Development and validation of a prognostic model incorporating tumor thrombus grading for nonmetastatic clear cell renal cell carcinoma with tumor thrombus: A multicohort study

Le Qu, Hui Chen, Qi Chen, Silun Ge, Aimin Jiang, Nengwang Yu, Yulin Zhou, Michał Kunc, Ye Zhou, Xiang Feng, Wei Zhai, Zhenjie Wu, Miaoxia He, Yaoming Li, Rui Chen, Bo Han, Xing Zeng, Yao Fu, Changwei Ji, Fan Xiang, Guangyuan Zhang, Cheng Zhao, Taile Jing, Chenchen Feng, Hongwei Zhao, Sun D, Liang Wang, Sheng Tai, Cheng Zhang, Shaohao Chen, Yixun Liu, Haifeng Wang, Jinli Gao, Yufeng Gu, Tangliang Zhao, Xiaoming Yi, Chaopeng Tang, Dian Fu, Haowei He, Qiu Rao, Wenquan Zhou, Ning Xu, Gongxian Wang, Chang Yin Liang, Zhiyu Liu, Dan Xia, Xiongbing Zu, Ming Chen, Hongqian Guo, Weijun Qin, Zhe Wang, Wei Xue, Benkang Shi, Shaogang Wang, Junhua Zheng, Cheng Chen, Łukasz Zapała, Jingping Ge, Linhui WangMedComm 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study introduces a novel prognostic model, the Tumor Thrombus Grading Prognostic Score (TT-GPS), for nonmetastatic clear cell renal cell carcinoma (ccRCC) patients with venous tumor thrombus (VTT). By incorporating VTT pathological grading, which was previously overlooked, the TT-GPS score significantly improves risk stratification and prediction of patient survival compared to existing models.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Clear cell renal cell carcinoma (ccRCC) is a significant cancer, and a subset of patients develop venous tumor thrombus (VTT), where cancer cells extend into the venous system. While surgery is a primary treatment, the prognosis for these patients is highly variable, ranging from 37% to 71% 5-year survival. Existing prognostic models often generalize across all RCC patients or focus on limited VTT characteristics like height. This leaves a critical need for more accurate and specific risk stratification tools for ccRCC patients with VTT, especially considering the potential for VTT to be a source of metastasis.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Genomic Analysis: They performed multiregion whole-exome sequencing (WES) on normal tissue, primary tumor (PT), VTT, and metastasis samples from 33 ccRCC patients. This allowed them to investigate the evolutionary relationship between these components and identify the origin of metastases.
  • Retrospective Cohort Study: They gathered data from three independent cohorts (Training, China-Validation, and Poland-Validation) comprising a total of 706 nonmetastatic ccRCC patients with VTT.
  • Prognostic Model Development: Based on the findings from the genomic analysis and cohort studies, they developed a new prognostic model, the TT-GPS score. This model incorporates four key variables: VTT height, VTT pathological grading, perinephric fat invasion, and sarcomatoid differentiation in the primary tumor.
  • Model Validation: The TT-GPS score was validated against existing prognostic models (e.g., SSIGN, Leibovich, UISS) using c-index and AUC analyses across the independent cohorts.
  • Risk Stratification: The TT-GPS score was further categorized into low, intermediate, and high-risk groups to assess its clinical utility.

Datasets

  • Genomic Dataset: 33 ccRCC patients with matched normal-tumor-thrombus-metastasis quadruples were used for whole-exome sequencing.
  • Clinical Datasets: Three independent cohorts of nonmetastatic ccRCC patients with VTT were used for model development and validation:
  • Training cohort: 304 patients
    • China-Validation cohort: 320 patients
    • Poland-Validation cohort: 82 patients

Key Insights and Ideas

  • VTT as a Metastatic Reservoir: The genomic analysis strongly suggests that VTT is the primary source of metastasis in the majority of ccRCC patients (81.8%), rather than the primary tumor directly. This highlights VTT as a critical entity in understanding ccRCC progression.
  • Underappreciated Prognostic Value of VTT Grading: The study reveals that the pathological grading of VTT, which is often overlooked in routine pathology reports, is a significant and independent predictor of patient survival (both overall survival and disease-free survival).
  • TT-GPS Outperforms Existing Models: The newly developed TT-GPS score, by incorporating VTT grading, demonstrates superior discriminatory ability and prognostic accuracy compared to established models, even those specifically designed for VTT patients.
  • Simplicity and Clinical Utility: The TT-GPS score is based on readily available clinical and pathological features, making it simple to calculate and potentially easy to integrate into routine clinical practice.

