Development of a new compact and light velocity-based mechanical safety device for a rehabilitation assist suit

Yoshihiro Kai, Atsushi Kaneta, Keisuke Ikeda, Tsubasa Kaneda, Kenichi Sugawara, Masayoshi TomizukaJournal of Advanced Mechanical Design Systems and Manufacturing 2020 · DOI

Abstract: Safety is an important requirement in rehabilitation assist suits. We have developed a velocity-based mechanical safety device (VBMSD) for an assist suit to aid in the flexion and extension of a patient’s knee joint. The VBMSD stops the suit’s motor when the angular velocity of the knee joint matches or exceeds a preset threshold level, known as the “detection velocity level (DVL).” Since the VBMSD is composed only of passive mechanical elements such as a rotary damper, it works even when the suit’s computer has stopped working. This paper presents the design and development of a new compact and light VBMSD, reducing weight by nearly 80% to enhance portability. Design specifications were determined by considering ISO 13482 and AIST human body dimensions data to ensure the device does not protrude from the user's body. Experimental results confirm the device achieves the necessary safety functions with high-speed response.

Introduction: The Need for Hardware-Level Safety

Wearable rehabilitation suits (exoskeletons) are typically controlled by computers, but these systems are not infallible. If a suit’s motor suddenly accelerates due to a software crash or sensor failure, it can cause pain or serious injury to patients already suffering from neurological conditions.

While software-based safety exists, "hardware-level" safety is the gold standard for reliability. However, previous mechanical safety devices were bulky and heavy, creating snagging hazards or making the suit too cumbersome for practical use. The challenge was to create a device that is entirely passive, adjustable, and small enough to fit the contours of the human body.

The VBMSD Mechanism: A Passive Mechanical "Fuse"

The Velocity-Based Mechanical Safety Device (VBMSD) operates on a balance of mechanical forces rather than electronics. Its core mechanism relies on two primary components:

  • Rotary Damper: Generates a damping torque proportional to the joint's angular velocity.
  • Torsion Springs: Provide a restoring torque to keep the device in a neutral state.
The VBMSD mechanism uses a balance between damping torque and spring torque to trigger a power cut-off when velocity limits are exceeded.

When the joint velocity exceeds a preset "Detection Velocity Level" (DVL), the damping torque overcomes the spring torque. This causes a mechanical bar to rotate and physically strike a switch that cuts the motor's power. Because the device is purely mechanical, it remains functional even if the suit's battery dies or the CPU freezes.

Design for Portability and Human Integration

To shrink the device, the research team replaced bulky tension springs with compact torsion springs and utilized 3D printing (ABS plastic) for internal components. The design was strictly informed by anthropometric data from the Advanced Industrial Science and Technology (AIST) database. By using the knee depth of the smallest demographic (elderly Japanese females) as a constraint, the team ensured the device would not protrude from the leg, adhering to ISO 13482 safety standards.

Comparison between the previous bulky VBMSD (150mm x 140mm) and the new compact version integrated into the assist suit.

Key Results

The redesign achieved a massive reduction in the device's physical footprint and weight:

  • Weight Reduction: The mass dropped from 270g to just 59g—roughly the weight of a medium-sized egg.
  • Shrunken Footprint: Height was reduced from 150mm to 52mm, and width from 140mm to 50mm.
  • High-Speed Response: Simulations and experiments showed a time delay of only 0.023 seconds between exceeding the speed limit and the motor cutting out.
  • Accuracy: Experimental tests at various velocity levels (1.1 to 2.6 rad/s) showed the device triggered within 0.2 rad/s of the target, proving the reliability of the mathematical model.

Conclusion

The new VBMSD successfully balances high-level mechanical safety with the portability required for wearable devices. While future work will focus on refining the switch attachment to improve precision and conducting long-term durability testing, the current design is small enough to be adapted for ankle and wrist assist suits. This development represents a significant step toward safer, more practical rehabilitation robotics for daily clinical use.

Summary updated

Abstract

Safety is an important requirement in rehabilitation assist suits. We have developed a velocity-based mechanical safety device (VBMSD) for an assist suit to aid in the flexion and extension of a patient’s knee joint. The VBMSD is attached to the assist suit. The VBMSD stops the suit’s motor when the angular velocity of the knee joint matches or exceeds a preset threshold level. This level is called the “detection velocity level (DVL)” and it is adjustable based on the specification of each patient’s gait training. Since the VBMSD is composed only of passive mechanical elements such as a rotary damper, it works even when the suit’s computer has stopped working. In view that portability is equally important as safety in wearable assist devices, the size and the weight of the VBMSD must be reduced for practical use. This paper presents the design and development of a new compact and light VBMSD. First, we describe the problems in the previous VBMSD. Second, we present the requirements and design specifications in the new VBMSD. The requirements and design specifications in the new VBMSD’s size are determined by considering International Organization for Standardization (ISO) 13482 and Advanced Industrial Science and Technology (AIST) human body dimensions data. Third, we propose the structure and the mechanism of the new VBMSD. Fourth, we explain the design process of the new VBMSD. In the design process, the frequency response and the transient response of the new VBMSD are also considered. Fifth, experimental results to check whether the new VBMSD achieves the necessary function are presented. Lastly, the possibility of installing the new VBMSD to an ankle joint assist suit and a wrist joint assist suit is discussed using AIST human body dimensions data, etc.
BibTeX
@article{kai2020development,
  author = {Yoshihiro KAI and Atsushi KANETA and Keisuke Ikeda and Tsubasa Kaneda and Kenichi Sugawara and Masayoshi Tomizuka},
  title = {{Development of a new compact and light velocity-based mechanical safety device for a rehabilitation assist suit}},
  journal = {Journal of Advanced Mechanical Design Systems and Manufacturing},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1299/jamdsm.2020jamdsm0101},
}
Figure