Development of a Heavy Metal Sensing Boat for Automatic Analysis in Natural Waters Utilizing Anodic Stripping Voltammetry

Qiuyue Yang, Bhawna Nagar, Ruslán Álvarez-Diduk, Marc Pineda Balsells, Alessandro Farinelli, Domenico D. Bloisi, Lorenzo Proia, Carmen Espinosa, Marc Ordeix, Thorsten Knutz, Elisabetta De Vito-Francesco, Roza Allabashi, Arben MerkoçiACS 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed an autonomous boat equipped with a novel fluidic sensing system for real-time, on-site heavy metal detection in natural waters. This system utilizes square-wave anodic stripping voltammetry to identify and quantify lead (Pb), copper (Cu), and cadmium (Cd), offering a more efficient and cost-effective alternative to traditional lab-based methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Monitoring heavy metal (HM) pollution in natural waters is crucial for environmental and public health. Traditional methods involve manual water sampling followed by expensive, time-consuming laboratory analysis, which requires specialized personnel and equipment. While some on-site automatic sensing probes exist, they often suffer from limited portability, lack of automation, and high costs, hindering comprehensive spatial assessments. This paper addresses the need for a fully autonomous, portable, and cost-effective solution for real-time HM monitoring directly in natural water bodies.

Methods

The core of this work is the development of a Fluidic Sensing System (FSS) integrated into an autonomous sensing boat. The FSS is based on Square-Wave Anodic Stripping Voltammetry (SWASV), a technique that involves concentrating HM ions on an electrode surface, followed by reoxidation and current measurement.

Key methodological innovations include:

  • Integrated Fluidics: A microfluidic system was designed to handle sample collection, mixing with a supporting electrolyte, and delivery to the sensing electrode within a flow cell. This includes a peristaltic pump for sample and electrolyte transport, a mixing system to ensure homogeneity, and a degasser to remove air bubbles that could interfere with measurements.
  • Screen-Printed Electrodes (SPEs): Custom-fabricated screen-printed carbon electrodes were used as the working electrodes for SWASV. These are chosen for their inertness, robustness, and lower cost compared to other electrode types.
  • Autonomous Boat Platform: A commercially available autonomous surface vehicle was modified to integrate the FSS and its electronic control unit. This platform allows for programmable navigation, automatic sampling, and on-site data acquisition.
  • Electronic Control Unit: A Bluebox system, interfaced with an Arduino Due, manages the potentiostat, peristaltic pump, and communication. Data, including voltammograms and GPS coordinates, are stored in a database.
  • User Interface: A user-friendly graphical user interface (GUI) on a tablet allows for programming the boat's mission (path, speed, sampling times) and receiving real-time data and status updates. Web and mobile applications (WAQUIN, WASCO) provide remote access to HM information.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on laboratory calibration and field testing with real water samples.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging the Gap: The research successfully bridges the gap between laboratory-based HM analysis and the need for immediate, spatially resolved environmental data.
  • Autonomous Spatial Assessment: The autonomous boat enables systematic spatial mapping of HM pollution, revealing concentration gradients that would be difficult to capture with manual sampling.
  • Cost-Effectiveness: The use of SPEs and a compact FSS design contributes to a lower overall cost compared to traditional methods, making advanced monitoring more accessible.
  • Field Validation: The successful deployment in a real-world scenario (an abandoned mine effluent) demonstrates the practical applicability of the system, even with environmental challenges.
  • Interference Management: While challenges exist with mutual interference (e.g., Cd sensitivity reduction), the system shows promise in distinguishing HM signals in complex matrices.

Key Results

  • Laboratory Detection Limits: The FSS achieved the following detection limits (LODs) in laboratory settings: ≤1 µg/L for Pb, ≤6 µg/L for Cu, and ≤71 µg/L for Cd simultaneously.
  • Field Performance: The autonomous boat successfully distinguished a higher concentration of Pb in an effluent from a galena-enriched mine compared to other sites in the Osor Stream.
  • Linear Response: The FSS demonstrated good linear responses to varying concentrations of Cd, Pb, and Cu in both deionized and river water.
  • River Water Matrix: Impurities in river water had a minimal influence on the analytical performance, with similar LODs to those in deionized water.
  • Recovery Tests: Recovery rates for Cd, Pb, and Cu in spiked river water were high (109%, 113%, and 104%, respectively).
  • Repeatability and Stability: The SPEs showed acceptable repeatability (RSD < 20%) and stability within 2 hours of continuous measurements.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Cd Interference: The high LOD for Cd in simultaneous measurements, attributed to mutual interference with Pb and Cu, remains a challenge.
  • Navigation in Complex Environments: The autonomous boat's navigation routine was not fully optimized for highly dynamic environments like mine effluents, leading to increased power consumption and time to reach target points. This highlights the need for more intelligent navigation systems that can adapt to real-time environmental uncertainties.
  • Future Research: The authors suggest further research into optimizing navigation routines for challenging natural environments and improving the detection of HMs like Cd in the presence of interferents. They also note that a more detailed validation of the system in both indoor and outdoor settings is presented in a separate, submitted work.

Summary updated

Abstract

Determination of the levels of heavy metal ions would support assessment of sources and pathways of water pollution. However, traditional spatial assessment by manual sampling and off-site detection in the laboratory is expensive and time-consuming and requires trained personnel. Aiming to fill the gap between on-site automatic approaches and laboratory techniques, we developed an autonomous sensing boat for on-site heavy metal detection using square-wave anodic stripping voltammetry. A fluidic sensing system was developed to integrate into the boat as the critical sensing component and could detect ≤1 μg/L Pb, ≤6 μg/L Cu, and ≤71 μg/L Cd simultaneously in the laboratory. Once its integration was completed, the autonomous sensing boat was tested in the field, demonstrating its ability to distinguish the highest concentration of Pb in an effluent of a galena-enriched mine compared to those at other sites in the stream (Osor Stream, Girona, Spain).
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yang2021development,
  author = {Qiuyue Yang and Bhawna Nagar and Ruslán Álvarez-Diduk and Marc Pineda Balsells and Alessandro Farinelli and Domenico D. Bloisi and Lorenzo Proia and Carmen Espinosa and Marc Ordeix and Thorsten Knutz and Elisabetta De Vito-Francesco and Roza Allabashi and Arben Merkoçi},
  title = {{Development of a Heavy Metal Sensing Boat for Automatic Analysis in Natural Waters Utilizing Anodic Stripping Voltammetry}},
  booktitle = {ACS},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1021/acsestwater.1c00192},
}

Loading related content...

Figure