Key Results

  • Metastasis Origin: 81.8% of metastases were found to be seeded by VTT.
  • VTT Grading Superiority: VTT grading showed significantly higher c-indices for predicting OS (e.g., 0.719 in the Poland-Validation cohort) compared to PT grading (0.694) and other variables.
  • TT-GPS Performance:
    • OS: c-indices ranged from 0.706 to 0.840 across cohorts.
  • DFS: c-indices ranged from 0.691 to 0.717 across cohorts.
  • The TT-GPS score consistently outperformed previously reported models in both c-index and AUC analyses.
  • Risk Stratification: The TT-GPS score effectively stratified patients into low, intermediate, and high-risk groups, with significant differences in median OS and DFS observed between these groups.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Retrospective Nature: The study is retrospective, which introduces potential biases in measurement and ascertainment.
  • Ethnic Representation: The validation cohorts were primarily from Asian populations. Additional validation in non-Asian populations is needed to confirm the findings.
  • Histology Specificity: The TT-GPS score is currently developed and validated for clear cell histology. Future work should aim to expand its applicability to other histological subtypes, such as papillary histology.
  • Further Validation: The authors mention that further validation of the TT-GPS score is underway in different ethnic populations.

Summary updated

Abstract

There is significant variability with respect to the prognosis of nonmetastatic clear cell renal cell carcinoma (ccRCC) patients with venous tumor thrombus (VTT). By applying multiregion whole-exome sequencing on normal-tumor-thrombus-metastasis quadruples from 33 ccRCC patients, we showed that metastases were mainly seeded by VTT (81.8%) rather than primary tumors (PTs). A total of 706 nonmetastatic ccRCC patients with VTT from three independent cohorts were included in this study. C-index analysis revealed that pathological grading of VTT outperformed other indicators in risk assessment (OS: 0.663 versus 0.501-0.610, 0.667 versus 0.544-0.651, and 0.719 versus 0.511-0.700 for Training, China-Validation, and Poland-Validation cohorts, respectively). We constructed a risk predicting model, TT-GPS score, based on four independent variables: VTT height, VTT grading, perinephric fat invasion, and sarcomatoid differentiation in PT. The TT-GPS score displayed better discriminatory ability (OS, c-index: 0.706-0.840, AUC: 0.788-0.874; DFS, c-index: 0.691-0.717, AUC: 0.771-0.789) than previously reported models in risk assessment. In conclusion, we identified for the first-time pathological grading of VTT as an unheeded prognostic factor. By incorporating VTT grading, the TT-GPS score is a promising prognostic tool in predicting the survival of nonmetastatic ccRCC patients with VTT.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{qu2023development,
  author = {Le Qu and Hui Chen and Qi Chen and Silun Ge and Aimin Jiang and Nengwang Yu and Yulin Zhou and Michał Kunc and Ye Zhou and Xiang Feng and Wei Zhai and Zhenjie Wu and Miaoxia He and Yaoming Li and Rui Chen and Bo Han and Xing Zeng and Yao Fu and Changwei Ji and Fan Xiang and Guangyuan Zhang and Cheng Zhao and Taile Jing and Chenchen Feng and Hongwei Zhao and Sun D and Liang Wang and Sheng Tai and Cheng Zhang and Shaohao Chen and Yixun Liu and Haifeng Wang and Jinli Gao and Yufeng Gu and Miao He and Tangliang Zhao and Xiaoming Yi and Chaopeng Tang and Dian Fu and Haowei He and Qiu Rao and Wenquan Zhou and Ning Xu and Gongxian Wang and Chang Yin Liang and Zhiyu Liu and Dan Xia and Xiongbing Zu and Ming Chen and Hongqian Guo and Weijun Qin and Zhe Wang and Wei Xue and Benkang Shi and Shaogang Wang and Junhua Zheng and Cheng Chen and Łukasz Zapała and Jingping Ge and Linhui Wang and Linhui Wang and Linhui Wang},
  title = {{Development and validation of a prognostic model incorporating tumor thrombus grading for nonmetastatic clear cell renal cell carcinoma with tumor thrombus: A multicohort study}},
  booktitle = {MedComm},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1002/mco2.300},
}
Figure