FmPDS1/2</i> resulted in albino phenotypes and a reduction in chlorophyll content to 46.44%-58.88%. This optimized system provides a robust platform for functional genomics studies and trait improvement in <i>F. mandshurica</i>, with potential applications in forestry biotechnology.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gao2025development,
  author = {Shangzhu Gao and Mingwen Zhao and Siyu Sun and Xing Fan and Jinyue Yan and Ying Xin and Yaguang Zhan and Fansuo Zeng},
  title = {{Development of an endogenous promoter-driven CRISPR/Cas9 system for genome editing in \&lt;i\&gt;Fraxinus mandshurica\&lt;/i\&gt;}},
  booktitle = {Forestry},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.48130/forres-0025-0016},
}
Figure